Poppy's

Poppy's Traditional Round Pizza

Poppy's 12" Traditional Round

12" Thin Crust Pizza with Poppy's special blend cheese, the
$13.00
Poppy's 14" Traditional Pizza

14" Traditional Round Pizza
$15.40
Poppy's 16" Traditional Pizza

16" Traditional Round Pizza
$18.56
Poppy's Choice Traditional Round

Cheese, Pepperoni, Onion, Green Peppers, Sausage and Mushrooms
$25.28
Hawaiian Traditional Round

Cheese, Bacon, Ham and Pineapple
$20.28
Meat Lovers Traditional Round

Cheese, Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Italian Sausage and Ground Beef
$25.28
Veggie Traditional Round

Cheese, Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms and Black Olives.
$22.78
BBQ Chicken Traditional Round

Cheese, Italian Chicken, BBQ Sauce, Onions and Bacon
$22.46
Pepperoni Parmesano Traditional Round

Cheese, Pepperoni, Shredded Parm, Grated Parm and drizzled with Garlic Butter
$18.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch Traditional Round

Delicious Chicken, Bacon and Homemade Ranch
$20.03
Buffalo Chicken Traditional Round

Buffalo Chicken Pizza with Buffalo sauce, Poppy's Cheese Blend, Delicious Chicken, Bacon and Red Onion! Topped with Homemade Ranch Dressing
$22.46

Poppys Pies Detroit Style Pizza

Slices Pizza

Cheese and pepperoni.
$4.00
Personal and Kids BYO Personal Pizza
$5.60
Personal and Kids Poppy's Choice Pizza

Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and green peppers.
$9.30
Personal and Kids Veggie Pizza

Cheese, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives.
$8.50
Personal Kids' Meat Lovers Pizza

Cheese, pepperoni, ham, sausage, gr. beef & bacon.
$9.30
Personal Kids' Hawaiian Pizza

Cheese, ham and pineapple, bacon.
$7.70
Personal/Kids BBQ Chicken

Cheese, Italian Chicken, Onions, Bacon and BBQ Sauce
$8.80
Small BYO Pizza
$14.05
Small Poppy's Choice Pizza

Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion and green pepper.
$25.30
Small Veggie Pizza

Cheese, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives.
$23.05
Small Meat Lovers Pizza

Cheese, pepperoni, ham, sausage, gr. beef and bacon.
$25.30
Small Hawaiian Pizza

Cheese, ham, pineapple, and bacon.
$20.80
Small BBQ Chicken

Cheese, Italian Chicken, Onions, Bacon and BBQ Sauce
$22.75
Large BYO Pizza
$20.00
Large Poppy's Choice Pizza

Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion and green pepper.
$31.35
Large Veggie Pizza

Cheese, mushrooms, onion, green peppers, black olives.
$29.75
Large Meat Lovers Pizza

Cheese, pepperoni, ham, sausage, gr. beef and bacon.
$31.35
Large Hawaiian Pizza

Cheese, ham, pineapple and bacon.
$26.75
Large BBQ Chicken

Cheese, Italian Chicken, Onions, Bacon and BBQ Sauce
$29.60

Hot Subs

6" Italian Sub

Ham, salami, provolone, roma tomatoes, Red Onion, Banana peppers, Mayo, Oil & vinegar, oregano. Served with chips.
$9.95
6" Ham & Cheese Sub

Ham, American cheese, lettuce, roma tomatoes, homemade Italian dressing. Served with chips.
$9.95
6" Turkey & Cheddar Sub

Juicy off the bone Turkey, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Roma Tomatoes and Mayo. Served with Chips
$9.95
6" Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Sub

Chicken, Bacon, Poppy's Cheese Blend, Lettuce, Roma Tomatoes and Homemade Ranch Dressing. Served with Chips
$10.25

Specials

Personal and Kids Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Personal Special
$7.99
Small Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Special
$20.00
Large Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Special
$26.75

Desserts

Caramel Cinnamon Bread

Warm delicious cinnamon sugar dough, baked to perfection and topped with Caramel and served with Homemade Cream Cheese Icing
$6.35
Choc Chip Grandma's Big Cookies
$2.85
Peanut Butter Grandma's Big Cookies
$2.85
Chocolate Brownie Grandma's Big Cookies
$2.85
Oatmeal Rasin Grandma's Big Cookie
$2.85
New York Cheesecake
$5.99

Poppy's Zones Calzones

The Binx Calzone

Golden brown outside, basted with poppy's garlic sauce and Parmesan. Inside filled with pepperoni and poppy's special cheese blend. Served with poppy's special pizza sauce.
$11.50
The Nonna Calzone

Golden brown outside, basted with poppy's garlic sauce and Parmesan. Inside filled with your choice of 3 toppings (excluding Chicken) and of course poppy's special cheese blend. Served with poppy's special pizza sauce.
$15.40

Poppys Specialties

8 Pieces Cheese Bread Special

Our delicious dough with garlic butter, spices, our special cheese blend and topped with Parmesan cheese, served with pizza sauce. Add pepperoni for an additional charge.
$7.50
8 Pieces Garlic Parmesan Bread Special

Our delicious dough topped with garlic butter, spices, Parmesan cheese and served with pizza sauce.
$6.75
Garlic Parmesan Breadstick's

Fresh Hot Breadsticks baked to perfection, basted with Poppy's own Garlic Parmesan Butter and the coated with Grated Parmesan Cheese. Served with Poppy's Pizza Sauce!
$7.00

Bae Baes Wings, KDs FF & Snacks

KD's French Fries

French fries, melted cheese, and bacon served with ranch, add jalapenos for an additional charge.
$7.45
French Fries Plain
$4.25
Boneless Wings

Plain with dipping sauce on side or tossed in BBQ, or mild Buffalo. (prices are due to chicken shortage, increased costs have occurred across U.S.)
$8.85
Bone In Wing Dings

Plain with dipping sauce on side or tossed in BBQ, mild Buffalo, or garlic butter Parmesan. (prices are due to chicken shortage, increased costs have occurred across U.S.)
$12.80
Miehls Mozzerella Sticks (6)

Hand Breaded Mozzarella Sticks deep fried to perfection, served with Poppy's Special Pizza Sauce
$6.59
Breaded Mushrooms

Hand Breaded Fresh Mushrooms, deep fried to perfection. Served with Homemade Ranch for dipping.
$6.85
Beer Batter Onion Rings

Delicious Beer Battered Onion Rings served with Horseradish Sauce
$7.75
Munchie Basket

Triple Threat: Mozzarella Sticks, Breaded Mushrooms and Beer Batter Onion Rings. These are FULL Portions of each! Served with Homemade Ranch, Horseradish Sauce and Poppy's Pizza Sauce
$18.85
Fried Pickle Chips

Deep Fried Pickle Chips served with Homemade Ranch Dressing for dipping
$7.45

Salads

Small Antipasto Salad

Lettuce, ham, salami, provolone, tomato, mild pepper rings, and Italian dressing. Substitute homemade ranch for an additional charge.
$8.25
Large Antipasto Salad

Lettuce, ham, salami, provolone, tomato, mild pepper rings, and Italian dressing. Substitute homemade ranch for an additional charge.
$11.50
Chef Salad

Lettuce, Ham, Turkey, American Cheese, Provolone Cheese, Garlic Croutons, Cucumbers, Tomatoes and Egg. Add Onion for no additional charge
$12.10
Chef Salad Small

Lettuce, Ham, Turkey, American Cheese, Provolone Cheese, Garlic Croutons, Cucumbers, Tomatoes and Egg. Add Onion for no additional charge
$8.50
Garden Salad Small

Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Croutons and Red Onion
$5.45
Garden Salad Large

Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Croutons and Red Onion
$7.65
Poppy's Chicken Critter Salad

Diced Fried Chicken, Lettuce, Red Onions, Cheddar Cheese, Poppy's Cheese Blend, Diced Egg, Tomatoes and Croutons upon request.
$12.65

Energy Drinks

16 oz. Bang Cotton Candy
$3.60
16 oz. Bang Unicorn
$3.60
16 oz. Monster Mango Loco
$3.65
16 oz. Monster Original
$3.65
Red Bull (12oz)
$3.75
16 oz. Bang Peach Mango
$3.60
15 oz. Monster Loca Moca
$4.65
15 oz. Monster Mean Bean
$4.65
16 oz. Monster Zero Ultra Violet
$3.65
Red Bull SF (12oz)
$3.75

Pop 20 oz. Bottles

Barq Root Beer
$2.60
Diet Coke
$2.75
Diet Mountain Dew
$2.75
Dr Pepper
$2.75
Crush Grape
$2.39
Mellow Yellow
$2.60
Mountain Dew Baja Blast
$2.60
Mountain Dew Livewire
$2.25
Mountain Dew USA
$2.25
Mountain Dew Zero
$2.60
Real Sugar Pepsi
$2.25
Sierra Mist
$2.60
Coke
$2.75
Coke Zero
$2.75
Diet Dr Pepper
$2.75
Diet Pepsi
$2.75
Dr Pepper Zero
$2.60
Crush Orange
$2.39
Mountain Dew
$2.75
Mountain Dew Code Red
$2.60
Mountain Dew Melon
$2.60
Mountain Dew Voltage
$2.25
Pepsi
$2.75
Pepsi Zero
$2.75

Water and Gatorade

16.9oz Bottle Aquafina
$1.50
Gatorade Fruit Punch Sports Top (24oz)
$3.85
Gatorade Cool Blue Sports Top (24oz)
$3.85
Gatorade Lemon Lime Sports Top (24oz)
$3.85
Gatorade Glacier Cherry Sports Top (24oz)
$3.85

Amanda B.

★★★★☆

Sep 16, 2022

The pizza was good, but the cheesy bread is dynamite! 0rdered a build your own pizza, toppings were great, crust is thin and over worked. Because it's over worked it makes it a little chewy. This isn't the only kind of pizza they have though. Perhaps next time I order from here I will try the Detroit style or wings.

Niki X.

★★★★★

Sep 1, 2022

This is delicious pizza!!!! I ordered the Detroit style and the crust was great .... Sauced and cheesy. The poppy's choice had the perfect balance of toppings and sauce. Again the crust and cheese were very good on this pizza and had very fresh toppings. An easy pick up on the way home from work.

Jim S.

★★★★☆

Dec 27, 2023

Really like the Detroit style but must admit the round pizza is quite good. Sauce is great, crust could have a little more crunch but otherwise one of my favorite. Gonna give it 7.7

S. G.

★★★★★

Apr 19, 2021

Had the Detroit Style Pizza, was just amazing, sauce is so good, definitely a hidden gem in Lima.

Susan M.

★★★★★

Apr 13, 2022

The best Chicago style pizza I have ever had in Lima, and the people are great . I will definitely be back.

Jennifer W.

★★★★★

Apr 3, 2022

The food is hot, fresh, well-seasoned, and well portioned!! Excellent service from upbeat voice on the phone to smiles at pickup with a thank you on the pizza boxes. Yum!!!!

Poppy's

Menu

Poppy's Traditional Round Pizza

Poppy's 12" Traditional Round

Poppy's 14" Traditional Pizza

Poppy's 16" Traditional Pizza

Poppy's Choice Traditional Round

Hawaiian Traditional Round

Meat Lovers Traditional Round

Veggie Traditional Round

BBQ Chicken Traditional Round

Pepperoni Parmesano Traditional Round

Chicken Bacon Ranch Traditional Round

Buffalo Chicken Traditional Round

Poppys Pies Detroit Style Pizza

Slices Pizza

Personal and Kids BYO Personal Pizza

Personal and Kids Poppy's Choice Pizza

Personal and Kids Veggie Pizza

Personal Kids' Meat Lovers Pizza

Personal Kids' Hawaiian Pizza

Personal/Kids BBQ Chicken

Small BYO Pizza

Small Poppy's Choice Pizza

Small Veggie Pizza

Small Meat Lovers Pizza

Small Hawaiian Pizza

Small BBQ Chicken

Large BYO Pizza

Large Poppy's Choice Pizza

Large Veggie Pizza

Large Meat Lovers Pizza

Large Hawaiian Pizza

Large BBQ Chicken

Hot Subs

6" Italian Sub

6" Ham & Cheese Sub

6" Turkey & Cheddar Sub

6" Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Sub

Specials

Personal and Kids Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Personal Special

Small Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Special

Large Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Special

Desserts

Caramel Cinnamon Bread

Choc Chip Grandma's Big Cookies

Peanut Butter Grandma's Big Cookies

Chocolate Brownie Grandma's Big Cookies

Oatmeal Rasin Grandma's Big Cookie

New York Cheesecake

Poppy's Zones Calzones

The Binx Calzone

The Nonna Calzone

Poppys Specialties

8 Pieces Cheese Bread Special

8 Pieces Garlic Parmesan Bread Special

Garlic Parmesan Breadstick's

Bae Baes Wings, KDs FF & Snacks

KD's French Fries

French Fries Plain

Boneless Wings

Bone In Wing Dings

Miehls Mozzerella Sticks (6)

Breaded Mushrooms

Beer Batter Onion Rings

Munchie Basket

Fried Pickle Chips

Salads

Small Antipasto Salad

Large Antipasto Salad

Chef Salad

Chef Salad Small

Garden Salad Small

Garden Salad Large

Poppy's Chicken Critter Salad

Sides of Sauces

Sides of Sauces

Energy Drinks

16 oz. Bang Cotton Candy

16 oz. Bang Unicorn