This is the amazing 'The House' pizza. It has coleslaw and pulled pork. The crust is the very light and soft.
Pepperoni and mushrooms
Entrance
ramen and noodles, outside
Deluxe pizza
Pizza
sushi and sashimi
S'mores bubble waffle, fabulous even via delivery.
Caprese
The House Pizza - BBQ base, mozzarella, pulled pork, topped with cilantro coleslaw & sriracha ranch.
On the right side there is The entrance with seating and napkins.
The House pizza
Peanut butter chocolate bubble waffle.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Italian Sub
Whipped and Berries Bubble Waffle
Cannolis
Phenomenal pepperoni pizza via delivery.
Peanut butter!!
This is the whipped and berry bubble waffle. It was so balanced, not too sweet that it had layers of flavor.
This is the bubble waffle with peanut butter and chocolate. It was amazing. The warm waffle with ice cream was a perfect blend.
Locally sourced ingredients.
Plates Bubble Waffle!
Gina D.
Feb 8, 2025
Really great pizza! Made exactly as we requested. The ingredients were super fresh. Very nice person took our order we called in and picked up, super friendly. Give them a try!
Read More
Tracee P.
Sep 16, 2024
On our trip the first place we stopped was The Colorful Cookery. We had one slice to see if we all would like it. Definitely order a whole pizza! We also had a side salad that was delicious. The service was quick and the crust on the pizza was delicious.
Read More
Keith H.
Nov 25, 2023
Don't sleep on this hidden gem in the heart of Berlin. The Colorful Cookery has amazing pizza. We ordered their House Pizza this time and it was absolutely delicious.Fantastic customer service and reasonable prices.
Read More
Sharon H.
Jul 17, 2023
You have to be looking for this place to find it! It does not sit on the main drag but rather sits in a walkway between buildings. There is signage on sidewalk that will direct folks to the door. It is basically a counter to place your order and a drink fridge. There are 2 tables right outside the door. The menu consists of mainly pizza with specialty pizzas as well as lots of toppings to design your own. We had a specialty pizza that was basically a deluxe. It was delicious with lots of toppings. Nice airy crust with flavorful sauce. Great place to grab something other than Amish style food.
Read More
Mariana A.
Dec 9, 2023
Amazing pizza! Very nice small place. Great service! Cannolis were sooooooo good!!!!! 100% recommended!
Read More
Abigail H.
Jul 15, 2024
This place is so tasty! The sausage was delicious and the vegan cheese tasted like real cheese. I loved all of their allergy friendly options. The place was cute and the workers were super nice. Definitely make sure you try their garlic sauce. This is the best place to stop for a quick bite after shopping nearby.
Read More
Bridget B.
Dec 13, 2022
All I can say is that this pizza is delicious. I come up once a year to Amish country to shop and stay. I have gotten their pizza each time, and it has been delicious every time. Lots of great flavor, and I definitely recommend picking up a pizza from here if you're in the area. I make it a point. There is no dine in, but we always take it back to wherever we are staying and have it for dinner. I'm so happy I stumbled upon this little spot.
Read More
Nicholas N.
Mar 20, 2021
Wonderful friendly service by Heather! We got the Stromboli and The House. Amazing flavors. The Stromboli was my wife's favorite. The House is spicy.Pizza by the slice for lunch or order a pie. The bubble waffle was amazing! This is definitely going to be our favorite treat this summer.
Read More
D L.
Aug 31, 2024
This was our first time trying The Colorful Cookery and it exceeded our expectations! The best BBQ Chicken Pizza I have ever had. My husband had the Italian sub and not only was it delicious it was huge! We also got the cannolis for dessert! This is a must try place when you are in Berlin.
Read More
Julie W.
Mar 4, 2024
Great addition to Berlin Ohio. The hand tossed crust is delicious and you must get a cannoli or two!
Read More
Rated: 4.2 (20 reviews) · $
American, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Sandwiches