Mama Renie's Pizza

Went down to the area for a weekend getaway and found this nice gem. A true tavern style pizza joint. Edge to edge toppings, crisp crust, friendly locals, and knowledgeable staff.

A wide variety of food. Not just pizza! The service was great and the ambiance is good ol' hometown diner. Great for the family or a night out when you don't want to cook.

The pizza was amazing! My husband (the pizza connoisseur) said he would drive the 3 1/2 hours, just to get the pizza. The bar/restaurant looked very inviting and cozy. We got carry out, but would go back to dine in, when we go back to hocking hills.

Just depends on the dough!!! They at times have the best pizza in southern Ohio, light, crispy, crackery...perfect for taste yet not heavy on the bread/carbs, adepquate toppings....other times it's average and at times below...the other food items they sell are sometimes better options than the pizzas but I usually do get a small at the very least. It takes times to cook ehm right but it is worth the wait!

Went there on a Sunday night, only ones there. Took about 45 min to get our food, 2 of 4 orders were cold. I wasn't given a napkin, had to get myself- I only got a burger but still. Not much to chose from in at area but very surprised at all the good reviews? Maybe locals get better service and food

Driving through Ohio and we found this wonderful little place in the middle of town. The food was really good as well as the service. I'm thankful for being able to rely on my way up to final chips like this particularly when we're traveling in the middle of nowhere that is familiar to us. I wanna give a shout out to the service which was first class and the homemade chips were fantastic! Definitely family friendly and the prices were very reasonable and the quality of the food was very good!

Was introduced to Mama Renie's when I was working in McArthur 10 years ago. Now, it is our destination restaurant every time my wife and kids take a family vacation in the area.Reasonable portions @ great prices.

Pizza tasted great and the price was very fair, but nothing that had a "wow" factor. Great for if you're in Hocking Hills and looking for something for dinner.

Great pizzas and breakfast food. You can't go wrong. Hole in the wall type place! Try it when you visit anywhere in hocking or Vinton counties.

I just always love coming here when visiting. The pizza is one of the best. But my second favorite is the chopped steak with Mac n cheese on a freezing cold day. All the staff that work here are so sweet and friendly. I definitely recommend coming here on your way to Old Man's Cave.