Massey's Pizza - Whitehall

The pizza is pretty good. Not the best of course (that's Robino's), but far better than the chains. But this review is about the cinnamon pizza. There is a huge disparity the size of the Grand Canyon between what they advertise the dessert is and what it actually is (see the photo). I paid $7 for this. I feel like they should have paid me that much to eat what they gave me. It's patently obvious they used hardly any cinnamon and they did not give it proper time to bake. It's like they didn't care what they gave me and they just wanted me out of the way. Shame on them. Avoid. Use the Reynoldsburg Massey's instead.

Ive been seeing the commercial for the deep dish pizza. Epic fail!!! Ordered my pizza was told 35 minutes, was surprised how they gave a time that the pizza should be ready, not knowing how busy they would be, so it added a extra 25 minutes of waiting to my time. Manager gave a free drink for the wait. Looked at the pizza it looked really good, lol to my surprise it was awful. $21 for a 12 inch deep dish pizza with just beef, onions, and mushrooms. Thinking this can't go wrong, this pizza had no taste, no flavor or seasoning. I should have took a picture but I didn't. My 1st time and last time trying Massey's pizza. Don't understand how they can be in business for as long as they have been. After reading the joke on the box, Cadillac of pizza (lol) definitely not on my top 5 of choices. Have to come better than that, should never put yourself that high up

This is a columbus hidden gem if you're from here you know the pizza is so good. I had the combination and it was wonderful

Great pizza place love their pizza ,generous with toppings. Variety of pizzas to choose from they also have all you can eat during the week .

There were 10 of us tonight! Ordering went smooth and our pizza and meatball sub was very delicious. Senior discount was better than the coupon we had. The Pizza was crispy with thin crust. Just the way we like it! The meatball sub was tasty with big fat meatballs! My only complaint is that it was warm inside the restaurant! Obviously the ac wasn't on or not working. Upon leaving we noticed there was outside seating. Probably would have been a better choice

Great food Everytime... good service. I have always ordered to go. I want to try the lunch buffet sometime in the near future. Everyone says it's good. Go for lunch and lmk

I'm writing the exact same from 2 years ago. SEE BELOW.Nothing has changed. The food is great but the BUFFETIS WEAK! Not attended very well. The Buffett is varietyOf Pizza... fine. Then some sort of mushy pasta in an unappealing Red Sauce. Salad bar good but not maintained very well.Now the best part is that this Massey's Only does is Fried Chicken!!!Pretty Darn Good too. Only problem is they only put out about12 pieces at a time. Most of the crowd are Hungry Working Men.They need to put out more chicken. Add another fryer or riskSome angry men and women.Just as I wrote in my below review from 2023. Clean the place up.It's 2025 not 1963. The eating area is disgusting.

This might be the grossest place I've ever been to. Total chaos. Employees and their children (?) running all over, into the kitchen, back to the dining room. There seemed to be no system at all to how they took orders or completed them. I saw multiple people preparing food that certainly hadn't washed their hands. I really can't stress enough how disgusting this place is. I prepaid online or we would have left. My kids love the pizza and I hope they won't get dystentry, but only time will tell! Of note, the fellow working the phones was trying his hardest. He seemed nice.

I haven't got their Stromboli in years but wtf is this? The ends are only bread...the other pieces have a lot of bread where it should be topings...isn't there garlic butter?? It was so dry! And what happened to the crust??? It use to be more of a pastry and not just bread...it was my favorite place for stromboil but never again..it has no flavor!

Why didn't anyone warn me that Massey's BBQ wings are actually FRIED chicken wings drizzled with BBQ sauce? WHY???