Mrs. Goodman's Baking

Love love love!!! Affordable, delicious, customizable, you name it. The cake was delicious, and the service is always so nice. Every employee I've talked to has been great. Thank you!

They did a great job with a custom order. I had 2 dozen cookies with different designs. It ended up being $4 a cookie, which seems pricey, but the cookies were large and very delicious. My guests raved. The shop is really cute and they do cakes, other pastries, cupcakes and cookies

I love Mrs. Goodman's and cannot recommend enough! I placed a custom order for a party plater of desserts for a 25th birthday and they did a great job following the directions. They can be busy when visiting in person and there is not a lot of space to sit down, it is better to grab and go. The environment is clean. Their products are always fresh and consistent, I am always looking forward to coming here to grab something for family, friends, or even myself. Glad I found this little gem in Columbus.

Got a birthday cake for my son's 6th birthday and it was fantastic. It looked amazing, tasted amazing, and was a huge hit!Pick up and ordering was super easy. Will definitely be getting from here again.

We have now ordered birthday cakes from Mrs. Goodman's on 2 separate occasions, and on both occasions, we loved the cakes we ordered. Mrs. Goodman's does a fantastic job with the cake designs, and they pay great attention to details. It also helps that the cakes are delicious - the chocolate cake is one of the best I have had in Columbus with just the right level of sweetness in the buttercream frosting. The place was moderately busy when we visited, but the staff was very patient and thorough with us while we asked our questions and placed our orders. We tried a few of their cupcakes, scones, cookies, and an apple pie, and one can taste the freshness in all these products. I highly recommend this bakery, and look forward to many more visits here.

We love Mrs. Goodman's baking. We have been there few times and every time we go there we end up buying more then what we wanted to. Everything there is just delicious. We ordered a unicorn birthday cake from there. Not only it looks amazing, but it tastes delicious. Everything we have tasted is just delicious. But the level of service is just amazing. Everyone there is super friendly and helpful. Can't recommend this place enough!

Hands down, this is the best cupcake and cookie in Columbus. Awesome service, delicious food and a must stop when in Worthington. We were served by Taylor and she was awesome. Great insights into their products, friendly and welcoming.

Fantastic cookies. They are all I've tried so far. Treat yourself to the oatmeal butterscotch! Superb

We ordered our wedding cakes through Mrs. Goodman's and they were delicious, beautiful, and our guests raved about how fantastic the cakes were. Many people went back for a second or third slice! They were great to communicate with prior to the big day as we completed our order. We will definitely be ordering all future cakes for special events from Mrs. Goodman's.

Mrs. Goodman's is our favorite bakery and has been for years. Today, I picked up my order and they surprised me with a design that was modified to fit my budget. I was thrilled. The designers are very talented- check out their social media pages to see what they can do! We love the quality of their buttercream and other baked goods too. Especially the pecan and cinnamon rolls.