Sicilia Fine Italian Specialties
Sicilia Fine Italian Specialties
This is the $7 baklava that I ordered. It's clearly not baklava and clearly not worth $7.
Cheese Pizza and pepperoni and sausage
Bruschetta
Penne with Ricotta
a slice of cheese pizza
Awesome after game spot!
Awesome Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage & Pepperoni. You've GOT to try it!
THIS IS WHAT I RECEIVED!!!
two slices of pepperoni pizza
food, pizza
food, pizza
menu
interior
Chicken Alfredo Pasta
waffles
pizza, food
This is what I ordered...
food
food
Davis A.
Nov 9, 2024
This is a quintessential night-out pizza stop in a college town. Attached to Out-R-In Bar, the line out the door gets crazy long on weekend nights. But if you can get there before then, DO. They get a ton of business by-the-slice, but get a full pizza if you've got the time.Most of the pizzas sit at 7/10. BUT the white pizza is CRAZY GOOD. Oh my lord. So many kinds of cheese, the crust is always fluffy-yet-crisp (it's seasoned too), and you get a side of garlic butter. Delicious. This is the greasy-mess-pizza that I love in Columbus.I give 4 stars because when the pizza's not ready when I arrive, they never let me know when it becomes ready. Whatever communication there is from the back-of-house doesn't reach the front-of-house. I have to watch for myself for when a pizza goes on top of the ovens and toss a coin whether I wanna ask them to check if it's mine. Then I'm the jerk if it's notI still always tip though, the pizza is so worth it!
Read More
Angela W.
Jan 9, 2025
I placed an order for delivery and received a completely wrong pizza and no breadsticks. I contacted the restaurant and they were impossible to communicate with!! They blamed the delivery person and offered no resolution to the error. The pizza I did receive was cold as ice as well. Absolutely non-existent customer service. They could have offered to send me the correct pizza and my breadsticks and made this right...but chose not to. I will never order from them again. Horrible customer service.
Read More
Kyle W.
Feb 1, 2025
Not only was this the best pizza my wife and I have ever had, the service was unbeatable as well. After a day out at Out-R-Inn next door, we decided to go because it was convenient. The pizza ended up being amazing and the cashier was extremely kind. Highly recommend this place!!
Read More
Shawn P.
Aug 13, 2024
Where do I begin with this review. Well I'm going to just make it quick and to the point. Don't be fooled by the name this is no way Fine nor Italian style pizza. I've have had better pizza in the frozen section of the grocery store. Sorry I have nothing good to say about this pizza place. It's definitely a drunken college student pizza spot
Read More
Kavion M.
Oct 22, 2022
$6.99 Baklava...so tiny...no wait...it's a piece of oreo pie. Not what I ordered. Shame.
Read More
Liberty L.
May 25, 2021
Placed a take out / delivery order from them a few days ago to try something new and the food was very tasty and satisfied my pasta craving for sure. I couldn't decide what to get so I went for penne with ricotta! The penne was cooked to perfection and covered with lots of melty cheese and it was still hot/fresh when the food arrived! The portion size was very big and you could likely get two servings from it, especially if you also had a side dish. Overall, a really good experience.
Read More
Hailey D.
Jun 5, 2023
I get this by the slice and it's the best most heavenly pizza in the world. But then when I order a whole pizza it never hits the same. Not sure if it's just me being crazy or what but either way the pizza is great. They also have super good mozzarella sticks.
Read More
Kurt S.
Jan 4, 2023
Sicilia is a 3 if you order it for delivery, a 2 if you're an adult looking to explore Columbus, and a 5 if you're a drunk college student who desperately needs carbs and wings. I'm not sure what else to put, but this is not a place that you should find through a Yelp review.
Read More
Mohamed E.
Sep 24, 2024
One of the best chicken phillies I've had. It's fresh and warm and the portions are good.
Read More
Gabriella O.
Apr 19, 2024
I crave Sicilias every single day. I live right behind it and I want it all the time. It is the best pizza I've ever had. You need to try it.
Read More
