Pizza Primo

For starters, the guys who run this store located at the corner of a small strip mall near 161 and North High Street are so friendly and welcoming. We ordered a large supreme and it was very tasty. Pizza Primo has mastered the signature cracker crust we Columbus natives grew up with and love so well. The sweet, slightly spicy sauce, small cut vegetable toppings (could have added more green peppers and onions :-)) with edge-to-edge placement make eating their square cut pieces especially enjoyable for children. They also offer a thick crust pizza as well, which looks great.

Did enjoy the large one topping pizza pepperoni for $12.50 on Monday and Tuesday nights Pizza Primo Worthington. I never had Pizza Primo Worthington until tonight. It was delicious and will get it again. It was not greasy and that was a great thing. Was very happy with my order and will go back to Pizza Primo Worthington soon.

If i could give this dump of a restaurant 0 stars i would. Paid $23 (including delivery) for a chicken parm calzone. Literally no chicken in it what so wver and had a very small amount of dried up & flavorless pepperoni. Then they go on to give me a big alluminum pan of just pizza or tomato sauce for dipping. The cheese was decent in the calzon but very little of that as well. Payed essentially $23 for a big piece of bread and a copius amount of canned marinara saice. Utter trash and sickened i spent $23. You serve crappy food and rip people off you deserve a brutal review

Looking for something quick near our hotel we went to Primos. We got a 12" meat pizza and individual spaghetti. The crust is thin, sauce is decent and service was quick. We enjoyed it. Will definitely be back if we are in the area.

As a first time customer, I really liked the pizza . They didn't overdo it on the tomato sauce. Could've had a little bit more pepperoni but they did put in enough pineapple. It did take a while for them to get to us but our pizza and dessert was hot and pop was cold. I am all for trying to support our local small businesses if it all possible. The person on the phone was very cordial and personable and my delivery guy was as well. To me, if you're ordering something the people are half the experience and the food is the other half. Two thumbs up on my end. I would order it again.

Picked up their large Pepperoni and I just wasn't feeling it. Lots of pepperoni but it didn't have much taste. The sauce was also blah and the crust was just too thin and crunchy--it was like eating cardboard, no thanks. Staff were friendly, that's about the only good thing I can say.

Paid extra for blue cheese and as you can see in photo its slightly sprinkled. Not enough regular cheese and it's just not great. Delivery from yelp on a Sunday at 9 and it took exactly an hour. All food was cold but even if hot it's just not good. Will not order here again.

Pizza okSalads awfulHad 2 times Same results$$$$Do not recommend This one in Worthington

I moved from Worthington years ago however, I still pick up my pizza from here. One of my favorites in the city. Taste great and location clean! Nicest people too!

Lived in the area for 5 years and just tried this. New favorite carry out place. We ordered a pepperoni pizza (Monday/Tuesday night special 1 topping), 5 traditional wings, and a small side salad. The pizza was great, thin crust and the sauce was amazing. Wings I was nervous about because they were a bit small but the flavor of the chicken was great. The salad could have used some work, was a tab old with some browning, I asked for no peppers but they forgot to remove the banana peppers and only took off the green bell peppers. Only con with the experience was the ordering, internet price is not updated so ordering on the phone was difficult and employee could have known the menu better. I also had my infant with me for pick up and an employee helped me to the car and was patient when I needed to strap him in first. Very grateful, we will definitely be back.