Mama Mimi's Take N Bake Pizza

We had pizza from them four times in the last two months. The Clintonville location was disappointing every time, specifically the fact that the same pizza tasted different each of the three times we ordered there. The same kind of dough (white) tasted okay one time, the other time it felt plasticky, old and the edges were uneven. The red sauce was much sweeter one time than the other. The whole wheat dough was just terrible; we only had it once.The Upper Arlington location was much better, but we ordered only once from there.Very disappointing because when I used to order from them years ago, it was always good.

For my New Year's Eve celebration at home, the tradition is to have pizza and watch a movie. This year, the Moltansanti with a Chopped Italian Salad from Mama Mimi's was my choice. I had the fixings to make a pizza from scratch but didn't want to dirty up a lot of kitchen things.The Moltansanti feels healthy because it has tomatoes and banana peppers. The pepperoni and tomatoes are under the cheese so someone might be fooled into thinking it's a cheese pizza with banana peppers. The banana peppers add a vinegary touch with a little crunch.The Chopped Italian salad is always a winner. They make a sweet italian dressing which may not be to some people's tastes. I ordered my food online ($1.50 convenience fee) and it was ready at the designated pickup time. They have an early bird discount code EB20 for orders placed before 4pm to get a 20% discount. If you're on the mailing list you may get a different code to use at other times of the day.

I love the idea of take and bake pizza, lasagna, etc. - my husband and I were able to pick our order up in the afternoon, put it in the fridge and make it when we were ready for dinner. We live downtown so take out / delivery can often be challenging or leave the pizza colder than we would like. Mama Mimi's Take and Bake Pizza is the perfect solution for us! I know it's not everyone's preference but for us, it's great. We ordered a large cheese pizza and family lasagna. We couldn't believe how much food we received! The lasagna can easily feed 4-6 people and the pizza is a great size as well. We also received complimentary bread/garli sticks and they were delicious! And very kind. The pizza was so flavorful, fluffy and perfectly seasoned. I was expecting more of a flatbread style and was pleasantly surprised. All in all, we loved Mama Mimi's and will definitely be adding this in to our rotation!

I picked up a medium pepperoni pizza and an order of garlic cheesy bread from Mama Mimi's. They offer a wide range of pizzas, salads and Italian appetizers for takeout from their Clintonville joint. The staff member who took and prepped my order was friendly; he explained how to cook my pizza and bread and gave me some useful tips. Be sure to save the wrapping which contains the instructions if you're forgetful. My pizza and bread turned out wonderful! The bread had a great cheese and garlic flavor, and the pizza was fresh and non-greasy. Overall a fun experience.

If you like homemade pizza but don't feel like doing the work this place will be your best friend. The flavors are truly legit. They use fresh produce and have a variety of sauces. I've had nearly all of their pizza combinations as well as their lasagna. Meat, veggie or all cheese for the picky eaters.The staff at this location is super friendly, especially Tony. He's been here for years and greets everyone like they are family. They always seem to have some sort of special going on, but it doesn't matter because I'm going to order regardless.Take it home, pop it in the oven, and voila! Pizza love

It was my first time coming here and the employees were so soo very helpful! they explained every to me. My pizza was delicious very homemade! You have to try the tiramisu I will never get enough of it.

The service is great but the pizza was quite bland and had the teeniest scattering of cheese.the other toppings were loaded up but barely any cheese and a tasteless, dry crust.

This place can be such a forgotten gem because it's been around so long, but it still is as delicious as ever. Had a half Italian half veggie lasagna tonight and a salad and everything was wonderful. Friendly service, delicious food, and great prices! Highly recommend!!

When I go, I visit their Grandview location (1565 King Ave), and have never been disappointed with it! It's 'foolproof', fresh and even good re-heated the next day! (I'm 'eating for one, so I have leftovers.) I've been going for years, so long that I have an old "Free Pizza Ticket" where each time, they initial a box; after 10, you get a free cheese pizza (you can add toppings, of course)! I don't know if they still run this or not, though (I hope so!) YUMMY!

Awesome service and excellent pizza!! Quality toppings, fresh ingredients, plus additional food items, like dessert!