Massey's Pizza - Gahanna

After almost 62 years of not having a fresh out the oven Massey's pizza I found myself in heaven. We have had them shipped over the years to Arizona and while they were great nothing replaces right out of the oven. Growing up in Whitehall we would never get pizza from anywhere else. I'll just have to think of another reason to fly to Columbus again. Thank you Massey's for being the best pizza I have ever had.

First time at this location and when I tell you how friendly the staff was they greeted us as soon as we walked in with a smile. This is starting to be my favorite pizza I love the thin crust and the crispness of the crust, love the amount of pepperoni. This location was really clean and well maintained also there are plenty of seats to eat in.

I recently visited Massey's with a friend and it felt like a visit to a new restaurant.  It's been over 15 years since I've been there and I honestly don't remember anything beyond the AYCE at lunch time at the Main Street location in Whitehall (which I doubt they do anymore), but I digress.Dining with a friend, I ordered The Godfather Deep Dish (my favorite pizza is deep dish), looking forward to that Italian sausage and Portofino pepperoni.  It did not disappoint, either.  Every chew of each forkfull that I put in my mouth was delicious!  Nice and hot, out of the oven, with just enough cheese and tomato sauce to give it that nice substance in both flavor and texture.  Even the crust was flavorful.I ordered a sausage and pepperoni stromboli "to go" for my wife, which she and my sons devoured.  I managed to get a bite dipped in marinara sauce and I have to admit, it was really good. Still, me, being a creature of habit, I'll end up getting that deep dish next time I go through instead of trying something else.

My hubby, friend and I stopped her for pizza. My hubby and I had not been here in a few years. The building was nice and kept clean. We liked the easy to read lighted menu above the counter to order. We ordered their 14" supreme pizza which comes with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and onions. Unfortunately, I have a severe mushroom allergy and need to stress that when I place an order to alert the pizza cooks that no mushroom can touch , be removed, or even have my pizza cut by a knife that was used on another pizza before mine that contains mushrooms. I had them put black olives in place of the mushrooms. In addition we got fountain drinks. The young man took my order but seemed to be annoyed when I explained my severe allergy. After about 20 minutes our amazingly tantalizing pizza arrived. It was perfect! Since Massey's use cornmeal for the crust there really isn't a crust and the sauce and veggies are all the way to the edge. The crisp and thin crust and veggies were incredible! Next time I'm back in Ohio, I will make sure to stop in and get another fantastic pizza.

Massey's is a gem for a couple of reasons. If you love thin crust this pizza will do it for you! It isn't cracker thin, but just about as thin as you can get before reaching cracker status. Toppings are overloaded. For me, I think I'll ask for half the amount of pepperoni next time. It was double the amount- but without an additional charge. Topping lovers would LOVE Massey's. I just like an equal amount of cheese to pep. Such great quality ingredients though, and the best pepperoni I've ever had. Just slightly spicy. $13.99 for a 12" and that was 3 meals for me. Very fair prices!

Best thin pep around, my opinion of course but if you don't like this, there's a special place for you.

No longer deliver to The Garden's Apartments anymore. Reduced their delivery area and eliminated a large number of customers. You know why they did this? Because they only give a damn about how much money they make. The smaller their delivery area is the less it costs them and more money stays in the owners pocket. Too bad. Massey's loss is Donatos gain. They deliver here. I'll never eat at Massey's again. Thanks for nothing!!!!

We have gone to Massey's for over 20 years. Today we encountered the most rude and disrespectful employee we have ever encountered. His name is Nick and he took our order upon entering the business. He started yelling at us and several other customers who came in with us. One gentleman attempted to open the door a couple minutes before 11:00. I told him that they will not open the door until 11:00. It was a few minutes past 11:00 before the door was opened. Upon entering, Nick began yelling at the man about not trying to open the door before 11:00. I think Nick got up on the wrong side of the bed.When I placed my order, he began yelling at me and telling me that he didn't need people telling him how to do his job. He said he had already worked 80 hours this week. Regardless of how many hours he had worked, he had no business disrespecting his customers and yelling at everyone.Nick needs an attitude adjustment and to learn to show some respect to his customers. We will not be returning to this Massey's because we do not appreciate being treated so disrespectfully, nor seeing others being treated disrespectfully. Massey's needs to finds an employee to replace Nick before he drives away all their customers.

I used to frequent this place but they for some reason just refuse to put any sauce on their pizza anymore. I even paid for 3X extra sauce and still got none, as you can see in attached pic.I wish this location would improve quality but I am done with them.

Great food. Excellent pizza buffet. Friendly and courteous staffing Close by for pickup or delivery