Tammy's Pizza

Great pizza topping are plentiful and fresh. Pricing is good I'm sure you'll enjoy your meal.

Small little place with minimal parking in the rear. They do not deliver, but the pizza is worth the trip to pick it up! I love their pizza!

Tammy's is one of my favorites. Definitely my favorite in GC. We get the pep and cheese and are never disappointed. We have also enjoyed the cheese ravioli. Ownership has changed hands, I hope that doesn't change things. One thing I noticed is now they seem to prefer online orders. I usually just call in my order but I tried the new online system and accidentally ordered a cheese pizza rather than what we wanted and always get--pepperoni and cheese. When I arrived and realized I had ordered it wrong (it was my fault), but the people behind the counter offered no resolve. Just disappointing. Always been a fan (4.5 stars)...hope to continue if things stay the same. Not so sure at this point (with most recent experience: 3 stars)!

This is the only pizza in Columbus that my husband will eat (outside of Pizza Hut). It came highly recommended. My friend ordered it one night for a "pizza, wine and movie" evening. My mechanic also recommended it. It is a particularly flat pizza. I love that. It's not fluffy pizza-chain-like crust and it more resembles a flatter, east coast kind of pizza. It doesn't have the crusty bottom that I enjoy though. It's a visually pleasing pizza. These sauce and cheese is ample and the cheese is stretchy. Cold pizza is my guilty pleasure and it's even pretty OK cold.Here is my issue. The taste of the sauce. I honestly don't know to put it and I feel bad for how I am but... it has an aftertaste like vomit, to me. My husband doesn't taste it. Obviously no one else does but me. I've had it several times and I always get that after taste. When I eat it, i use garlic powder, red pepper flakes and parm. It helps. I'll give two stars because of that and the fact that my husband enjoys it.

Good Columbus style pizza. Reasonable prices. Cheese has an odd aftertaste that wasn't my favorite. Pepperoni was not very spicy.

Traveling for business and wound up in Grove City, OH.I like pizza, I eat it more than my wife would wish.This Tammy's pizza was quite possibly the worst pizza I've had in years.I think they spilled a bunch of sugar in the sauce, it was cotton candy sweet.They use Doordash to deliver and the pizza was barely luke-warm by the time it was got to me and the crust was not crispy, it was rubbery. I'm not surprised that they leave it by the door and run away. Call it Covid precautions if you want, but if you are handed a cold pizza, you complain, so it's my opinion that dude knew that and bailed.I ate a couple of pieces and I am literally throwing the rest away, and it was NOT inexpensive.Save your money.

Made an online order, pick up was on time and tasted great very fresh, definitely returning

This pizza used to be one of the best. My wife and I ordered for the first time in a while. Completely changed the crust and we were unimpressed what used to be a thin and crispy pizza is now more of a doughy hand tossed. If it's not broken why fix it!

In the past Tammy's was my choice for Pizza. But after this evening I think I am finished with Tammy's. We always order the Tammy's Porker. In the past there were plenty of toppings. But tonight not much in the way of toppings. The sauce was sparse. And the crust was no where near done. I don't know if you made any ingredient changes, but there was little to no taste to my pizza. We ate inside which was clean. I wished I had asked for paper plates as the slices were limp from lack of crispiness.

Good pizza. Best in GC... Long way to the top.Ohio has a thing of not slicing pie slices. Apparently they have a lot of friends with their slicing of 2"x2" squares.This "pie" was good in consistency in that every slice embraced was a full can full of every topping. The crust was decent and not doughy like fake Sicilian. Of the options, Tammy, you don't disappoint. An out of work immigrant Italian could feast on this pie for weeks. It's so heavy. You settled midwest but your Za's are loaded for the Pacific. Good flavor, good intent. We don't need a fat melting pot. Grazie.