Mama Mimi's Pizza - Columbus

Mama Mimi's is a tasty and convenient take and bake pizza place. They send very clear and easy baking instructions home with you, and it's a very easy process. They have a wide variety of choices, including multiple crust options (white, honey-wheat, gluten free, cauliflower), sauces, and toppings, and they also offer custom options from which to select. They also offer salads, lasagna, garlic cheese bread stix, cheesy bread loaf, and desserts. This location shares the space with a beer and wine store, so you can also pick those up while you're grabbing your pizza.Everything we've tried has been good, and some of the items we especially enjoy include the Moltansanti combo, the meatball pie, the garlic cheese bread stix, and the Italian vinaigrette for the salads.The parking lot is small and can get crowded. The staff is friendly and efficient.

Such a gem in Columbus. They make their pizza fresh to take and bake. It's reasonably priced and the staff is so friendly. It's also inside a wine shop, pairs nicely when you're getting something to take home! I had Carmella's favorite and the margherita. Both excellent. I also had a Caesar salad- the cheese was delicious. Highly recommend to anyone in the area!

I'm a pizza fanatic. Mama Mimis isn't just good take and bake pizza, it's good pizza, period. If you follow the instructions, or even get really radical and turn your oven up a little higher to 475-500, and use a pizza stone, you can bake pizza at home that is better than any delivery pizza. Oh, and I laughed really hard at the review that said they couldn't get the raw dough off the paper. It's parchment paper, you bake it on that! I don't really like the giant pepperonis but they offer smaller pepperonis. Can't remember the name for them but if you call I'm sure it's something that can be figured out. I actually prefer to order non traditional pizzas here, the Marmaletta is amazing. Their email subscription has good coupons pretty often. At full price this is definitely on the expensive side, but we like the Marmaletta so much that I have to admit occasionally paying full price.

The pros of this pizza is that it is completely customizable and you get to watch it be assembled in front of you. The cons are the crust and sauces are not fresh, it is expensive and when I baked it the crust was soggy. I feel bad because the people working were so nice and I've heard many good things but it wasn't for me.

We love Mama Mimi's for both the product and convenience but until this location can create accurate orders or educate their staff on customer service, we may have to take a break. The past two visits have resulted in my husband and I receiving inaccurate orders or uncommunicated ingredient swaps while still paying full price. We ordered a Caesar salad (our favorite) but when we went to pick it up the employee let us know they were actually out of romaine so she had swapped spring mix instead, "which we usually actually upcharge for so, you know..." all while blankly staring at us. We gave her the benefit of the doubt (New? Just really inexperienced? Not aware that this 'fancy' spring mix will definitely not hold up to the Caesar dressing?) and paid for our order - as no mention of a discount or comped item was to be had. The second miss was this past weekend. We called twice and got their answering machine, but was able to reach an employee on the third try - 5:00 on a Saturday. We were ordering for out of town visitors who had a very favorite Mama Mimi's order. When we got there, I noticed our visitors' favorite pizza had been made with the wrong sauce. When I mentioned this, the employee just stared at us and said..."Uh, so do you want me to remake it or what...?" We were in a hurry so we expressed our frustration but said we didn't have time. Charged full price again! No apology! When we got to the car I realized another pizza had been made incorrectly, even though she had repeated my order to me during the ordering process.So, out of 2 visits and 4 items - 3 items have been incorrect and we have paid full price for everything. Please educate your staff on the importance of order accuracy and how to remedy any customer dissatisfaction that occurs. Not really into gambling with this place at the moment. ___________Just to note, I wanted to leave this feedback directly to Mama Mimi's management and not plaster it on Yelp since I'm guessing the owner/manager would want to know the service is slipping but there is no email address or direct phone line I could find to actually reach someone in charge.

I had heard about Mama Mimi's, and finally got around to trying it. Their online ordering was smooth and simple- I did a custom pizza. 15 minutes later, I was picking up my pizza. They were very efficient and friendly at the store (bonus- you can get wine at the shop that shares the building). Once home, the pizza only took 10 minutes in the oven. I really like knowing just how fresh everything is! It feels healthier that way. It's a little pricey, but I would definitely try it again!

The pizza was great. The madebot very fast and so easy to bake at home. The service was way good. Friendly people here.

Ordered the Green Goddess & Marmaletta Amore pizzas, Greek & Gourmet Field Greens salads, & a Veggie Lasagna dinner pan for 4. Fresh & tasty. Good food! Recommended.

Not sure what the other raving reviews are about? I had high hopes for the pizza, but overall it's really mediocre and not something I would buy again. Honestly, I would rather eat frozen pizza from Kroger (which is just down the street by the way). It's cheaper and way better. I really can't justify the price of the medium pizza I got from here. $15 for a smallish medium pizza that I had to bake at home?? Not to mention, the picture online didn't match the actual product. They gave me a honey wheat crust even though I chose a white crust. Even with the correct crust, I don't think it would have tasted any better. This is the first time I have regretted ordering pizza. I won't give one star because I don't think it's complete trash. I mean I still ate it lol just not something I would ever buy again!

Today I went for the first time to mana mimi's ordered 40 dollars of pizza one stuff with sausage worst tasting cheese and I found 1 tiny piece of sausage. Never again had to order somewhere else.