Stone Brother's Pizza

Delicious pizza! Probably in my top 3 favorite pizza places. Lots of seating inside. A large menu to choose from. Nice customer service. Highly recommend

First off let me start by saying we have lived in this area for a little over a year and have never seen an advertisement for this place and when I search for pizza is does not appear on any search engines, so I am happy we found this place just casually driving and decided to take a chance but sad it took so long as we think it is the best pizza of the 3 pizza places located within Utica, OH. It was dinner time on a Wednesday and we had just left a meet and greet at our children's school. We live outside of town so we usually take a turn to head in another direction or else who knows how long it would have been before we would have crossed paths with this place had we not.Parking was ample. Not very busy when we arrived. Atleast thats how it seemed. We put our order in and waited and waited and waited as the saying goes fast food isn't good and good food isn't fast. It was what we noticed as we waited ... order after order after order being picked up. This place is literally the locals secret!!! We were amazed with the traffic coming and going, which made us excited for what we were about to take in.After maybe a 20min wait, our order of cheese sticks were delivered piping hot with a side of marinara. Nothing fancy but still Delish! Another 15-20min 1 6inch meatball, 1 personal cheese pizza, and 1 large signatures pizza "The Blitz", with a couple sodas concluded our order. Fyi there is no alcohol served at this establishment (trust me, its not a deal breaker)The meatball sub was for my daughter. It did not look that great. The meatballs are very small and dark, almost looked waaay overcooked. I had to tear half the hard bread off it was served on so my daughter could even bite into it. This is her favorite type of sandwich and she was not interested in eating it due to the presentation. My husband and I both tried it and didn't think it was bad at all, just lacked the appeal but tasty!Personal cheese was cut into triangles - our picky eater loved it! Def got a thumbs up!!!The Blitz to our surprise was huge for a large and cut into squares from a circle. The toppings were ample, fresh, crisp - perfect! Not too much or too little of anything. The sauce was perfection! Not too sweet not too tangy not too acidic. The crust was great too but with The Blitz we would ask for a little crisper only due to all the toppings taking over (just a personal preference) and our eyes being bigger than our stomachs that it took awhile for us to reach the middle of the pizza (but totally not a bad thing). I usually don't eat onions or sausage on pizza but sometimes in marriage you gotta be flexible and I had told my husband he could pick this time and let me tell you, I enjoyed every single bite, so much so I was adding the fallen onions and sausage to my slices of pizza!! Amazing!!We left this gem with full bellies and plenty of leftovers. My husband mentioned he can't wait to try just a regular pepperoni pizza from this place (maybe pizza twice in 1 week lol)We recommend ordering in advance as the wait can be excruciating - especially when you show up starving lol but so worth the wait too!!! Can't wait for round 2

Amazing pizza! Stone Bros pizza was piping hot and full of flavor that made this pizza great. The staff was very friendly and they made sure we were taken care of. I will be back!

The food is amazing! Not only are the pizzas delicious, there jumbo wings with all of the sauce options were the best.

Very family oriented place that places their focus on delivering first rate customer service. Their pizza is a piece of heaven! If you want finger licking crispy wings this is your place! They are my go to place going forward!

Great staff, we dined in. The place was clean and great environment. Food came out fast, fresh and hot! All in all would say 10/10 and would recommend!

Ordered a medium pizza with three different toppings they charge 1.50$ per toppings. When we get it it hardly has any toppings on it way too much pizza sauce. For what they charge and what they give I would drive to Johnstown or Mt.Vernon to dirko's pizza way better pizza and they actually put toppings on that you paid for. This is what happens when there are only two pizza places in town and neither know how to make a proper pizza or how to put seasoning on it..

When I came here, the pizza didn't look appetizing, or warm, it was completely cold. Would not recommend. Pizza Factory is right down the road, I'd rather go there.

Great food good people . Salty type sauce . Mexican (taco) pizza rocks if you order on a Friday or Saturday give a littlle more time than it tells you online .

Best pizza in town! My son-in-law is a New Yorker & loves it too!! We order ahead of time and pick up. The signature pizza's are delicious and many to choose from. The crust is more on the thin & crispy side which we prefer. Always a treat when decide to do pizza take out night! *****FIVE STARS ALL THE WAY***** You Rock Stone Brother's!!!