The Original Goodie Shop

this place is so cute. I went here with family and they loved the cookies with all the little designs. the service was good and The employees are doing a great job. they are really kind and we need more people like that!! It is also helpful because they made a bunch of cookies for a event and the cookies were an immediate hit!

Okay first off, wow a donut for $2!! This bakery is no frills and sells you basic but good treats. I love glazed donuts, especially frosted ones. I ordered an original glazed donuts with chocolate frosting. For the price it was wonderful, tasty and fresh. Honestly 5 stars and I'd go back for another! I also ordered butter cookie Christmas wreaths, a chocolate chip cookie and a dog biscuit. Everything has been good and my dog loved his biscuit. As for service it was good. I got offered a free cinnamon stick which I thought was really kind of them to do. Though it wasn't my favorite, I'm not a fan of chewy dense treats, I still enjoyed the flavor of it. I mentioned it was my first time, and that's why I think they offered me the free treat. My only recommendation is if someone is new, make sure to say you have cookies on the other side. I had already ordered my treats and wish someone said they had even more cookies. I would have bought one of their frosted cookies if the lady wasn't already ringing me up at the registerOverall I had a great experience and will be back when I'm in the area.

I'm pretty much always here for an Upper Arlington shop that shows up and shows out for Pride events. Also the cookies are delicious and beautiful.

I read that The Original Goodie Shop came in 1st and 2nd in a local donut fest, so that prompted me to drop in on a Saturday morning. To their credit, the donuts were the best of the assorted sweets that I tried. The cream filled vanilla long john was 5 stars. The cake donut was maybe a 4. The lemon bar was a 3.5. The Brownie was a 3. The cookie was a 2. After my trip, I was told that they are known for their cinnamon sticks. I think if you stick with those and the donuts, you'll be in good shape.

Great king cake. Service is excellent. It's a very very small bakery. It's not sexy but the service and king cakes are good. If it's 5 customers inside it will be packed . The good thing is they are expanding.

My family has been going here for literally my whole life (over 60 years). I stopped by today and my sister and I both bought decorated cookies. I bought some that were small and perfect for a tea, or in my case, just a small bit of sweetness for a light dessert. The "multicolor corn" cookies were perfect for fall and glad they had "buckeyes also".

Would have given 2 stars but I really do love their donuts so I went with 3. This an update to my previous review based on my most recent visit. Called one afternoon to order 3 dozen donuts for the next morning to bring to work. I had looked at the menu online to have a better idea of what to order, but the employee asked a lot of clarifying Qs to ensure she wrote down the order correctly. I was so grateful for her help because I ended up ordering stuff that I had wanted but didn't see on the menu (like sprinkled donuts). I asked her what I'd expect for the price and was quoted $65 since they "have a deal on Wednesdays" which was the day I'd be picking up donuts. I didn't ask what that deal was, but was happy about it since pricing with the deal seemed on par with pricing from other bakeries that sell donuts (Buckeye Donuts and Lil Donut Factory). Come Wednesday morning, my donuts are all ready to go and I'm ready to pay so I ask what the "deal" was that the other employee referred to out of curiosity. This employee looked confused and said he didn't know so he asked the other employee who also didn't know. Then he proceeded to ring up each donut individually which took some time considering I ordered 36 donuts. Why was my check not prepared at the time of ordering esp if I placed the order ahead of time? When he finished, they were charging me $80 instead of the quoted $65 so I had to pause and re-ask about that deal the previous employee mentioned.I told them the lady I spoke with the previous day said it was a deal since I was ordering on a Wednesday...and that seemed to click with one of them at least because she mumbled they can honor the pricing. A 3rd employee overheard this and said my order didn't qualify because I picked out the donuts. Apparently the deal runs Mon-Thurs where you get a discount (said discount was not specified) on a dozen or half dozen donuts if the customer lets them pick the donuts. He also said this isn't a deal that they necessarily advertise. That statement really rubbed me the wrong way because of the sneaky practices in trying to make customers pay more instead of trying to win over their loyalty. They did not honor the pricing I was quoted, which was a BAD MOVE. They lost a loyal customer over $15 and some weird statements making the customer feel awkward...how foolish. My husband was annoyed at the principle of everything and for how long that whole process took on a weekday before work since we didn't anticipate having each individual donut rung up at pick up. With the lack of good customer service, he insists we never go back. My heart is sad because I love their donuts so I'm not saying I'll never go back...but it'll be a long time before I do. It's a damn shame because I'm pregnant and literally all I want right now is donuts and this is the closest donut shop to my house.

I called and ordered a couple days earlier since I wasn't sure how busy they get. I came to pick up my order on a Friday at 10:30.I got paczki, but these were likely just jelly-filled donuts. Not quite the same texture but close! We got 3 of them: lemon, raspberry, and cherry. It was still very good. Nice and light!It's a small place located in a shopping strip. The parking lot is large and has tons of spots.I saw others come to pick up their orders too.One of the staff members seemed to be offering a baked good for free. Unfortunately, I got a different staff member to help me so I didn't get that same offer...not sure why. They did have some really tasty looking cupcakes so I might come back to try those.

A cute little shop full of goodies tucked back in a section of the Tremont Center. Let me start by saying I love donuts. I love them so much it is a problem, so I only allow myself to have them a few times per year. I was really excited after hearing about this place. Staff was efficient and friendly. Pretty good selection at 8:30 am on a weekday. The donuts were just ok. Bought half dozen cake donuts and they were pretty dry and a bit stale tasting. The frosted cookies looked beautiful, so I will give it another shot the next time I need a sweets run.

Absolutely amazing service and quality!!!!! I came to this bakery for a last minute cake needed for my best friend's birthday after original plans got cancelled and they were so sweet and could get it done in less than 24 hours. The cake came out gorgeous and absolutely delicious