Sexton's Pizza

After having lunch at their nearby burger bar we wanted to try the full Sextons experience so we grabbed a pie for Sunday. After getting the pizza it looked so good so we tried a slice in the car. This pizza is unlike many spots in Columbus where it's cut in squares yet nearly close to all of that areas spots are trying to copy or piggy back off of Donatos. This was traditional cut with a unique crust flavor. The toppings flavor profiles of the meat were great as well. Furthermore it had plenty of cheese. My only suggestion is for them to add MORE MEAT such as pepperoni, bacon etc. Outside of that it's a good and decent pizza.

What's the dilly 'yo! That's not a typo, that's the flavor of my new favorite pizza in C-Bus! Square crust with perfectly caramelized crust paired with crunch thin sliced dill pickles, whole milk mozzarella baked to perfection with just a drizzle of garlic olive oil. Is it amazing? Don't take my word for it, they sell out of their pies pretty quick on the daily do place your order and enjoy sooner than later!

Horrible vulger music playing with foul language that offended me. They didn't have any water. However the staff was very polite and helpful. Service was very slow. We waited a long time before we received our done in pizza. However no one is wearing a hair net. Waited and waited and every got served before us that came in after us. We won't be back.

Good pizza. The fries and the ranch both add a lot to the quality. Nice employees that are cool.

Absolutely amazing! You must try!Got the mike pizza and can't wait to come back and try more. Sexton's Burger Bar is absolutely amazing too.

First timer at Sexton's Gahanna. 5* NY style. Great tasty crust, wow on the cupped pepperoni, and the cheese is just outstanding. Only drawback tonight, there was no one to serve beer since all four employees were under 21. The beer on tap selection was very good, which made not getting a beer even worse. You could get cans out of the cooler, but the selection was poor. The team was working hard and they were slammed at 6:30. "I'll be back"! Thanks to Stallone for the quote.

My friend had been telling me about this place for weeks. You have to order online, and I never seemed to be able to beat the rush. But I decided I would get up early and order ahead of time. I ordered the pepperoni pizza, and for a got a side of the ranch and hot honey on the side. I thought the pizza was just okay, maybe I have to try one of their specialty pizzas. But to me the pepperoni was just okay. I was a little disappointed . But the overall service when I picked up the pizza was good, the restaurant was clean inside . I will definitely give them another try for sure.

This is my very favorite pizza in Columbus. It's the style I prefer. I prefer a sit down place which it is but no ambiance or comfort. It has tables with bleacher seats and plastic chairs. Order at the register and they bring out . Our server was very personable which was not what we had experienced before. Just the right amount of sauce - not sweet - again my preference. Yummy cheese and pie cut ! Just the right amount of char but not burnt. If it was a more comfortable dine in place I would definitely come more often and bring people.

I was skeptical to try but the pictures made the pizza look delicious and rich with flavor, the packed pepperoni was impressive. Fast forward to what I received. I preferred 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 mushroom. The bottom was burnt and uncooked in places and tasted as such, the pepperoni was scarce. There was a lack of sauce in places and just dough. Very disappointed.

Ordered doordash and it took over an hour when it said it was going to be 20-30 minutes. When i got the pizza it was cold and hard so it wasn't enjoyable but i ate it because i was starving!