Wally's Pizza & Subs

If any of you are familiar with the concept of DiCarlos Pizza, this is a similar style of pizza. Wally's comes in square slices, sold by the slice. They start by cooking the crust and sauce, and then putting the cheese and toppings on after it's cooked, letting the steam slowly warm them. I will say, it's probably not for everyone, but I love this pizza so much! It's a thin style, chewy crust, a sweet sauce and a generous amount of cheese. You can order by the slice, order a 1/2 tray which is about 16 slices or a full tray. I may be a little partial because I grew up on this pizza and now I live out of state, but I always drop by when i'm in the area, and sometimes make a special trip there just for their pizza! Best pizza ever!

Always a stop in Cambridge on my way back home to WV. Great pizza and definitely get it topped with both pepperoni and sausage

Italian sub, no dressing, extra Mayo, extra banana peppers, lightly toasted. You're welcome.

Please dont eat here. Its just terrible. Waste of money. If you dont want food poisoning, the DONT eat here

Stopped in while traveling thinking this was a full-service restaurant. It isn't. There is no dining room nor is there a restroom for customers.My family ordered a couple of slices. They took a good 20 minutes to be ready. The cheese was unmelted and the crust a strange consistency. However, my wife liked the sweet sauce. I ordered a BLT sub which they forgot to make as part of the order. The bacon was in little crumbles versus slices which fell out of the sandwich. The bread was good though.I am frankly baffled by the positive reviews for this place. The pizza is unusual, but not in a good way. I have absolutely no desire to return here and would not recommend.

We always get Wally's 5 pizza but my goodness, their Italian sub!! I think I've found a new go to for an Italian sub. If you've never tried it, you will not be disappointed! Keep up the great work!

I ordered a late order for 10 pm pickup .well in advance... They called me 5 min before and asked if I was still coming and when.. I told them in 5 min... Our pizza was barley warm., Poorly made and did not taste good at all... Wally's used to be our fav. But we lived in byesville for 10 years and went to Tommy's. We will not make The mistake of ordering here again .. the pizza cost more and was a total disappointment and waste of money .. The closing workers were young and didn't seem to care about anything but closing up. They lost you business tonight

Their unique style of pizza is excellent. Matt and his crew do an excellent job. We travel 40 minutes away to pick it up.

The dough, cheese and toppings always undercooked,the sauce is terrible. The wings are absolutely disgusting. How can you ruin a simple pizza? Wallys...

Wally's has a unique style of pizza I have found nowhere else. The crust has the crunch of a thin pizza but is not thin. It's more like a pan pizza except it is not all bread or greasy like a regular deep dish. This perfect crust becomes the perfect vessel to bring all of the yumminess of the toppings to your mouth. Don't be afraid to order extra cheese. It will melt perfectly by the time you get that box home. If it makes it home.