Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH
Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH
Large half peppadew half classic pie
GF Peppadew Pie
Menu
Menu
16 oz. Cup of Draft Rootbeer
Sm. Margherita Pie, @GF Peppadew Pie
Beer
Lg. Chicken Gouda Pie
Lg. Peppadew Pie
16" pie - Half Grape & Gorgonzola, half Mozzarella Caprese
Lg. Classic Pie (half minus mushrooms)
Steak and Cheese Sandwich
Char-grilled wings.
Large half peppadew half classic pie
food, salads, salad
Large half peppadew half classic pie
White pizza with Roma tomatoes & spinach
Char Grilled Hot Wings
food, pizza
Char-Grilled Hot Wings
Sm. Classic Pie
Steak and Cheese Sandwich
Char Grilled Hot Wings; Chips and Salsa
Becca O.
Feb 2, 2024
Always good eats at Pies and Pints! We headed in for a quick stop and waited only 10-15 minutes for a table at peak hours on a Friday. The restaurant was busy but not loud. Our waitress, Brandi, was super attentive and anticipated our needs and provided speedy service! Unfortunately when a gentleman greeted us at the door he wasn't exactly inviting; he didn't say hello or ask us anything he just expected us to spit a number out at him I guess. Brandi turned my mindset around and I appreciate her work ethic and attitude!The peppadew pie was salty, sweet and a touch spicy, the perfect combo for anyone! My sister enjoyed her Margherita pie and said it was cheesy and cooked perfectly! We'd also recommend their root beer that they have on draft! They have Coke products and an extensive rotating menu for drafts and bottles. Ciders available for gluten free folks, as well as pizza and icons on the menu!
Read More
Dave C.
Jan 4, 2025
Our "go-to" pizza place. Sit at the bar when we can. Bartender(can't recall her name), gives great recommendations on their beers & ciders on tap. Wife loves the cheesy garlic bread, and the Margarita pizza is the bomb.
Read More
Anna H.
Jun 6, 2022
First time here: arrived for happy hour and pizza on a Wednesday. The table on the patio and inside were busy but only a few at the bar. The happy hour wine is very limited but I chose a red. The beer selection is extensive. I already had my eye on the Thai pizza that I saw on the online menu. I got a large to go. Yikes, it was $26! It was really great, had plenty of shrimp, and I would get it again. Minor complaint: the bar seating is not comfortable. I noticed they are the same at the dining area tables. I don't want to sit there long.
Read More
Wing Yan K.
Apr 17, 2022
Great place to hang out to grab a drink and slice of pie for the weekend. They have a wide range of House and Specialty pie options.I really like the Thai Pie. The Thai curry sauce complement very well on the pie. Along with the hint of lime, cilantro and basil, it take it up a notch.
Read More
Chris R.
Dec 4, 2023
Absolutely horrible service and zero customer service at this location. The atmosphere gave off a really weird vibe. Took us forever to get seated because the host never appeared but there were three employees just hanging out at the bar, the gentleman who I assume was the manager finally finished playing in his phone and decided to turnaround and seat us. They weren't busy at all and a server never came to our table so we just got up and left. Such a bummer because the pizza looked amazing online. Sadly we would never think about returning.
Read More
Leah U.
Sep 6, 2023
We ordered delivery from Grubhub from Pies and Pints. We called the restaurant to order delivery and they helped me figure all of the logistics of how to order using the app. I'm not from the city so there's no delivery where I'm from. They were all super sweet!!! Now onto the good stuff, the pies!!! Amazing!! I had the cauliflower crust chicken Gouda and I cannot tell you how pleasantly pleased I was at the flavor of this pizza. I was really worried about the crust but it is honestly better than a regular crust. Get any of them and try them. I don't think you'll be disappointed. My husband had the regular crust classic pie and devoured the whole thing. We also had the Greek salad and we would definitely get it again. All things considered, I would eat here every week if I lived close enough!!!
Read More
Ruth R.
Jul 29, 2023
The service is always friendly and efficient I appreciate their consistency. The pies are large and in charge with great flavor. It's a great place for a date or a family hangout. The times that we have eaten there it's been pretty relaxed the music isn't too loud, it was enjoyable to be able to have conversations without having to raise your voice
Read More
Katie H.
Dec 12, 2022
Delicious pizza! We arrived just after 8 on a Saturday night and there were plenty of people inside but we did not have to wait at all for a table. Ordered a 16" with half of two of their specialty pies. Note - if you want to get half and half you have to order a 16", as they do not allow splitting that way on the 10" pizzas. There were several tantalizing-sounding options but we opted for half grape and Gorgonzola and half mozzarella caprese. Both were flavorful and fresh...grapes should not work on a pizza but they totally do! Service was great as well. The only caveat is the price - $25 is a bit steep but hey, it's unique and tasty. We'll be back!
Read More
Douglas D.
Dec 20, 2024
The service is usually great but not always especially at night. We stopped visiting for about a year! We were willing to give this location another chance and for a while it seemed better! We had another bad experience so we won't be back. Spoke with management directly at time of visit, which was shrugged off.
Read More
Bruce H.
Sep 30, 2024
Great atmosphere, service capped off with great tasting food. Beer selection is very good also!
Read More
