Large pepperoni pizza
Cheated on toppings again? What's happening to my favorite Tommy's
Outside
Best location
Half mushroom/onion half cheese. Always great.
Menu
All the pepperoni came right off
Can't ever get home without eating at least one piece in the car...
food, pizza
Menu back July 2022
Regular Italian Sub
Regular Italian Sub
pizza, food
Small supreme pizza
Cheese Garlic Bread with Cheese
pizza, food
pizza
sandwiches, food
sandwich, food, sandwiches
Chef Salad
Raw Chicken Chef Salad
menu
food, pizza
Vegetable Sub
Sandy W.
Aug 3, 2024
Very attentive service and delicious Italian Submarine sandwich! The ambience of this restaurant hasn't changed in years!! Our friend orders pizza so lunch was amazing!
Read More
Theresa G.
Jan 3, 2024
Danggg based on reviews, you either love or hate this place. I am disappointed in you, Columbus Yelpers! Tommy's Pizza is the campus pizza experience! Many moons ago, typically whilst intoxicated or hungover, I would eat Tommy's with coworkers. I moved back to Columbus and rolled in - still just as good as I remembered! It's not gourmet, it's your classic campus locally-owned pizza shop. No frills and delicious! Even sober ;)
Read More
RE C.
Feb 12, 2024
Loved the pizza it was phenomenal Krispy Krust with lots of toppings. Was up there for a basketball game at Ohio State and very close proximity to the arena. Not a big place but the food is outstanding, give it a try
Read More
Richard T.
Mar 22, 2024
The best pizza in town! Pricey but worth it, especially if you like it well done. The crust is unbeatable. Service is usually pretty efficient too.
Read More
Caitrin C.
Jul 20, 2023
Visiting Ohio and love the Midwest pizza- That cracker crust and cheese for days is what my pizza dreams are made of. All photos and many comments led me to believe that's what Tommy's was offering and I couldn't wait! I ordered online and walked from my hotel to pick it up. My cheese pizza had a few pepperoni on it-- which renders those piece inedible for us. The pizza, which had been sitting on a table in the restaurant, was congealed and had slid around the box enough to be smashed up on part. Staff were abrupt and neither friendly nor dismissive. The taste was mediocre. Quality was poor. And it all just felt really unattended to and like there's no care for the product they're feeding people.
Read More
I D.
May 23, 2024
I hate driving far to a place, picking up food, get home to find it overcooked and poor Quality. For a refund they expect me to drive another 45 minutes to get my $18+tip back in rush hour.. gas prices etc... and I grabbed it in my LUNCH BREAKMEMO, cook food like the customer is THERE, STOP BURNING IT, KNOWING IT IS MEDIOCRE and still giving to customer. Not okay. Will dispute with bank to save the trip.
Read More
Derek S.
Dec 14, 2024
I was visiting the hospital down the road and ordered pizzas for everyone. As it has been since my first visit in 1988, it was great. No one else had tried it before and they loved it. Only knock was the building does need some desperate updates. The service was great on my to go order.
Read More
Joe D.
Dec 6, 2024
I think Tommy's pizza snd Italian subs are the best in town. I wish they had inside dining open later i went there on a Friday at 9:25pm following an OSU hockey game. They were open only for takeout orders. All inside ding area were closed. They advertise being open to 10pm or 11pm. They should make it clear that the dining room closes much earlier.
Read More
Don E.
Nov 9, 2024
Went there today at 3 p.m. and the door was locked. Sign said they were open at 11. ???
Read More
Kharis T.
Oct 15, 2024
If I could rate this place 100 stars I wouldn't family and I LOVE Tommy's pizza it's amazing and the people are so sweet and the atmosphere is fantastic too. HIGHLY recommend Tommy's!
Read More