Garlic cheese bread
Personal pizza
a neon sign for a sub shop
Pizza pictures
Italian sub
Buckeye memorabilia
Cool signage
Brutus
Garlic cheese bread
14" Pepperoni, half with sausage, onion, banana peppers
Pepperoni bites
The Goods-Philly Cheese Roast Beef
More pictures
pizza, food
salads, interior
New menu prices
Ask! The specials change.
Street signage to look for.
cupcakes
New menu prices
Dinners menu
Pizza menu
Joseph S.
Oct 28, 2023
What a fantastic joint! We have never been here, so we decided to give it a try before our movie. We got their Italian sub and a personal pizza. Both were amazing. The sauce on the pizza was mouth watering good. The Italian was great, but just a little extra Italian dressing in it would have made it better. I'd advise you to ask for extra dressing. Unfortunately, there is no dine in. I asked when it would be back, and they said hopefully soon. It was blocked off, so you'll have to sit outside. You'll find two picnic tables to the left of the entrance. Other than that, I'll definitely be back to try more subs and a bigger pizza.
Read More
Stephen K.
Jun 21, 2024
Ordered lunch for my family from here yesterday: a large cheese and a large pepperoni. I'd heard good things about it and it lived up to the hype. The sauce was tasty, and the crust was crispy even hours later when we finished it off. We'll be back for sure.
Read More
Barry H.
Apr 12, 2022
Decided to stop in to Susie's Sub Shop this afternoon. It is located on Karl Road. They have been at this location for 3 years. I decided to order a Philly Cheese Roast Beef sandwich and some Garlic Cheese Bread. The Philly Cheese Roast Beef sandwich which had a good amount of roast beef with onions, green peppers, mushrooms and Swiss cheese, all toasted nicely. The Garlic Cheese bread had a very mild garlic flavor to it with a great layer of cheese with some spices sprinkled over it. It was a lot of food for the money.
Read More
Reginald L.
Jan 31, 2023
Susie Subs has never disappointed. I usually get either a sub or pizza. Recently I ordered a sausage, pepperoni and I could not have been more satisfied and this is coming from a person who has pretty much given up on outside the home food establishments. Thank you Susie Subs for your consistently in creating subs and pizzas that are always high quality. There are only a couple of places that I will order food and Susie Subs is one of them.
Read More
50cal R.
Jul 30, 2022
They make really good pizza. The staff is always pretty nice sometimes they are slammed with orders so it's expected for them to be rushing and short. Never had a bad experience with the food.
Read More
Renee W.
Oct 15, 2023
"C-Rating "Cracker thin crust. Liked the crunch but lacked flavor. Didn't care for the sausage. Tasted better fresh, not once it cooled down. Glad I tried it, but it didn't make my list to go again.A- one of my favsB- like but not a go toC- edible, but just okay D- uh... maybe if I am drunkF- oh hell no! never again!
Read More
David B.
May 4, 2024
Great little locally owned sub shop - had a turkey sub, pepperoni pizza and the pepperoni bites.....all were really good. I'll certainly be back
Read More
chentrel t.
Nov 3, 2023
Food is so delicious and the people are great. It's a friendly atmosphere all the way around. If you're looking for made to order fresh food.Try Suzie's subs I promise you won't be disappointed
Read More
Jeri B.
Oct 9, 2023
I have been a customer since they were located at Westerville Rd. and Weber Rd. until now when they are maybe seven minutes in traffic from where I live. This has made me hungry so gotta order my spaghetti dinner with a extra meatball. Try them
Read More
Mary L.
Jul 23, 2023
Nothing Special. Just not good food. Pizza had very little sauce and very little cheese, and the crust was tough. The subs were ok. The people that worked there are very friendly and nice.
Read More