Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta

This place has amazing pizza. I've been there several times throughout the year and each time the pizza is amazing and I can't wait to go back every week. This is a mom and Pop operation and they care about their customers. I think that it is the best pizza place in Westerville.

We first discovered Pasquale's Pizza + Pasta a few months ago while visiting an Asian restaurant next door. While waiting on our food we kept noticing a lot of customers coming and going from Pasquale's and thought, they must have something good going on there . We made a mental note to try them out one day...Well that day finally arrived . We decided to give them a try for our Friday night dinner. We placed an order online for a Large pepperoni + sausage pizza. Their online portal was very user friendly, which made it easy to place an order + pay. We were advised that our order would be ready in 15 to 30 mins, and it was. We don't live very close to Pasquale's so it did require us to take the freeway to get there, however no more than a 15 minute ride. When I went inside to pick up the pizza, I noticed this place was jumpin' . It's a very small mom + pop restaurant, however it didn't stop them from having a dining room full of customers who were dining in, and about 15 staff behind the counter completing orders. I approached the counter and was pleasantly greeted by a happy, smiling young lady. I received my order and made a mad dash out the door to see how fast I could get home before this pizza turns completely cold. ‍First impression was that this pizza smelled great! It was evenly layered with pepperoni + sausage, and just the right amount of cheese. PROS: Not overly salty; pleasant sauce, not too tangy or overbearing; this was truly a large size pizza, more than enough for two people to share. CONS: Some of the pieces were burnt on the edges; the pizza seasoning is a little too strong for our taste buds. Overall Pasquale's Pizza + Pasta has pretty decent pizza. I would definitely like to try them again to sample their pasta. Something tells me that's where I'm gonna find a hidden gem .

Oh, this kills me to leave this review because everyone at this restaurant was so nice. but the entire dining experience was off.First we were lucky to get a table. Pasquales has a small dining room. Tiny. Seats maybe 7-8 different parties. We got the last open table. The entire time we were there takeout steadily flowed and a line to dine in formed. They have a lot to choose from: salads, pizza, subs, pasta dishes etc. large case of bakery items. We ordered a pepperoni mushroom pizza. It took a reasonable amount of time to get the pizza which was amazing it didnt take longer as we sat down at the same time as two other parties. Our server then had a ton of take out orders right after we sat down--- people were running her hard, lots of orders flying into the kitchen. It was super busy. Looking at our pizza I was sad. They used so much pepperoni on this pizza. It rivaled Donatos edge to edge pepperoni in pep quantity. Sounds like its not a problem, right? Wrong! Remember this was a mushroom/pepperoni pizza. There were hardly any mushrooms. I know this because I peeled off all the pepperoni off my three pieces because I don't really like pepperoni, my husband does. I was lucky if I found two pieces on a slice and what I found were not large slices of mushrooms either. What little mushrooms were on it were drowned out by the greasy pepperoni. You literally "had" to peel off pepperoni to find and taste mushrooms. Oh so disappointing. Then there was the sauce issue: the sauce even tastes like its changed. It lacks depth in flavor meaning I cant taste any spices. I stopped eating the pizza after two and a half squares. When my husband was done I looked at what was left and noticed this was probably one of the greasiest pizzas we had ever had there. It just feels like they have cut corners while also raising prices. The whole visit was just weird and so opposite of the our visit last summer. Husband asked if I wanted Canoli... I really like their Canoli. I actually passed. By that point I was completely ready to leave. Id say this is a solid 3 out of 5 The waitress was amazingly good.

My wife and I wanted to try a new place for pizza and decided to try this place based upon yelp rating. We ordered a meat pizza and substituted one topping for mushrooms and they did not charge extra. That is a bonus in my book as many place still charge for extra toppings even if you leave one off that is included in the price. The pizza came out quick and was hot! We enjoyed the pizza a lot. while not any problem with the pizza, not our most favorite. Plan to return to try pasta dishes as well. The service was outstanding! My drink never hit bottom. The place is rustic but clean and in good order. I would go back in a heart beat.

Amazing pizza. I love their crust, it's crispy in the outside, and soft in the middle. The put loads of cheese on it too, unlike most of the corporate chain pizza restaurants. Their sauce is also made from scratch, in house.I highly recommend ordering one large meatball with your pizza or entrée. It comes covered in their homemade sauce, and it falls apart in your mouth. It's not tough and chewy like mane other meatballs I've had at other Italian restaurants. Their salad are great, and they make their own Italian Dressing, if you like that. Very tasty!Finally, they have a glass case full of desserts which are also delicious. Plus everyone there is friendly, and the service is fast and accurate. I eat here 3x a month in my lunch breaks too. I highly recommend it!

Called to place an order was told it would be done in an hour. It was Friday night so I had no problem waiting. When I arrived there wasn't much parking and the restaurant felt like it was full to the brim. People everywhere and it felt like there was no space. Waited in line to pick up. Some people in line where placing an order some where picking up. Not very organized it seemed. When I looked up their menu online it had no desserts listed but when I got there I saw they had cannolis. From far away they looked average size so when I asked to add two to my order I was definitely surprised to have to mini cannolis. They were alright. Felt like they had been sitting for a long while. The girl who was helping me seemed irritated that I added them on. Pizza was good! The pizza sauce is a sweeter red sauce. Would go back!

Pasquale's is one of the little gems in the city of Westerville. The food is outstanding and the service is always friendly. My personal favorite is the baked chicken salad but the pizzas are outstanding, as is the pasta. The prices are very reasonable as well. You can't go wrong at Pasquale's

The food is very very good, It will definitely fill you up. I actually know the owners, It is a family owned pizzaria and they are great people.

Pasquale's Pizza is hands down some of the best pizza around. You can taste the tradition and passion in every bite--family values run deep here, and it shows. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it the perfect place to gather with loved ones. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, you're treated like family. If you're looking for amazing pizza and a place that feels like home, Pasquale's is where you want to be.

Hidden gem, family owned business! I travel for work and whenever I am in the area I always have to have Pasquale's pizza. One of the best pizza's I've ever had and I've had a lot from a lot of different places. Consistently delicious! Highly recommend.