Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery

We love tyler's pizza - ordered a pep and mushroom and a mushroom and onion. I'm a big dan of the sauce .They get busy on the weekends so plan ahead. Worth the wait!

I'm in Columbus unexpectedly on a leave of absence from work for 5 months. I live in NYC so, you know, pizza is a thing. But actually I found Tyler's because they turned up in my Google search for "apple pie near me." On my first trip, they'd sold out of their bakery items (it was near closing time on the day before Thanksgiving). We got a small Autumn Swoon pizza but vowed to come back for pastries. We smashed that pizza. The crust is perfect. Thick enough on the edges to get that full creamy bread taste, thin and sturdy enough in the center to bind with the other flavors and hold up to the heavy toppings. And the flavors are fresh and bold, with just the right layering of sauce and generous spread of cheese. When I went back for pastries, I had to put in a special order since they don't bake everything on their menu on all days. I ordered Blueberry Chocolate Chip Bars and an Apple Turnover. Meanwhile, I got a Stromboli for dinner, with pepperoni, sausage, and banana peppers. SMASHED. It was delicious, wood fired like the pizza, charred but not burnt. They were also giving out samples of the Walnut Crusted Cheesecake, which my daughter and I had been eyeing on their menu. OMG please order this. I ordered A WHOLE ONE which I can't wait to pick up this Friday. I also sampled the Russenzopf (walnut cinnamon bread), which was good but a little sweet for my preference and I'm not a fan of cinnamon. I've not been disappointed by ANYthing I've ordered here. The owners are a husband and wife team and they've been present every time I've gone in, and they are pleasant and personable and seem to enjoy seeing how pleased their customers are with their product. I'm a.new fan from afar and will be at Tyler's every time I come back home to Columbus to visit.

The pastries and the pizza were both great. The 1 and 2 star reviews on here are obviously from people that like red baron frozen pizzas. I will say we took it home and put it in the oven to warm up. It did make the crust crispier but overall the pizza is very solid and the pastries are Awsome. This is def a repeat pizza shop for us. .We have eaten pizza all over and this is one of the best in central ohio

The people in this restaurant are very sweet, genuine and good people. I get confused with the times of restaurants because I don't know if it is ok to go to them until they close or if you should not go if it closes in the hour, some places want you to but it is rude at others so I call and I ask first. The lady that answered was very nice and she helped me with everything, she said it was ok to put in the order. I got there but there was wasn't anyone so I was worried that I made a mistake and shouldn't have put it in but the lady and man there were very nice and said it was ok and that they were been busy before but just slowed down. (Again I hope it was not because I broke the rule if it is I am so sorry. I do wish that companies might put it on their things to say if it is ok or if it's not maybe leave it blank))). The lady gave me some things to sample for my family which was so nice of her too. They said that they will have the pizza on Thursday at JFK in Reynoldsburg during the market festival the pizza oven will be there (if you have your pizza cooked at a big chain store you are missing out to support your local businesses but also to have the goodness of fire oven! They will have that at JFK too along with the good baked treats). The restaurant is clean, nice and cozy. It is very welcoming and I love it. I wanted to leave a tip but she insisted I not but I know it is important to show your appreciation so I will leave a bigger one next time. I know this is not the best post but if in doubt go to this place they are lovely and kind people and the food is very very good (I am very picky especially when it come to pizza) if you like NY style pizza I will say you will like this definitely. This post is so long I'm sorry but I just wanted to tell you how great they are and you should come here!!!! Thank you again to the people I met there))(I drop cheese bread trying to carry it in but I will attach the pictures of the rest. We had cheese pizzas and she gave us samples of a chocolate pastry and a whole zucchini bread which are both delicious as well again I am probably the most picky person my family hates going to eat out with me. Come here everyone!!!

Firstly, it's adorable and tiny. You walk in and it smells of fresh pastries and pizza, there's beautiful loaves of bread on display, dough getting loved on and pizzas being slung in the brick ovens. Everybody was very nice and there were samples to try and let me tell you...one nibble of the chocolate croissant and it was love at first bite; flakey, warm and decadent so naturally I bought two. Just when I thought I found my one and only I tasted the cream cheese danish....boom my pastry soul mate was right before my eyes. No debate the best pastry I have ever eaten; creamy, light, rich and voluptuous so naturally I bought two. Now for the calzone and pizza I can lump them together since they are similar by design. The dough is absolutely spectacular! Charred, crisp and chewy, really reminded me of my trip to New Haven. Undercarriage is to die for; leaves a little black char on your fingers. Cartoon esq. cheese pull, peps were crispy, sauce was fresh and vibrant. Tighten up the middle a bit and it's a 9+. This is a drive an hour to try it spot easy. From a guy who's eaten pizza in Chicago, New Haven, New York and about 75% of places in central Ohio. Chocolate croissant-8.9, Cream cheese danish-9.4, calzone-8.6, pizza-8.8

A phenomenal place, I've referred them to others who love it as well. Every pizza we've had is extremely tasty, and the people are very nice too. This is my favorite pie in Columbus, we always enjoy the chance to get our family Tyler's pizza. Years later: still our favorite pizza, and we've jumped into the baked goods by mistake. We don't visit anymore without a few boxes and a bag. Muffins are delicious, cinnamon croissant roles are sensational, and the cheese danishes are a family favorite. The staff is always very friendly and attentive, and our orders always correct. We like to call ahead to ensure we can get one for the evening, they are popular for many reasons. Thank you for a phenomenal experience, Tyler's Pizzeria!

5 stars! Everything we have enjoyed from Tyler's over the years have been delicious. I miss them being in Gahanna, and now not being open more hours. Their pizza is amazing. I'm disappointed that I can't make pre orders anymore.

Amazing local place. A true hidden gem of Reynoldsburg. Everything here is amazing. In the years I have been coming I have never had a bad order. The pizza is tasty, the pastries are amazing, and always end up spending at least $20 here. 5 stars!

The employees were great and such a cute little take out place! I was extremely excited to try the pizza since I love wood fire. But... the pizza was SOAKED with grease. I understand pepperoni has a grease that releases but the whole pizza as you see was soaked. Just a few taps on the paper towel shows you how much. The pizza had a great flavor but I couldn't even hold it up since it was so wet with grease. I would like to give it another try but... nervous to spend the money again.They were kind enough to give me a refund. I felt bad but I just was very disappointed after searching yelp and looking at others pizza.

Excellent pizza and the bakery items were sooo yummy! They were very friendly and gave samples of the bakery items so you could make sure that you liked it before purchasing them which was really nice! Of course I ended up buying multiple bakery items and shared them with friends-they all loved them as well! They bake different items daily so order the bakery items ahead of time if you want certain items. Plus they sell out quickly! Overall excellent service and food with quality fresh toppings, homemade sourdough pizza crust, and the pizza is really cooked over a wood fire!