Little Italy Pizza - New Straitsville

Pizza

Thin N Crispy Pizza with 1 Topping
$5.00
Hand Tossed Pizza with 1 Topping
$8.00
Pizza Pan with 1 Topping
$8.50

Thin N Crispy Specialty Pizza

Thin N Crispy Cheesy Potato Pizza

Ranch, cheese, potato, bacon and ham.
$6.25
Thin N Crispy Hawaiian Pizza

Bacon, ham, pineapple and cheese.
$6.25
Thin N Crispy Meat Lover Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, hamburger and cheese.
$6.25
Thin N Crispy Philly Steak Pizza

Steak, mushroom, onion, green pepper, ranch and cheese.
$6.25
Thin N Crispy Veggie Pizza

Mushrooms, onion, hot pepper, green pepper, tomato and cheese.
$6.25
Thin N Crispy Supreme Pizza

Pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, onion, hot peppers, green peppers and cheese.
$6.25
Thin N Crispy Double Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

Pizza sauce, ground beef, bacon and cheese.
$6.25
Thin N Crispy Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Chicken, bacon, ranch, cheese and tomato.
$6.25

Hand Tossed Specialty Pizza

Cheesy Potato Hand Tossed Pizza

Ranch, cheese, potato, bacon and ham.
$11.50
Hawaiian Hand Tossed Pizza

Bacon, ham, pineapple and cheese.
$11.50
Meat Lovers Hand Tossed Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, hamburger and cheese.
$11.50
Philly Steak Hand Tossed Pizza

Steak, mushroom, onion, green pepper, ranch and cheese.
$11.50
Veggie Hand Tossed Pizza

Mushrooms, onion, hot pepper, green pepper, tomato and cheese.
$11.50
Supreme Hand Tossed Pizza

Pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, onion, hot peppers, green peppers and cheese.
$11.50
Double Bacon Cheeseburger Hand Tossed Pizza

Pizza sauce, ground beef, bacon and cheese.
$11.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch Hand Tossed Pizza

Chicken, bacon, ranch, cheese and tomato.
$11.50

Pizza Pan Specialty Pizza

Cheesy Potato Pan Pizza

Ranch, cheese, potato, bacon and ham.
$11.25
Hawaiian Pan Pizza

Bacon, ham, pineapple and cheese.
$11.25
Meat Lovers Pan Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, hamburger and cheese.
$11.25
Philly Steak Pan Pizza

Steak, mushroom, onion, green pepper, ranch and cheese.
$11.25
Veggie Pan Pizza

Mushrooms, onion, hot pepper, green pepper, tomato and cheese.
$11.25
Supreme Pan Pizza

Pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, onion, hot peppers, green peppers and cheese.
$11.25
Double Bacon Cheeseburger Pan Pizza

Pizza sauce, ground beef, bacon and cheese.
$11.25
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pan Pizza

Chicken, bacon, ranch, cheese and tomato.
$11.25

Beverages

Canned Soda
$1.00
6 Pack Soda
$4.00
12 Pack Soda
$7.50
Coffee
$1.00

Appetizers

Onion Rings
$3.00
Battered Cauliflower
$3.00
Battered Mushrooms
$3.00
Jalapeno Poppers

Served with cream cheese.
$4.00
Bread Sticks
$3.50
Bread Sticks with Cheese
$4.75
French Fries
$1.75
Corn Nuggets
$2.50
Cheese Sticks
$4.00
Pretzel Sticks
$4.00
Chicken Tenders
$4.50
Wings
$6.50
Potato Skins
$4.25
Popcorn Chicken
$4.50
Cheesy Bread

Pan crust, garlic butter and cheese. Served with a side of pizza sauce and garlic butter.
$5.00

Subs

Italian Sub

Ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, onion, hot pepper, lettuce and tomato. Italian dressing on side.
$3.50
Pizza Sub

Pizza sauce, pepperoni and cheese.
$3.50
Ham and Cheese Sub

Ham, cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$3.50
Whole Hoagie

Hoagie patty, cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$6.00
Regular Sub

Ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, pizza sauce, onion and hot peppers.
$3.50
Meatball Sub

Meatballs, sauce, cheese and garlic butter.
$3.50
Veggie Sub

Cheese, pizza sauce, mushrooms, green peppers, onion, hot peppers and tomatoes.
$3.50
BLT Sub

Bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$3.50

Premium Subs

Grilled Chicken Sub

Grilled chicken breast, cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$4.00
Whole Philly Steak Sub

Philly steak, cheese, mushrooms, onions, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$6.50
Crispy Chicken Sub

Chicken tenders, cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$4.00
Breakfast Sub

Egg, bacon, sausage, ham, onion, green pepper, mushroom, hot peppers, tomato and cheese.
$4.00
Pizza Deluxe Sub

Pizza sauce, cheese, pepperoni, onion, hot peppers, sausage and mushroom.
$4.00
Whole Sausage Sub

Sausage, cheese, pizza sauce, onion and green pepper.
$6.50
Deluxe Sub

Ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, pizza sauce, onion, hot peppers, sausage and mushroom.
$4.00

Sandwiches

Cheeseburger
$4.00
Double Cheeseburger
$4.75
Pizza Burger
$4.00
Mushroom and Swiss Burger

Grilled mushroom and onion.
$4.25
Mushroom and Swiss Double Burger

Grilled mushroom and onion.
$5.00
Fish Sandwich
$4.50
Ham and Cheese Sandwich
$3.00
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
$4.00
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$4.00
Fried Bologna Sandwich
$4.00

Salads

Dinner Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onion and cheese.
$3.50
Chicken Salad

Crispy or grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato and cheddar.
$7.00
Chef Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, ham, pepperoni and cheese.
$5.00
Philly Steak Salad

Philly steak, lettuce, tomato, mushroom, onion and cheddar.
$7.00

An order of fried mushrooms! What a joke.

Establishment with a drive-through

Establishment

Namesake

LITTLE ITALY PIZZA, GREAT FOOD.

Wall decor

Cheesy Bread Sticks

Interior table view

Exterior

Front counter

Pizza & salad

Bread Sticks with Cheese

BBQ Wings

interior

Roger N.

★★★★★

Sep 21, 2024

This pizza place is our go to choice for delicious and affordable pizza. Good Customer service and have never been disappointed with anything we have ordered- pizza, wings, subs, appetizers.

Jennifer P.

★☆☆☆☆

Feb 1, 2024

Placed my order for two subs at 4:27 pm for delivery and the order did not arrive until over two & a half hours later & the subs were almost cold. I will not be giving this company any more of my business, this is extremely poor service and not how you retain your customer base.

Layne W.

★★★★★

Aug 15, 2019

Purchased takeout pepperoni pizza and cheese bread. Keep in mind I don't like pizza; I typically just tolerate it because there's nothing else. But this pizza was honesty some of the best pizza I've ever had. It made me start liking pizza again. Cheese bread was great also.

Barb B.

★★★★★

Nov 15, 2019

Best pizza we've ever had. Have ordered many times now and the consistency in quality has always been right on target. You have to try the hand-tossed Philly Cheese Steak Pizza. It is phenomenal! The facility is spotless, staff is friendly! Hope to see them expand a little more as far as seating goes, but for now, it's just wonderful having someplace to go close to home. This little place has really breathed some life into the community. I hope other businesses follow their lead!

Jay H.

★★★★★

Jul 5, 2019

Rode here on motorcycle from Lancaster. Definitely no complaints. We ordered a pepperoni with their sweet sauce and the hand tossed crust. Pepperonis were crispy, I love it when they're like that. Job well done.

Little Italy Pizza - New Straitsville

Menu

Pizza

Thin N Crispy Pizza with 1 Topping

Hand Tossed Pizza with 1 Topping

Pizza Pan with 1 Topping

Thin N Crispy Specialty Pizza

Thin N Crispy Cheesy Potato Pizza

Thin N Crispy Hawaiian Pizza

Thin N Crispy Meat Lover Pizza

Thin N Crispy Philly Steak Pizza

Thin N Crispy Veggie Pizza

Thin N Crispy Supreme Pizza

Thin N Crispy Double Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

Thin N Crispy Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Hand Tossed Specialty Pizza

Cheesy Potato Hand Tossed Pizza

Hawaiian Hand Tossed Pizza

Meat Lovers Hand Tossed Pizza

Philly Steak Hand Tossed Pizza

Veggie Hand Tossed Pizza

Supreme Hand Tossed Pizza

Double Bacon Cheeseburger Hand Tossed Pizza

Chicken Bacon Ranch Hand Tossed Pizza

Pizza Pan Specialty Pizza

Cheesy Potato Pan Pizza

Hawaiian Pan Pizza

Meat Lovers Pan Pizza

Philly Steak Pan Pizza

Veggie Pan Pizza

Supreme Pan Pizza

Double Bacon Cheeseburger Pan Pizza

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pan Pizza

Breakfast

Breakfast Pizza

Beverages

Canned Soda

6 Pack Soda

12 Pack Soda

Coffee

Appetizers

Onion Rings

Battered Cauliflower

Battered Mushrooms

Jalapeno Poppers

Bread Sticks

Bread Sticks with Cheese

French Fries

Corn Nuggets

Cheese Sticks

Pretzel Sticks

Chicken Tenders

Wings

Potato Skins

Popcorn Chicken

Cheesy Bread

Pasta

Spaghetti

Spaghetti with Meatballs

Chicken Parmesan Pasta

Subs

Italian Sub

Pizza Sub

Ham and Cheese Sub

Whole Hoagie

Regular Sub

Meatball Sub

Veggie Sub

BLT Sub

Premium Subs

Grilled Chicken Sub

Whole Philly Steak Sub

Crispy Chicken Sub

Breakfast Sub

Pizza Deluxe Sub

Whole Sausage Sub

Deluxe Sub

Sandwiches

Cheeseburger

Double Cheeseburger