Lindsey's Bakery

I can't believe I forgot to review this AMAZING place when I noticed the photos on my phone. I went during the pumpkin show and my advise is to go early or not during the show because in my photo, you'll see a big line wraps out the door and down a long ways. Worth the wait, though. Amazing doughnuts that are so soft and makes you wanna eat a full dozen before you leave.

This is a small town bakery that capitalized big time on the towns "Pumpkin Show". During Pumpkin Show the bakery is mobbed inside and out to see their biggest pumpkin pie. A 4'-5' behemoth. Their pumpkin pie, and other baked goods, are pricey but excellent , and regularly sell out. Waiting until Pumpkin Show was behind the community for the year, and the mobs were gone so one could get into the bakery, I splurged for my yearly treat of their pumpkin pie!The pie was beautiful and delicious. However, this is a $15 pumpkin pie with the pumpkin in it less than 1" thick. Less is not more in pie filling, and they used to be massive allowing one to delight and reminisce about their pumpkin show behemoth pie in the front window. It used to be a fun, overpriced, but filling and overstuffed, fall treat from a hometown bakery. Now they just feel like another opportunistic "fair food" vendor. Yes, the service was cordial, fast and efficient. The ambiance looks like the small venue bakery it's always been but without the pervasive fresh baked goods smell that help endear such places.

Circleville is Central Ohio's undisputed pumpkin capital, but the pumpkin donut at Lindsey's (sold year round) was just okay for me. They have cut out cookies, which I wouldn't get again, and a large apple fritter that was an improvement from the cookies. Then came the Maple Bismarck which outstanding! It had the perfect light crunch and terrific filling on the interior. I would come back in a heartbeat to try their whole fleet of Bismarcks. There's not much in terms of dine in space, but those donuts can be enjoyed anywhere.

Home of the world's largest pumpkin pie!Pumpkin donuts are good too, cake style, light pumpkin spice flavor, light glaze. During the pumpkin show, expect a line half a block long to get a piece of pie, not from the world's largest pie, but using the same recipe or some donuts.

We were in Logan and searching for a breakfast spot with vegan options rather than more lunch style food (burger/salad) that most places seem to offer. This was worth the drive! So many delicious bakery options to choose from! We got a $15 dozen box (no other option with so many choices) and love them all! Donuts and cinnamon rolls and still more offerings to try! Maple, jelly, cream, sugar, just an amazing sugar explosion! We will be back!

They have THE best pumpkin donuts.Their fritters and cookies are awesome too. One of my favorite things about the pumpkin festival is visiting thepumpkin

So, I've heard of this bakery for years... especially during the Circleville Pumpkin Festival. I mean, every time I've gone I've been unable to grab up some goodies because there's always a line wrapped around the building. However!!! I was able to swing by during an impromptu visit on my way to Hocking Hills. While it was snowy and quiet, there was no line and I had a ton of treats to choose from.Of course, I had to try one of their famous pumpkin donuts. Out of the three items I got, this was by far my favorite. It was soft with the perfect amount of pumpkin flavor and this slightest glaze over top. I could have eaten a hundred of them. I also grabbed a peanut butter cookie and a powdered donut with jelly filling. The donuts were definitely the highlight. YUMMO!As for the space itself, it's exactly what I would expect in a small town. It's a wee bit outdated and quaint but has some personality. The staff weren't overly friendly at all and the service definitely lacked but I was in and out of there quickly and got everything for under five bucks. I definitely see why this is such a hotspot during pumpkin season. I'll be back!

Known for their pumpkin donuts (year round) and gigantic pumpkin pie during the Pumpkin Show Lindsey's is a staple bakery in Circleville. During the pumpkin show they usually have a line down the block, but it is usually pretty fast. I got to visit in January when it wasn't as busy. I got a few other donuts and a cookie. Their pumpkin donuts are by far the best choice. The other items were okay. Everyone was really nice. Even at their busiest during the pumpkin show everyone was super awesome and kept their cool with the crowds of people coming through the doors.

I love the pumpkin donuts but everytime I try to go they are closed. They have the worst hours. Sun /mon - closedTues - sat - 7-3 Still gave 4 stars but COME ON LINDSAY!

If you are up near Circleville and you don't stop at Lindsey's for at least a doughnut there is something wrong with you. I had a Long John, chocolate glazed cake and a cream horn. The doughnuts were sooooo goooodddd. The cream horn was also good but I ate it later and would have prolly been best to eat it off the rip. It was huge.