Michael Angelo's Pizza

Staff was very friendly and helpful. Ordered 2 chef salads , 24 wings and a 10" Margherita pizza. Food was solid, would recommend to anyone passing through

This is authentic NY style, Napoli style pizza. NY style Crust and sauce are fabulous and the prices aren't outrageous, they don't have 4 kinds of pepperoni to confuse your brain. They cut it like a pie and not all that square stupidity other Midwest pizza places do. Just don't order hamburger on your pizza, NOBODY knows how to do that in the Midwest. They're missing so much, but the rest of it is fabulous and uncomplicated!

Ordered large 14" Margherita pizza and Pepperoni rolls with Marinara dipping sauce. We were able to pay over the phone, food was delivered to our car, and placed in our trunk. No contact service. Food was very good.

Yum! I've had this pizza a couple times. I like the soft crust! It is not too thick or chewy. I had the blt pizza, which is a real winner. The only thing thing I wish that was different would be for the lettuce to be cut into smaller pieces. I also had the margarita pizza and it is delish. One disappointing thing is that when we went in to pick up the pizza, no one greeted us! I'm sure they were busy, but no one else was in the restaurant. Overall, this place makes a great pie and we will be back!

Big hype. Also big taste, wanted a thin crust, the manager said hey! Try the New York hand tossed. She rocks! Get your self in there... get a mom and pop pizza! Get a real pizza done right...

Been here a few times when camping in the area and the pizza is amazing. I wish they were closer to Columbus. I've never been inside as someone else has always picked it up, but I can say every pizza we've tried has been great. Bit pricey, but worth it!

Fantastic thin crust pizza. Lots of options. Love this place. No ice but I bring my own.

ALWAYS great pizza!! Subs are great too. Very friendly staff. Good prices. Quite a treat

The pizza is very good. During peak hours you can sometimes see dough thrown by their 3-time world-champion thrower, Michael Shepherd. There is also a Kenton, OH store, but I have not been to that one.If you travel past Bellefontaine or are in the Indian Lake area, it is worth the 8-10 mile detour to visit Michael Angelo's. Rushsylvania does not have many attractions beyond being a great mid-western small town, so Michael Angelo's can be your excuse. I like their subs best. Just a great balance of good bread, plenty of meat and veggies, and packed around a nice blend of spices. You never need to consider traffic or parking - there is no rush hour in Rushsylvania.