Panzera's Pizza

Great pizza. Old school pizzeria and ovens. They know how to make a reasonable and traditional pizza.

I stopped by here on a whim after working at a market nearby and was so incredibly impressed that I went out of my way to go back another day. The crust is so thin and crispy but not like a cracker, it still has that chewy texture I love in pizza dough. The sauce has a nice flavor and consistency and they don't put too much on. I was incredibly surprised by this unassuming place and pizza and will gladly be back in the future. I had great quick service both times I've visited as well.

Another recent find due to Experience Columbus' Pizza Trail. The pizza is really good, with more pepper than you usually get from a pizza place, so it has some nice heat to it, and the cheese is perfectly melty.I did take out, but they also seem to have a nice patio if you want to eat your pizza out of a box outdoors and people-watch. The app they use is fine for ordering and terrible at tracking the actual order status, so if it says your pizza will be ready at a certain time, I would trust that instead of the tracker.

Loved this pizza. First time trying Panzerra's and really enjoyed the crust, the sauce and cheese. Our pizza was an extra sauce, extra cheese pizza. We ordered a large which was enough for 2-3 people. The sauce was flavorful and the perfect amount of cheese. I would order here again

This pizza was really delicious. The sauce was flavorful and the sausage and tomato toppings were generously proportioned and fresh. We ordered a 13" pizza and two of us split it for dinner; there were no leftovers, but we also weren't left hungry.The biggest issue for us was that staff weren't wearing masks correctly or at all. The person at the counter had a mask, but only over their mouth. And, the guy making the pizza had his mask down around his chin. They clearly know they're supposed to be wearing masks, but couldn't put in the effort to do it right. While I doubt we'll get sick from our brief interaction with them in the store during our pickup, this just made us trust them and their cleanliness a bit less.

Ordered a pizza for my family for takeout. I arrived and went inside while my husband waited in the car. The clerk was talking to a friend/patron at the counter and I was not acknowledged. I grabbed a water and waited for the clerk to finish his discussion. Five minutes went by and I placed my water on the counter, hoping I would be served. They kept talking and was joined by a woman. I stayed a few more minutes and left. I ordered Westside Slice. I was never even glanced at. My hungry toddlers had to wait with my husband and got no pizza. Whatever was going on with that clerk in how he ignored me blows my mind. Very rude and arrogant. Never again.

Pizza was fine. Not my taste. Biggest win for this location: low prices (esp garlic bread & soda)Staff is great and very friendly.

More toppings on a Stouffers French bread pizza. I have noticed this from other pizza places as well (Iaconos and Sparano's) last few months. Not sure if it's due to inflation or what the reason. But very disappointed for the price we paid for a large and a small pizza (38 dollars) . With all the options around, will not return here. They skimped on the toppings so much I could have eaten the entire large. Ordered extra sauce and you would have thought I told them light on the sauce. If you desperate one evening because Rotolos is closed by 9 and you want a pizza, then this will be OK in a pinch but don't be prepared to be impressed. Tommy's and Benny's Pizza will continue to be the go to places for me. And Adriatico's.The pictures I see in other reviews (28 days ago). in the past did not look like my pizza. Not even close and that one had extra sauce on it. It actually looked pretty good.I feel violated.

Damn Good pizza. Crust is crispy, sauce is sweet and has this almost wine reduction taste to it that is fantastic. As a guy who likes light sauce on pizza, even I would recommend to get extra sauce as they go very light on sauce.Overall, this will be a regular of mine now. So Give this place a try and support a small business. You will not regret it.

If I could 0 stars I would. DO NOT EAT HERE. As soon as I pulled up, Carlo, creepily stared at me for several minutes as I looked through their menu. Carlo then came out and told me to "figure it out quickly" or to leave their parking lot. Carlo is apparently the owner**** (should close up and find a new hobby). The only reason I was there was to complete the Columbus Pizza Trail. Quite frankly, I will NOT be trying Panzera due to Carlo's rude hospitality. Panzera should get off of the pizza trail if they don't want new customers. There were 9 of us looking forward to trying their pizza, but they clearly did not want our business. And we clearly don't want to spend our money here. Check out Grandads Pizza that's right down the street, that was awesome service and some awesome pizza. (See picture below for Carlo.)