Sammy's New York Bagels

Many years ago I shopped at Sammys in New Rochelle, NY. When he came to Columbus I couldn't get there fast enough. When I moved back to Columbus this year I couldn't wait to order bagels from Sammy's. I placed my order online for bagels and danish. His Black Russian bagels are my favorite, then the everything -then multigrain. His veggie cream cheese and lox spread are sooo creamy and easy to spread. Their production place is across the street from my apartment- so I get early delivery. The raspberry crumb cake and the chocolate crumb cake are yummy sweets for a coffee break, as is the blueberry danish. Sammy's bagels are much tastier than Foxes also bigger see pic. Foxes bagels all taste bland, if blindfolded they all taste the same.

What a great idea. A friend had these delivered to my doorstep. They arrived by 5am, complete packaged and placed into a cooler on my front porch. It was wonderful waking up to fresh bagels on my porch.I cannot speak much to the ordering process but my friend said she put the order in a few days in advance. I believe there is a delivery fee if you don't meet a certain dollar amount.Our delivery included a big variety of bagels plus two scones and cream cheese. I'd say the scones were so/so but the bagels are very tasty! Wonderful idea instead of a meal train or casserole drop off. Will certainly use them in the future.

My fave bagel in Central Ohio. They have no retail store presence, but you can order on the website for delivery! We did a large order that I ordered a week in advance for delivery on a Saturday. Perfect bagels and perfect packaging. Good email communication. I'm not sure what their delivery area is, so check the website.

I wish I could give more than five stars. These are THE best bagels and scallion cream cheese I have ever had. They are way better than the bagels I had in NY last year. Also, Sammy's has restored my faith in excellent customer service. Thank you Sammys! Here's the details:* They are a delivery only business. * Place your online order before 3 pm, and your order will be delivered to your home the next morning. * Delivery times vary by zipcode. * $20 is the order minimum. $30+ orders get free delivery. * They offer bagels, cream cheeses, baked goods (cookies, croissants, donuts), deli salads (egg salad, whitefish salad), and lox. If you like egg salad...theirs is incredible.

This was our first time ordering Sammy's and loved it so much I had to write this review the moment I finished my first bagel. We ordered 20 bagels yesterday afternoon and woke up this morning to have fresh bagels right outside our door. We live downtown, which can get tricky with deliveries, and did find them outside of our lobby door rather than our apartment door but none the less - amazing service!The bagels were securely wrapped and placed in a large brown bag with an extra plastic bag inside. From the moment my husband walked through the door, our apartment smelled like delicious, fresh bagels. They are soft and fluffy, while having that distinct NY shell and feel. We've tried the Everything Bagel + Russian so far and they're just so. good. Super easy to order, beyond convenient and a delicious New York style bagel. 10/10 would recommend!

I ordered the bagels on Friday for Saturday delivery. They were delivered at 6:45 in the morning, wrapped in plastic so they didn't get wet in the rain. They were not warm ( it was only about 15 degrees outside ) but they were fresh and soft on the inside. The whitefish salad was fresh and delicious

I just love a toasted bagel with cream cheese for breakfast, but the local grocery stores tend to sell what some coworkers have referred to as "breadles" which are good, but not great. I also tend to grocery shop in the evening, after the bagel shops are closed. So, enter.... bagel delivery!They have a great website and online order form. The minimum order for delivery is $20, so I'm going to freeze a couple of bagels. You can buy bagels individually or purchase a dozen. I went with individual and also got some cream cheese and egg salad. There were some really nice cookie and pastry options, but this time around, I'm just getting bagels. Added a tip for the driver and delivery instructions and waited until the next morning.The paper sack of bagels was sitting on my front porch, wrapped in a plastic bag. The delivery driver did not knock or ring (as planned) and never woke the dog! I cut open the plastic bag and smelled, EVERYTHING BAGELS! the bagel, once toasted is that perfect combo of crunchy and chewy. I'm planning to freeze the rest and looking forward to bagels another day! Will most definitely order again!

Sammy's New York Bagels has tweaked a few things over the course of the pandemic in regards to cost, delivery amount, and days delivered. Orders placed by 3:00 pm are/can be delivered next day with delivery days being Monday to Saturday. Currently it's $12 for a bakers dozen of more standard bagel flavors and $15 for specialty flavors such as seasonal flavors, jalapeño cheddar, cinnamon crunch, etc. Still a phenomenal deal for such tasty bagels. Order minimum for delivery is $15 which is quite easily reached. Especially if you add on some of the baked goods that SNYB makes. (My wife loves the B & W cookies so I always make sure to add some on to my bagel orders to get a few extra brownie points with her!)Have you ordered bagels yet? No, well get on it! (P.S. Make sure you add some of SNYB's black & white cookies because they are heckin' tasty when dipped in coffee.)

We regularly order bagels from Sammy's and are usually pleased with our order. Today, unfortunately, we had a bad experience. The poppy seeds on the poppy seed bagels are bitter and there are so many of them that they're impossible to scrape off. I left a phone message and also an email asking for a refund for the poppy bagels as they are inedible. They got back to me pretty quickly and said they would refund me for the poppy seed bagels. You can't beat that for customer service.

I was looking for a replacement for Blocks, and Sammy's Bagels is much more than adequate. Their bagels are exactly what I wanted. Plus, they deliver!!