Panther Pizza & Ice Cream

I highly recommend Panther Pizza. Noelle and her crew do an excellent job of offering that little extra that makes this establishment the go-to place for anything you need besides their excellent award-winning pizza. They offer subs, wings, appetizers, and ice creams. Want to try something new? They offer free samples of pizzas when you stop on to pick up your order. You can also eat-in, or have it delivered. Live outside the Licking Valley area? I highly recommend you make the little extra drive Hanover to check this place out.

Ordered pizza and it was wonderful! It was full of toppings, perfectly cookies, amazing. The employees working were decently nice. We got the stuffed crust pizza and i ate 2 pieces and I was full, and I'm a fat man lol. That thing was STUFFED with cheese. We got 2 All the Way pizzas and they were really good, delicious, full of toppings. I swear the 3 pizzas we got was 10 lbs. I drove 45 minutes for this pizza and it's definitely worth it. I forgot to take pictures as I was stuffing my face full. I will be coming back

We read a lot of great reviews about Panther Pizza so wanted to try it ourselves. It was a 45 minute drive each way but had to check it out! We ordered a pepperoni pizza, a Chicago style pizza and some desserts. The pepperoni pizza was good but we didn't care for the Chicago pizza. It was very heavy (which is always a plus ) but the crust was way too thick for us. We've had Chicago style pizza several times before so the crust is thick to an extent. But this crust was way beyond what we expected in thickness. It took away from the flavor of the pizza for us. What did stand out from what we ordered were the desserts! They were extremely reasonable in price and that alone would have us taking a trip out to see them! They were all so yummy and we loved the selection. 10-15 different desserts to choose from. Outside of a bakery, I've never seen that many options at a pizza shop or any restaurant! Make sure you pick up a piece!

Omg. This pizza is absolutely worth traveling off the beaten path for. The "haus" (pronounced hoss by the staff" is absolutely my favorite pizza ever. The staff are friendly and the selection of home made desserts are just to die for. If you haven't tried this place yet, what are you waiting for?

Visiting from out of town and found this little pizza shop so decided to give it a try. Staff was super friendly, suggestive and patient to my questions. Ordered the Stromboli and slice of apple crisp pie and neither disappointed. Stromboli was crisp and filled with great meats and the apple crisp pie was just like homemade. I'll be here all week and looking forward to coming back to try the Chicago style deep dish. Highly recommend this local pizza place.

My favorite hometown pizza place. Never disappoints I grew up eating here and taste just as good every time I order. Panther is the best. They have amazing variety pizza, subs, desserts and shakes. Definitely recommend there big cookies always baked to perfection.

The food is amazing and I am in love with their mac bites! The service was pretty fast and the servers are very nice and sweet. The place is very cute and they keep it very clean!

Would do a negative rating if I could. my last two orders were awful. I ordered two pizzas and they sent one out by mistake for delivery. They then ran my one pizza back through the cooker while they replaced the first one. The second was burnt and was awful. just ordered a salad. Got there to pick it up and they said "we are still cooking your bread". I didn't order bread. Waited ten minutes and finally said just give me my damn salad please. Got my salad with no bread and was asked if I wanted to give a tip. they seem to hire junior high kids that aren't ready to run a business.

Made us wait on hold for 15 minutes then when we called back instantly put us on hold. Thank you for screwing us over when we tried to give back to a local spot.

Seriously awesome pizza. Definitely my favorite. Makes me hungry thinking about it....I swear that is the best crust on any pizza in central Ohio.