Nazareth Restaurant & Catering

I've gone here about 3 times, and each time I have highly enjoyed the food! I usually have the falafels - whether in a sandwich or a platter - because they're so good! You can tell they are fresh. I've also enjoyed the hummus, tzaziki, and baba ganoush. They were all great, but my favorite is probably the tzaziki. The pita they bring you is warm and good too. Lots of vegetarian options! Service is always great. The food comes out faster than expected. I enjoy coming to this place whenevr I'm in the area, and I highly reccommed!

Hubby and I haven't been here for a while and glad we went for lunch today. The seating was comfortable and ambiance inviting.I ordered a bowl of lentils soup and a Kafta sandwich. Both were very tasty and very fresh. Our server was very efficient and pleasant.

I met three friends here for lunch - on Tuesday since they're closed on Mondays. We came at 11:30 and had no trouble finding seating. The waitress was prompt, attentive and friendly. She took our drink orders as we arrived.The menu was extensive with lots to pick from. While it was springtime, it was rainy and chilly out so I was looking for some comfort food. I ended up going with the lentil soup. Our group orders were varied and also included a couple appetizers. I did try some of the hummus and it was really good - along with the pita bread.I am a thirsty person and the waitress did a great job of keeping my diet soda glass filled. Our orders all came out together and quite timely. Everything was accurate and hot. My lentil soup was REALLY good. I got the bowl and it was a decent sized serving. I finished eating somewhere in the middle - not first or last of the eaters. That's perfect for what I wanted - a lighter yet warm lunch but didn't want to finish quickly and watch others eat.The waitress did a nice job of clearing the table and bringing containers to take home leftovers. Cashing out was really quick and easy as she could run our cards at the table and cash us out on the spot. She also didn't seem put out that we each wanted a separate bill.I definitely will return. It's a good location for me - I live in Gahanna over by Easton but now that the construction on that part of Hamilton Rd is done - I can get over there in less than 10 minutes and parking is right outside.

Nazareth Gyro Rotisserie grilled beef & lamb combination served on warm Pita bread with onion, lettuce, and mild banana peppers, topped with our famous house dressing Fresh cut fries I wasn't too impressed with the Gyro. I will try something else if I go again

Really loved this place. Extremely authentic and great quality food. Atmosphere was great with live music and quick service. Very large portions with tons of food. Went with a couple people and got the lamb bowl, steak kabobs with hummus, gyro, and dips. As well as had cashew fingers which were a nice treat. Really loved all the dips and gyro meat. Everything was great quality and you can tell the hard work/quality ingredients. Defs recommend

Great food and good ambiance. Party had the following entrees: spicy chicken, beef kabobs, chicken gyro. We also had the following sides: Greek salad, pita & hummus and grape leaves. Highly recommend this place. If I could, I'd give it a 4.5/5.0.

This was my first return visit to Nazareth Restaurant since I reviewed it last year. When "going back" to a restaurant, I always fear it won't be as good as I remembered and that maybe I've built it up too much in my memory. But, Nazareth was as good this time as it was last year. Everything I said in my original review is still true.It still deserves a 5-star rating.We were there again on a Friday night as part of a group of 20 people (a dine-out group from our church). There again was a single server handling our group who did a phenomenal job of serving our group. She was very organized, all the orders were correct and everything was served VERY QUICKLY. (NOTE - they DO NOT have a liquor license - so it's strictly soft drinks, iced tea, and lemonade). The service was excellent with minimal wait times - DESPITE the size of our group. Service was definitely 5-star.As for the food, our group ordered a wide variety of appetizers and entrees and everyone was pleased with their orders. I had the spicy gyro platter with fries. Both were exceptionally good. My wife ordered a small entree of stuffed grape leaves (4). She said her grape leaves were also excellent.

I havent eaten here in at least a year and I have no idea why... I went the other day with my daughter and mother in law and it was amazing! My M-I-L got the vegetarian platter and I got the falafel pita sandwich and a side of fries. Word to the wide, get the small size fries, they give you so much amazing goodness that you'll want to eat it all and I'm sure you'll be wayyy too full if you had anything. Else to eat! The other thing that surprises us what the veg platter... it's enough for 2-3 people. For real... I was so full from mine that I couldn't really assist, but everything was great!Service was good too. Quick, friendly and tolerated my crazy toddler!

I dunno, y'all. I'm a little concerned that this place gets such great reviews. I'm kind of guessing that this is what passes for Really Good Middle Eastern Food in the Columbus suburbs. But dang it, y'all, whether you realize it or not, you can do considerably better, imho.I got a gyro sandwich with a Greek salad. The salad was kind of overdone with just plain iceberg lettuce, and while the dressing was good, it went to waste on the lettuce before it could seep down to the tomatoes and such. The gyro was fine, but there was waaaay too much lettuce on top, and waaaay too little basket below to catch all the stuff that kept falling out of the overstuffed pita. The sauce was OK, the onions were bland. My wife got a Greek salad with no onions (?!?) and gyro meat for added protein. She said it was fine, but she was sad about the lettuce to other stuff ratio, too, and she thought the dressing was kind of meh. The service was OK. The store is clean and attractive. Parking is adequate. I dunno. This is kind of borderline for me. I like Lavash much better.

Four of us shared a comfortable booth, and had excellent service. It was not our first time there. Their chicken and rice is delicious as is the sauce on the side. Another person had a chicken gyro and loved it too. The Greek salad was an artful mix of a ball of feta, tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, calamata olives and cukes, a beautiful presentation. The hoummus is a perfect consistency with adequate pita sliced. Onion rings were very crispy and delish. Baklava slices went home for later. Can't wait to return!!