Pizzeria New York

The big mistake I made all those years ago was driving past this place, assuming it wasn't designed for the normal family. That, mainly because the bar next door was always flooded with the rowdy crowd that bled over into the front of this spot. End result? I missed years and years of enjoying some REALLY good New York style pizza.Keep in mind that I'm a Chicago Deep Dish style pizza, so if you're going to give me a different kind, you betta bring it! And I don't just mean the actual pie.My wife and I walked in and were prompted greeted by Ryan, the owner's son. He was a kind gentleman, eager to introduce us to his family's creation, sharing a bit about his family history and the development of their restaurant. We decided to eat in and order the house specialty: Paps Special. This consisted of sausage, pepperni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers and banana peppers. We hate mushrooms, so for a small amount, we subbed out the mushrooms for Old World Pepperoni.Wise decision.Mannnn, this pizza was delicious! Vegetables cut fresh, meat well-seasoned, pie cooked the perfect amount of time, crust with the right, buttery texture. It didn't take long to create it and I swear it took less time for the two of us to EAT it. We enjoyed it so much that days later, I was back to pick up two more for my family at home!...and yes, they loved it. My only disappointment was that my sons didn't want to ride down and eat it there (lazy buzzards). Nothing like pizza hot out of hell's fire...Check this place out and as always, be sure to tell 'em Kenny sent ya!

Worst service experience I have ever experienced. A bunch of kids ruining a business with terrible customer service and service skills. Food was good but the service sucked ass. I hope the owner of this business actually reads this review, you have lost customers today that was their first time and last. Food was good but not good enough, there are too many choices to come to a place like this and be treated this way.

authentic NYC pizza this place is delicious. i used to live in nyc and this pizza is the real deal. notches above chain pizza i highly recommend

Pepperoni Pizza On a scale of 1 to 10 I'd give this a 5. Don't expect it to taste like New York Pizza. New York Pizza

This small business doesn't care about customers. They use cheap ingredients, and cut corners wherever possible. Their pizza is barely edible, and the owner expects to sit on her heiny all day long while her underpaid underlings are expected to do all the work. I would never recommend this business to my worst enemy. I honestly don't know how this business is still chugging along. Please take my advice and stay clear of this business!

Pizzeria New York is not bad. It's exactly like it's authentic. This is still a pretty good try for Ohio. It sells pizza by the slice, weekdays at least. They also have sandwiches and subs. It didn't have any pizza by the slice on a weekend. It could have been out. They weren't that busy the last time. It's more of a carryout. They do have lots of seating. It looks kind of sparse inside. There's not much interesting going on. It has chairs and tables of course. There's a couple TVs on the walls. Besides that there isn't much of an atmosphere. This is reflected in how quiet the inside is. I had the vegetable sub. It's about $7 for the footlong. This is good even though it's not an excellent sub. I got it without cheese. Pizza sauce is good to add on this I could eat something from here again. Maybe not pay for it. They are kind of expensive for the amount the give you.

Great Pizza. Not like the usual thin crust Columbus-style. Friendly and fast service.

Best NY Pizza available love it to death Steeler fans as well!! But that's it

Closest you'll get to NY pizza in cbus. Not you cheap value pizza night but the quality is good.

Good option if you want to mix up pizza night! If you like NY style pizza, this is a decent option to get your fix. It definitely can't compete with the real deal but is close enough. Ordered a large cheese and large pepperoni for takeout and the family loved it.