Pizza Cottage - Grove City

We went on a Friday night with a party of 9 and we were sat within 10 minutes. There were only a handful of other tables and I was shocked for prime dinner time on a Friday- until we ordered. We ordered a couple pepperoni pizzas and appetizers, boneless wings, and a burger. They brought the food out randomly and not all together, which was strange. One person got their food 30 minutes before the next and the cheeseburger took another 30 minutes after that. Food was decent, just wish we could have all enjoyed dinner together instead of intermittently over an hour time span. Pickerington is a farther drive, but we've never had these kinds of issues there.

Never tried pizza cottage before. They put this new one in Grove City and we thought we would give it a shot. We were not impressed. The pizza wasn't anything special at all. It was just ok. Nothing stands out about it. The BLT sun was pretty good. I'm kind of a sucker for BLT anything. The Italian sub was average. All in all it was just ok. There are so many other pizza places around that we really like so I doubt we will go back.

Since Pizza Cottage began using DoorDash for deliveries, it is yet another local pizza joint that has good pizzas that I'm crossing off my list. I guess the concept of getting a pizza delivered is being discouraged these days. I don't care how good your food is, if you choose to use a third-party deliverer and they constantly deliver cold, soggy pizza that has been sitting for 30 minutes, it REFLECTS ON PIZZA COTTAGE, not DoorDash. Several other Grove City businesses have also gone this route with poor results. I'm done with Pizza Cottage after tonight's debacle.

Service was fantastic! Our waiter was very friendly and polite. We ordered a cheese pizza and a sweet tai chili pizza. They were both really flavorful. The only take back was that the crust was really thin and crisp (which is not my favorite type of pizza, personally). Our children loved the cheese pizza and my husband and I thought the spicy tai chicken pizza was really flavorful and had a little kick to it (which we loved). We will definitely be back to try the other types of pizzas (there are a lot of different types, which makes it really fun).

I really enjoyed my visit here. Delicious pizza that took me by surprise since I've never been to one before. We also got the works without mushroom and that was just as good. The one major downfall was the appetizers came out after the pizza was served which was a disappointment. We got the jalapeño popers and moserella sticks for the appetizers. Other than that, I'd love to visit again to see how the subs and pasta taste.

Decided to check the Pizza Cottage out today. Not very many people there. We ordered a medium 1/2 pepperoni/mushroom and 1/2 peppers/mushrooms. Also got a garlic cheese bread. The garlic cheese bread was pretty good, plenty of cheese on top. The star of it was the dipping sauce, had crushed tomatoes with a nice spice in it. The pizza was a little too thin for me, a good amount of cheese which could have been cooked just a little longer, good amount of mushrooms, the pepperoni they are using had very little flavor to it. It curled up like Ezzo's but no taste. On to service which was totally lacking. Not a whole lot of people in the place but the servers were all out of site the majority of the time. Our server Justice went missing after delivering the check, another server went by us a number of times and finally asked where our server was. She finally tracked her down so we could pay our bill. Also be aware they have a supply chain surcharge they add to your bill.

I decided to check Pizza Cottage. Ordered pickup drive thru and it was ok. Online order said 35 minutes it will be ready and it was. I ordered 10" pepperoni pizza with Sicilian thick crust $11.99, chocolate chip cookie $2.99 I think and cheesy garlic bread with extra pizza sauce and garlic sauce. Totaled around $21.00 with tax, no tip since I picked it up. Friendly staff. Food was hot and fresh but didn't impress me. Pizza sauce was weak and somewhat watered down, crust was over cooked and dry in both pizza and cheesy garlic bread. When website said well done I didn't think it would be dry, blackened crust. The cheese, pepperoni slices and garlic butter sauce was nice. The taste just didn't impress me enough to desire to come back. Maybe nice for others but not me.

Went to this location after waiting for a pizza that never delivered from Donatos. Pizza and appetizer was fresh and hot! Customer service was great! Will be considering pizza cottage first before ordering delivery.

The service was awful. Misty took a tables order before us, waited for their food to be brought out, THEN took our order. The table was finished eating before we even got our drinks. There was what sounded like a phone alarm going off every 5 minutes the whole time. Awful.

Pizza well good! Mozzarella sticks were fantastic! Great customer service! Cookie seemed a little stale. Other than that would highly recommend.