The Meatball Mafia

Pizza absolutely slaps. Has great substance to it. Many different flavorful topping options. Thicc in all the right places. Right amount of grease. Money.

Big fat Antnee is one of THE best pizzas I've ever eaten! I ordered 2 for our football weekend. These yinzers need Youngstown specials. So gooood!!!!

Very friendly staff. The Good Soul Sausage Sub is amazing. If I was a local I would be a regular for this sub alone. Now the pizzas are a little pricey for the size and my honest opinion just ok taste wise. Inside the market with a brewery and plenty of options to go along with the amazing sub.

We have been to this location quite a bit but finally getting around to reviewing. What drew me in this time was the pickle pizza. And I had to add bacon of course. It wasn't the best pickle pizza I've had in the city but very good! Probably number 2 haha. The sauce is super creamy with that garlicky flavor that goes well with the pickles and bacon. The slices are pretty loaded as well so I ate off this for a day or 2.

Great pizza with the perfect amount of toppings! The staff is friendly, and the pizza comes out in a reasonable amount of time.Crooked Can, where this is located, is a great place to go as a group or an individual. They also have live music.

Boyfriend and I ordered an Uncle Junior meatball sub. It was such a wet sub, you need knife and fork since you could not pick it up. The sauce was not very flavorful and the meatball did not look appetizing. (See photo) I took two bites and gave up on it. I don't think we will try them again.

Visited for the first time and ordered the Nicky Santoro - 3 handmade beef meatballs, hot giardiniera, provolone and mozzarella cheese, in an Italian torpedo roll. Meatball was a good, solid meatball. Bread was soft and tasty. Sauce was REALLY good. Giardiniera was very spicy but in a good way. Overall, a great meatball sub! Gonna try the pizza next time!

The pizza here is amazinggggg. Crust is light and airy even though it's a pan pizza. The sauce is delicious and not overwhelming at all. Cheese is great quality. 10/10 recommend!!

My first trip to Center Street Market was for the reviews of Meatball Mafia.Service was fast and friendly. I had the StandUp Guy because I thought it wouldn't be very heavy. It was incredible. And thick. I couldn't finish the 12" pie.The drink options are fairly limited to canned drinks and bottled water. Keep in mind that indoor seating is limited and parking may be limited depending on when you are there.

Nice Youngstown, OH vibe located in the Old Hilliard Crooked Can complex. The pizza is very good! We had the Sloppy Giuseppe, & it was worth it. All pizzas are 12", pan style & pie cut. The flavor & the crust was excellent. Definitely worth a visit for that. On the other hand, they DO sell bowls of pasta, too, which are a bit expensive. We had 2) different bowls of pasta and/or meatballs that were roughly 8 & 10oz.'s & it was $25. Really. The pizza was less than that, & way better tasting. More to eat, too. If you visit them sometime, try the pizza. You won't be disappointed. As for the other items on the small menu, you may want to skip them as the prices are pretty steep for what you get. They're good, not great, but nice for something new.