Sweet Tooth Cottage

If it would be possible to give more stars I would. This is a fabulous bakery with lots of tasty treats, not that we have tried them all, yet. The customer service is definitely worth noting, particularly in this day and age. We purchased some of their custom sugar cookies for our vet after our dog passed. They could not have been more helpful, going so far as asking for a picture to help when decorating. The cookies tasted great as has everything we have tried. They even put the extra cookies in for no charge, again outstanding customer service.!! This is a great place and I would highly recommend to anyone looking for a good bakery in the area!

I have travelled by Sweet Tooth Cottage many times and finally had the time to stop. They have a variety of desserts. Their sugar cookie cutouts are adorable. I tried a cheesecake slice and a brownie. Both were delicious. The staff was nice and gave me a moment to see all the options before making a selection. This is a cute bakery off Sawmill.

I have always loved Sweet Tooth's custom sugar cookies, but this was the first time I ordered a cake from them and it did not disappoint!The team at Sweet Tooth is always incredible to work with and they helped make getting my mom's custom lemon cake with lemon icing for her birthday/retirement process very easy and the cake was as delicious as it was beautiful!

My bf found this place by accident.. and two days later he brought home an AMAZING decorated cake!! The lady working was so kind and helpful, he said. He brought home cookies as well .... And let's just say they didn't last long! The no-bake cookies were to die for, and the pb blossoms were amazing! And they don't skimp in size!

I mean.....quite possible the best cookie I've ever had! You cannot go wrong here....its almost hard to choose because everything looks and tastes so delicious! We will return often!

Great customer service and friendly staff. This was my first time ordering from Sweet Tooth Cottage. I've been told that their cookie cakes are better than the ones in the mall and of course way better than what the grocery store has to offer.Super cute cake and my son loved it! It was soft and the icing was delicious. Our only minor complaint was that the cookie cake was a little too dense for our liking. We will be ordering again and happy to support this business!

Owners husband the manager is Very rude. I asked about a rewards program for returning customers. He advised me that I obviously know nothing about small businesses or I wouldn't be asking that. As I tried to explain that I spend lots of money with his wife's business, and they should consider with the pricing. He then said he's not having this conversation anymore, and hung up. I'm done patronizing this company. I use to speak highly of their cookies, but no more. You have lost a loyal customer, maybe if you loose enough you will care.

I ordered a birthday cake for my sister's 75th. It was perfect and everyone said it was DELICIOUS!

I found sweet tooth cottage to be a delightful shop with a great selection of baked goods. The snickerdoodle had the perfect amount of cinnamon! A great treat!

Solid selection of beautifully decorated cookies and amazing cupcakes. Great customer service.