Nick's Pizza

Liked the pizza the first time I had it, so I went back a second, and last time. I'd been working outside all day, and my boots were a bit muddy. "You can't come in here with them boots like at." And, I never went back, this is the country, we get dirty, we may have one of several kinds of dirt on our boots in the middle of the day, any weekday! It's not like this place is even remotely Michelin material. I'll never darken their door again.

I've been eating Nick's Pizza for years and love it. My usual is a Pepperoni Pizza and an order of Loaded Taters. The taters are mashed potato puffs that are covered with cheese and bacon and served with ranch dressing. Greasy goodness there. The pizza is what I consider Eastern Ohio pizza, thicker than the think cracker crust that you can get at a chain place, but thinner than hand tossed. Their sauce is sweet, but has a spiciness to it. Soo much cheese! Seriously, if you are ever in St. Louisville, you must stop.

Nicks Pizza is my favorite pizza place ever. It's a family owned pizza place that I grew up on. Most people in the area think it's the best place ever. But if you plan to go on a Friday night or Saturday night call ahead or you'll be waiting a while. It's worth the wait though.

Ate there once and the Pizza was not worth the 45 minutes we had to wait for it.. Very greasy and the crust was pretty much card board. Toppings were decent though. Service was ok.overall I was not impressed by this place. Heard a lot of good things but unfortunately for me my experience was nothing to brag about. Will never go back

Awesome pizza! One of my favorite pizza places. The toppings are fresh; the wait is rarely more than 25 minutes; and you can eat there or take it home. The crust is thin and crisp. If you like Elm's in Granville or Plaza Pizza in Newark, you'll love Nick's in Saint Louisville. Great value for the price, too. Excellent tomato sauce and their "all the way" is my favorite. David H.

My family and I love this place. Not fancy but very good pizza, subs etc. we have been coming here for years and it is always good. But can be very busy! So sometimes ordering ahead is good to do!!

Pizza has a Nice spicy sauce lots of garlic to it, thin cracker crust,best cheese,best pepperoni. The Stromboli is Great with the same spicy pizza sauce on the side. pepperoni & cheese bread sticks are my go to item with sauce on the side too. Pizza can be to thin at times and a bit over priced with sometimes an hour wait. Does not accept credit or debit cards WTF? Bring cash! It's worth it.