Toni's Family Trattoria

This has become our favorite "go to" spot. Everything we have ordered has been outstanding. A few favorites are the house salad with the blue cheese dressing, the roasted beet salad is nice sized and fresh tasting, the Spaghetti and Meatball (has sausage as well as a meat sauce), Chicken Parm and Calabrian Chili Campanelle. For pizza we like the Sweet and Spicy. I have never had room for dessert and always have to take home food. The desserts look really good. Great service and owner/manager is always present for dinner. Wine list is outstanding. This is good for a group of 4 or so. Very small and intimate. They do take reservations.

Food was excellent. I can't wait until I can go back and try something else from their kitchen. The service was great, and the wait was less than they originally quoted us, so a happy suprise. Would recommend reserving a table in advance so you don't have to wait as the restaurant is smaller so less seating.

We stopped by Toni's Family Trattoria after shopping at the Outlets. We had a great experience and absolutely enjoyed the service, food, and time! Our waitress was so wonderful and checked on us all night to see if we needed anything. We loved her! Our food was super delicious and tasty too! We started off with their special bruschetta of the night - it was divine! It had whipped ricotta and roasted tomatoes and was full of fall, savory flavor! My husband ordered a veggie pizza and thought that it was "incredible". He states that what really made the pizza was the "hand tossed dough and the fresh toppings". I ordered the rigatoni alla vodka. It was "incredible" as well! I loved everything about the dish! Our daughter ordered the buttered noodles and cleaned her plate for the first time, ever! She states that the buttered noodles were "nice and buttery"! For drinks, my husband had Bud Light and I had their Pinot Noir. Their Pinot Noir was super smooth - so smooth that I had two large pours. I highly, highly recommend Toni's Family Trattoria! Definitely stop by if you are ever in the area!

My girlfriends and I have come to Toni's several times now because it has the great Italian food! Toni's is in my top 3 of all Columbus! Located in the cute little town block of Galena, Toni's is a quaint restaurant that packs a big punch! Their Eggplant Parmesan is absolutely THE BEST I've ever had! They have great wine and beer selections, and I usually opt for the Chardonnay. Space is limited, so not sure how they could accommodate parties larger than 6. It's perfect for parties of 2-4. They have some bar seating also. We usually go on a Wednesday or Thursday and never have to wait. The staff is super friendly and service is excellent. The ONLY thing I wish is that they offered complimentary bread to share. They do offer a slice with some of their entrees, but you have to pay extra if your entree does not come with one or if you want extra. It's worth it, don't get me wrong, but this was a first for me for an Italian restaurant.I highly recommend you stop in and enjoy!

You can't go wrong at Toni's! Dine in or Takeout - the food is amazing and the service is top notch.

There was a wait next door so we decided to give this new place a try - what a lucky surprise! We started with the fried gnocchi calzone appetizer / it's more like an Italian crab Rangoon - really tasty! The spaghetti with meatballs and sausage was really good - the meatball is tender and homemade, and the sausage had a really nice flavor. The fettuccine Alfredo was a delicious homemade pasta with a creamy, smooth sauce, and we all had the fennel sausage pizza. Outstanding. The desserts looked good. we were too full to try it - next time, for sure. Our server Allie was awesome and so fun to talk to and the atmosphere is really nice. Also of note is the wine list - it is a labor of love for the owner, showcasing a lot of her favorites along with the prerequisite selections. Really surprising for a small local place to have such a robust wine list. For a restaurant that's only been open a few months, they really have their s&$t together early! Highly recommend! Go there now!

Food was okay, had spaghetti and meatballs. Sauce had good flavor but meatballs were dry. Service was alright. She was knowledgeable but didn't refill water, had to ask.

Toni's always has great food and service. It is one of our favorite local restaurants and I would highly recommend dining there.

Great atmosphere, great food and outstanding service from our server, Sara. Also great service from Connie at the bar. Can't say enough good things about this amazing little hidden gem.

Toni's was such an inviting atmosphere upon walking in, and felt like an authentic, family-owned Italian restaurant right off the bat. They were able to seat us within seconds even on a busy Saturday evening. The food was phenomenal, I've been to Italy and I would say this food tasted like one of the most authentic I've had in the US! Not outrageously pricey either. Great service too. My only complaint is that I had not heard about it sooner!