Pioneer Pizza
Pioneer Pizza
a bowl of doughnuts and a container of sauce
a pepperoni pizza in a box
a box of baked potatoes and dipping sauce
12" Medium Old Fashioned
the front of the restaurant at night
a pepperoni pizza in a box
Back dining area & bar.
Old fashioned pep with mushrooms
Menu
Menu
One of the best! Pep, sausage, half Jalapeño!
Fried pickles
Deluxe minus onions
Ham and pineapple
Pizza box
Italian sun
Gluten free pizza
Lg. All The way.
Pep,banana peppers, onion! Delicious!
Hawaiian pizza
Great Pizza!!!
Delicious
"All the Way" Pizza. Half gone cuz we started in the car on the way home.
Delicious as always!!
Michael B.
Jan 9, 2023
After our first choice turned out to be closed, we thought we'd try Pioneer. We went during the college football championship & the place was empty. (Monday night). One waitress, who was kind, but a little slow on service, was the only one in the dining area. The lg. "All the Way" was good, but had so many toppings on it, you could've made a salad with what fell off. Good sauce, crunchy crust, PLENTY of toppings. Price was a little high, but the taste was worth it. Restaurant was nice & had a cool look to it. Stage out back for live music, too. Cool vibe to the place. Overall, I'd say it was okay. Like I said, the pizza had WAY too many toppings on it. Most of which was onion. But it looked like a cool place to hang out for a while. Next time I'll get a Stromboli, though.
Read More
Julie W.
Nov 14, 2023
Carry out order: The customer service from call in to pick up was great. The pizza was delicious and each bite was full of toppings. They ran out of a certain size and upgraded us.
Read More
Casey G.
Jun 10, 2023
We had a gift card and finally got to use it. The restaurant is sectioned off into a to-go pickup area, a small dining space, a bar area, and then a large outdoor patio with stage they share with a brewery. We got to try a salad, pizza, chicken wings, and potato skins. The salad and potato skins were so-so. The pizza and chicken wings were delicious! The service was fast for how much we ordered and brought to our table. They have a local lottery dispenser in the bar area, with a jukebox. This is a fun spot to hang out in the Plain City area.
Read More
Amanda D.
Aug 24, 2021
This is really good pizza. Not a huge chain. It's good, hometown pizza. Great ingredients. They never skimp. Got the "all the way" pizza and boy was it good. The sausage is to die for. The crust is nice and crispy on the edges. Kind of a hand tossed style. The Italian sun was really good too. Great bread and a good amount of meat and veggies. The dressing was good. We drove it hole to Galloway and it was still absolutely delicious.
Read More
James V.
Dec 22, 2021
Local institution in Plain City! Smooth experience ordering online then picking up. Pizza was delicious. Quality ingredients well prepared. Loved the mild sweetness in the sauce and old world pepperonis.
Read More
David F.
Aug 1, 2023
Didn't know what to expect but was very happy with our food. Took a minute to figure out exactly how to get in the place as there is a nice big outdoor area, but I'm not sure Pioneer is part of that. The shop itself was very clean and well kept. A set of doors that looked like they went to the kitchen turned out to be the way to the front counter. Ordered wings, a meatball sub and a salad. Accidentally left my credit card on the counter(thanks to the guy who followed me down the block to return it!). On to the food..... The wing deal got us a bunch of wings for under 10 bucks. The wings were cooked well but just a little too much sauce but easily brushed off. Tasted great and were cooked well. The sub was great meatballs tasted good and loved the sauce. Overall good place and we would go there again if in the area.
Read More
Tls K.
Aug 10, 2021
Located in "downtown" Plain City at the Northwest corner of Chilicothe & 161. We parallel parked on the street in front if the restaurant. The pizza restaurant shares a space with a bar and an adjoining patio. We were directed to sit in the pizza side so tbe other half was not explored. It was pushing 1p0° outside when we entered the artic circle that is pioneer pizza. Two of the four in our party got blankets from the car and wrapped up to ward off frost bite. Im not kidding - dress appropriately. You have been warmed.My pizza was FANTASTIC!. We had the buffalo chicken made with Franks Hot Sauce. It had a nice kick without killing the diner's mouth. My kiddo ordered the stromboli. He selected pepperoni and home made sausage as his fillings. Red sauce was served on the side. I tasted the crust & red sauce. Both were solid but nothing special. Hubs ordered the sweet thin crust pizza with the traditional red sauce with old world pepperoni and banana peppers.The pepperoni was not crispy and did not curl up. Either it was either undercooked or they gave him traditional pepperoni. Finally, I ordered the pizza pictured. The BBQ sauce was excellent. Reminded me if Sweet Bany Ray's. They offer both fresh and canned mushrooms. I'm all about canned and they nailed it with the combination of white & yellow cheese! We both agree the sweet crust was lost. Everyone liked their pizza but I'm the only one that loved their pizza. The menu offered salads, subs, appetizers, speciality pizza, "box" pizza, thin crust, cauliflower crust, and more plus a plethora of topping to choose from in tbe build your own menu. I wil return dressed warmer and order my created pizza again. My husband would like to try the box pizza but would order the same pizza again.
Read More
Steven P.
Jun 25, 2022
Okay keto people. This is a great place to change it up. They offer keto friendly items. Cauliflower crust, or crustless pizza any way you want it. And bone in wings without breading. Good prices, and good food.
Read More
Paul K.
May 13, 2023
My buddy and I popped in on a Thursday evening. We sat at the bar, and after some confused looks from the barmaid, we got some beers. They don't have a list or beer menu, and most of their coolers don't have glass, so it was a back and forth. Do you have Molson...no....do you have Heineken...no... This went on for some time and we ended up with a Miller Lite and a Michelob Ultra. Fail. Then we ordered a peperoni pizza. It came out hot and fast, but it wasn't anything special. The sauce was bland, and the crust was dry and flavorless. Barely better than a frozen pizza. I'm giving this palce a three because they do have a great location and lots of buzz. They share a large outdoor seating area with The Grainery - apparently they also share an owner - and with a band going it was a nice place to be. Our barmaid was definitely enjoying it, as she was drinking way more than us by spiking her soda. Nice. I wanted to love this place, but left feeling lukewarm.
Read More
Madison P.
Jul 28, 2024
Food was okay, but customer service was terrible. The girls were rude and acted like I was bothering them by ordering food at the restaurant. Ordered on 7/27 at 2pm. It was a festival night in plain city, (before the craziness started). I had a menu snatched out of my hands when I started looking at it. Maybe get a new job if you hate it so much. Didn't meet one worker that was nice. Will not return.
Read More
