Malcuit's Tavern

My husband and I made a reservation for 2 on a Friday and got our table immediately upon arrival. We ordered the mozzarella sticks to start and they were great. We also both ordered the filet mignon and a loaded baked potato. The filet was phenomenal! They were cooked to a perfect medium rare and sat in an incredible buttery sauce. Our server was so kind and attentive as well. We will be returning when we find ourselves in the area in the future.

Good food and great service! I highly recommend eating there! The baked potatoes hooked me!

stayed in Strasburg for a long weekend and took my son, daughter and son-in-law to Malcuitt's. had a good meal there pre-pandemic. Called ahead for reservation and they asked bar on dining roI'm. I like the bar because there are a few booths that reduce the din and you can talk. service was quick and friendly. I explained a rye Manhattan to the bartender and she made a good one. I knew the size of their steaks, so my daughter and I split a strip steak with salad and baked potato. My son had salmon and my son-in-law had a casserole looking thing. All was excellent. steak was medium rare, as ordered. salmon was cooked but still soft. note: some reviewers state that the steaks are brined in pickle juice--not true. They use pepper, another herb that I missed and soy sauce. A pickle spear is placed on the cast iron plate with the steak after it has been seared and then placed into the oven. Works quite well. We all thought prices were fair for the size and quality of the meals. Even my son who is a bit of a critic.

Never disappointed with Malciut's! We usually try to get there to eat at least once a year or so. My husband and I had a nice date night enjoying the delectables: steak, fish, and pasta. They have great steaks and for some reason, I love the spaghetti side! Will be back, as always!

Dinner for 2. 05/28/22Appetizer - Ordered BA's sample platter app (great)Meals - 2 salad (good), fries (good crisp but tasted like cooked in old burnt oil), green beans (no seasonings, tastes to be just boiled in over chlorinated water), 7 shrimp with linguini in garlic butter sauce (no flavor at all, tastes like it was cooked in a steamer bag with no seasonings), 25oz Porterhouse (worst ever, tastes to me marinated in powder milk with no other flavor, meat was tinder but slightly undercooked for medium rare-ok, no juices in steak at all ,usually a little blood when cut but this steak was attacked by a vampire before cooked- badWill never return!P.s. because of how busy they were server service was acceptable.

My family and I ate here this past summer. It was delicious! Service was topnotch too! I would love to eat here again. It is on the pricey side so it's not some place I would be able to afford frequently. But what isn't these days. With that being side I would much rather pay good money to eat here than I would at Texas roadhouse on down the road.

Outstanding service & food! Raspberry Mule is definitely a hit if you like ginger beer .

We have never had a bad steak at Malcuits. We order medium and that is exactly how it comes out. Salads are great, huge baked potatoes. The waitresses are great also. They are hustling about and getting you what you need.

I had dinner at the Tavern last night and as always it was awesome. Not many things you can count on in the world today but you can count on a great meal and great service at Malcuit's tavern.

I have had two incidents with this restaurant. First time was when I went and was asked if I had a reservation, I did not but was clearly made to feel like a street person. The hostess walked away without saying a word until someone else came to seat us. The restaurant was not even busy. The second encounter was being charged a "convenience fee" of 4% and when I questioned why, was told if using a credit card they charge this. I explained I used a debit card. I was then told I had to take the matter up with my bank. For a restaurant that can charge market price on a steak, I don't think they are hurting for money to have to pay a credit card fee. Amy - Strasburg, Ohio