The Other Guy Pizza

Fantastic food. Absolutely the best pizza I've had....,ever. Generous toppings, all super fresh. We also got an Italian sub....outstanding. Again perhaps the best sub I've had for years and years. Since it was Friday we got 2 cannolis to go. They are to die for! Prices are unbelievably reasonable. The owner, Rocco, absolutely loves running the place. You can tell when an owner puts his heart and soul into his restaurant, the result is astounding. If you're in the Sunbury area this is a must stop! Tell them a very satisfied customer referred you......and get a cannoli if it's Friday or Saturday and they have any left . Cai

OMG!!!!! Really!! Me and my fiancé each got a 10', she got the Margarita and I got the Meat lovers......can I just say AMAZING!!! Best pizza I've had in ...I can't even remember! The dough is soooo good, but the toppings are wonderful!!! Don't let the exterior of the building turn you away, this is old school down home American made! The owner Rocco is the man!! Will be back, a LOT!!

If you live in the area, this should be your go to spot. Really like the style of pizza. Have not had a bad one yet. My wife loves the subs. She has mobility issues and the owners would always bring hers to the car when I was out of town so she would not have to unload her walker and go inside. Family owned local business with great quality and service. Easy to love this place.

Yum! We stopped in on a Friday night to this place on a whim and we are sure glad we did! The place has a few tables for seating and has a convenience store vibe (they also sell beer and wine). We ordered a pizza with half pepperoni/ half meatball and both sides were great. We added a sausage sub that was delicious and the garlic knots for an appetizer that were great little bite size knots of awesomeness. Also, the guy that owns the place seems to be a fun guy and extra votes for him cause he's a veteran! Highly recommend!

Best damn pizza in Sunbury, New Albany, Johnstown, or Delaware. Best pizza I've had in years.

I honestly was not impressed at all... the pizza was ok. The cheese/garlic bread was nothing special. The saving grace is the home made cannoli's... those were awesome. They are worth getting. Their pizza game is weak but their cannoli game is very strong.

I have heard good things about this place so we decided to give it a try and it did not disappoint. We ordered a large pizza and garlic bread with cheese and I told him this was our first time there and he threw in garlic knots. Everything was amazing! The sauce flavor and sauce amount were perfect the toppings were good quality and the crust was crispy but not too crispy. I drove 10 minutes to pick up the pizza but I would have driven farther for this pizza. It is a must try!

Hoping to bump this up to a 4 star tonight. Service has always been great, and good beer selection. We'll see what happens tonight!

Good pizza and meatball subs. Owner is very friendly. Has a large selection of take out beers.

The pizza and subs are good and I definitely recommend going on Friday to get a few cannolis they are so good and they go quick so get there early