The Wall Street Pub & Grille

I'm a Seneca country transplant from Columbus area, so I don't have the sense of nostalgia for places like Jolly's that many have around here - which IMO is mediocre at best. So I was pleasantly surprised to accidentally discover Wall Street a few years ago. WOW! I've been many times and every single time it's delicious and, the staff is friendly and professional, and the atmosphere is rustic and warm.My personal favorite is the "War Pig" sandwich, and I hope they never get rid of it. The slaw (what I would call southern style slaw) is just... well, it's delicious.They also have some great beers on tap that rotate seasonally. Whenever I'm asked if I want to go out to eat, I ALWAYS suggest Wall Street first.Highly recommend.

Still good but for the integrity of my fine critic, i give it a 4/5. On my MAC scale I rate is a 7.6/10

went for a late lunch and when we walked in there was a table of 6 and the rest of the place was empty. we stood at the door waiting for one of the three employees at the counter to acknowledge us and that took about 7 minutes. Once seated we got our drinks and food fairly quickly. But we sat after eating for about 15 minutes before being checked on again. This whole time the only other customers was the table of 6. We enjoyed the food but it was nothing to write home about. Frozen burger patty but the bun was toasted nicely and we both got the tater tots and those were good too. The space was nice and the seating comfortable.

Great little place to grab a bite. Located on the Tiffin campus. VERY clean and cozy. I had the Turkey club wrap with tots. Was very good and had a LARGE amount of turkey. VERY filling. Wife had the Nashville hot chicken sandwich. She also said hers was good as well. Stating the chicken had a good crispy coating. Dont get to the Tiffin area much, but would stop again if passing through. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Lunch was right at $30.00

Second time here the first time I would have given rave reviews, this time not so much. Let's start with the service. The server only came over once even after our first order was an appetizer and I looked over at the server several times as all that the 5 servers were doing was standing at the kitchen serving window so we couldn't place our dinner orders until she brought the appetizer. The spinach artichoke dip was underwhelming with big pieces of artichoke and a paste like taste. My soup was too thick to be homemade. Overall lack of seasoning as well for both dishes. The metallic taste of a container isn't pleasant either.

Meatloaf sandwich was excellent, service was great, portions were some of the LARGEST I've ever seen!!

Could be better. Sometimes the staff acts like they don't care you've asked for something and then they give it to you like it's the WORST job in the world. I asked for extra napkins and they slammed it down on the table. Not like I asked for a kidney. If I ask for something, bring it to me unless you're out. And don't think about ordering the beer cheese soup because you'll get this dumb look on a waitress's face like they don't know what you're asking for. "I don't think we have that" but I can always check. But the one time, she just never came back to our table. The food is always good. Just the service is almost always shitty. But there are good days and bad days.

This place is one of my favorites in Tiffin. The food is tasty and the service is five stars. The ambiance is pleasant and inviting. The fish and chips is one of my go-to's at this well-known establishment.

The meatloaf sandwich was a taste sensation. Bacon jam was delicious and the sandwich was filling.The thick cut sweet potato fries with the cinnamon butter made it even better.I had it to go but the atmosphere was nice and hopefully I'll get a chance to sit down the next time.

Yelp Roulette for another big win! Tiffin University, The Wall Street Pub and Grille. Excellent food, and they do flights for wine and beer. I choose the first 4 wines from the list. That was an excellent sweet flight. They were at least 4-5 oz each. $10 for the flight. I had the portobello sandwich with tots (mushroom with spinach, sun roasted red pepper and cheese with aoli, and Brad had the BBQ burger. His had pulled bbq pork, aoli and pickles. Both were delicious. Highly recommend. We will be going back sometime.