Susie's Pizza

The spouse and his family grew up on Susie's Pizza - The Oldest and Still the Best. It's a thing when we come to Upper for dinner, and their pizza is, for a mom & pop place, some of the most consistent and tasty around. The sauce is slightly sweet, and the pepperoni meaty but not curly. Just the right amount of greasy, cheesy goodness. I look forward to it (as does the spouse). They'll likely be around for as long as they want to - as the high praise on Yelp attests.

Best darn pizza in the area!! We moved to Florida over a year ago and cannot find anything that even comes close to this in Florida. Every visit back to Ohio, we will go out of our way to get a Susie's Pizza. It's worth it!!!

This pizza is the best! I grew up on it. The cheese is so delicious with the right amount of saltiness and chewiness. The crust and sauce is divine. When I come back to Upper Sandusky I must get some to take back home to Columbus.

Lived in Nevada, Ohio years ago. The BEST pizza I ever had. People down right friendly, and you get lots of pie for the money. Not a big population in Upper, but if your near Marion, Delaware, or Findlay it's worth the trip.

Pretty good for a "mom & pop" pizza place. A little pricey. They need specials or couplons. I get their pepperoni and anchovies from time to time. I think they are the only place in town that carries anchovies. They are always fresh & yummy but a little chincy. (Need more)

Best pizza in Ohio.Drive from Cleveland to order, some of the nicest people work there and have yet to have an order messed up.Every pizza is consistent and I know that I will never be disappointed.It's too bad that more people don't know the greatness that this pizza is.