The Elm's Pizza Parlor

I've lived in the Granville/Newark area almost my entire life and dream about Elm's pizza. I always order for pickup at a certain time and it is always ready. Friendly folks too! I figured out from the old pics on the wall that my great grandmother, Ethel Williams Heddleson was Hudson Williams sister (he had the car dealership at the location before the pizza business was started by family members). Small world!

Gonna give them three stars right now.Called for delivery tonight on May 18, 2022. We live in Granville and they have no idea about the new neighborhoods being built. Apparently 5 miles is too far for delivery for them. So instead of finding out if I want to pick up my food the less than sociable gentleman I spoke to on the phone hung up the phone on me.Place looks like a great hole in the wall pizza joint, so we will eventually give them a chance, however first impressions aren't the best. And if you say that you live in Granville your entire life maybe you should get outside and start seeing that your town's expanding.I'd rather buy pizza from a local joint than a national chain. You're losing business if you don't know that people are moving into town and expanding your delivery area. 5 miles is not that far away for people to deliver by car.Three stars for the lack of effort. Hoping I can revise my review in the future and give them five stars. Again first impressions mean a lot so this is not gonna be one of the first places I rushed to for dinner.

Underrated. This is easily a 4 star on the verge of a 5 star rating. Located in downtown Granville. Food is constantly satisfying and excellent. Central Ohio is full of so many quality restaurants serving pizza, Elm's Pizza Parlor stands out. I visited Thursday, May 6. I had the medium pepperoni and cheese (pictured). Excellent flavor. Crispy thin crust. Great sauce. Generous pepperoni. Not greasy. My mom got the Gluten Free pizza and commented how much she liked it. Dinning room was clean and lots of room for guests. I love this place and always make a visit whenever I'm in Ohio.

We ordered three larger pizzas with 2 toppings each. The sauce was thick and rich on all the pizzas, the best part was that it went to the edges! The crust was a nice hand toss. The toppings combinations we had were pepperoni and banana peppers, sausage and ham, and sausage pepperoni. I liked them all and couldn't pick a favorite, but sausage and banana peppers will be my next combination.

Elms is our go to in Granville. Always open standard hours, staff is friendly yet older & professional, the pizza and Stromboli are delicious. Fresh crust and ingredients every time. We have never had a bad experience here and come at least 1x per week.

The stromboli is pretty tasty, order that if you are considering eating food from here. So many people say this place has the best pizza but I can't figure out why. I'm guessing it's because they grew up with it or some other type of connection because frankly the pizza is not that good. In trying to figure out what I don't like about this pizza I've pretty much determined that there's nothing about it that I like. Don't like the cheese, sauce, greasy limp pepperonis, the seasoning on top, or the boring tasting cracker crust. None of it works. If I was limited to ordering pizza in the village I would definitely order from one of the other two places in town. But this is just my personal preference. You may love it. Minus one star for the crap attitude the employees always seem to have, for charging for refills, and for the employee that parks their monster truck out front and half in the street.

Super friendly staff and pizza is great! Be sure to have cash if you order delivery bc there isn't a tip option for credit card on deliveries.

The food wasn't ready for pickup at the time i was told. The employees were friendly, well the cashier was, the others were busy talking amongst themselves about current events. The pizza is just barely ok. Tasted like a cheap frozen pizza to be honest. The sub was just ok too - not over packed with meat or a decent size. I probably wont go back and have had better frozen pies quite honestly.

We were traveling from Cincinnati to north eastern Ohio when we decided to stop for dinner. This place caught our eye so we decided to give it a chance. What a delightful surprise we found in this sweet mom & pop pizza parlor. Friendly people, great food and clean bathrooms!! My husband ordered the homemade lasagna which was nice and saucy(nice flavor of sauce) and a nice portion; came with 2 slices of garlic toast and had a nice fennel flavor that was not too over powering. I had the small chef salad that was plentiful with mozzarella cheese and ham - a little pricey for the size of the salad in my option but very good and came with a packet of Marzetti's dressing. I also had the Philly cheesesteak sandwich/sub which was soooooo good!!! Nice real steak and cheese with peppers, onions and mushrooms; the sub bun was GREAT! We will return here and recommend this place!

Great family owned business Service is friendly and fastStromboli is fantastic Thin crispy pizza