The Bexley Coffee Shop

I visited on a Friday morning in November 2024, the day after Thanksgiving. We popped in real quick to get some teas to go.I ordered a green tea, my niece got a herbal tea, and my sister-in-law also ordered a herbal tea. The teas are from the Harney & Sons tea brand ($3.45 each). The green tea that I got with honey tasted fine. I believe that I got a citrus/flower blend but I can't remember the exact name of the green tea. My cup was a medium size cup and it was slightly expensive. I also ordered a blueberry cake ($2) which tasted good (it could have been fresher). It was a large piece too which is always generous to get.The owner was pleasant to talk with and she sadly mentioned the problems she had had with keeping staff (finding people to work there). Nonetheless, even with the little interaction, she seemed nice.I don't visit that part of town often neither do I live in Columbus but if you're in the area, feel free to support this local business.****GOAL of 150 reviews in 2024- 118/150 total reviews in 2024- 767 total overall Yelp reviews- Reviewed on 5 December 2024

Can't believe we have not been here on our Coffee Trail adventures. Stopped in on International Woman's Day ... so glad we did!! The coffee bomb was amazing! Thunderkiss coffee. My Favorite. Go support !!!

It pains me to leave a negative review for a local small business but here we go-- Hours are incorrect on yelp, even though they were just updated. They close promptly at 1130a. Showed up at 1132a on Wednesday to the employee at the shop watering the plants. I noticed the hours changed sign in the window and the employee on duty sneaked back in and locked the door in my face. No conversation. I was literally going to buy a cold brew with cash-- easiest transaction in the coffee game... but no, they didn't want the business. So weird for a business to not want business... They're also closed on Sundays which is disappointing. My last 3 times attempting to there the shop has been closed. This was definitely my last attempt.

THIS IS IT!!!! this is the cafe you need to visit! firstly, i want to say thank you to the owner(?) and barista. Im having a hard time but when I came in i was greeted with such warmth and kindness and some laughs and just comfort.So thank you.This cafe is a VERY cozy warm environment. I felt so at peace here after everything. this was a place i could drink my little hot chocolate and rest and decompress before my flight home. I felt very welcome and it was CLEAN!The food and drink was also amazing, i got this little caramel apple walnut cake and wowwowowow... it's everything i was expecting and MORE! mmmm i wish i could take some home seriously. This shop also has a wonderful tea menu lots of variety and they even have a fall menu out right now with so many fun drinks!so overall 10/10 immaculate vibes, food, drink, and people here. Thank you for your kindness and warmth once again. when i come back i will 100% visit again.

When I first enrolled in classes near by, I was alarmed because it seemed there was a severe lack of coffee near by. I don't know why this coffee shop didn't pop up when I initially searched, but I'm really glad someone recommended this spot. It's proximity is a huge plus but the quick service and great drinks are what keep me coming back. The basic menu is just that, pretty basic. Hot, iced, and frozen drinks. Smoothies, a few pastries. So far I've only experienced the fall seasonal menu, but I really enjoy the mix of classic fall options and a few more interesting flavors. The maple pecan syrup in an iced chai is ridiculously good!The interior is cute, nothing fancy but it's cozy and sweet. The patio area has a decent amount of seating. The staff is always super friendly and I always love when places offer Apple Pay!

The owner can't keep staff because she's nasty to them. The way she talks to her employees is condescending not something I need to hear about. I'm just trying to grab a coffee. They are rarely open between the reduced hours and closing randomly multiple times a week. Might as well go somewhere else

This place is ADOREABLE! Maria is so sweet and every single thing on the menu is absolutely delectable! Drinks are made right in front of you with a smile and fresh baked goods were also being prepped! There is the prefect patio space as well as indoor seating. Definitely a must-go if you're looking for a quiet coffee shop just out of the hustle and bustle of the city. I'd pick Bexley Coffee Shop over Starbucks any day of the week! I got a smoothie and lemon bar and it tasted so refreshing! Also pet friendly with dog bones and a water bowl for your pooch!

The coffee tastes like black licorice and it is in a very run down building. If it wasn't for the sweet lady we likely would have turned around and left.

Great Mom and Pop style place off the beaten path. Excellent pastries and ice coffee to wake you up!

I have been there twice, both times the owner was training young people to work. The way she talked down and scolded them bother me. The banana bread was excellent, but I can't go back and support an owner that does not treat her young employees well.