Leb's Pizza House

Being perfectly honest, the pictures on yelp make this look pretty unappealing to me. I moved to the area not quite two years ago and have considered ordering for a while, but I couldn't get over how the food looks in pictures. I've also been severely disappointed by small town pizza in the past, so I'd always drive to Delaware or Marysville if I wanted a pizza. Tonight I was feeling extra lazy, didn't want to cook, didn't want to drive and refuse to use food delivery....so I decided to give Leb's a try, since it's just three minutes from home.The place itself isn't much to look at, which is fine by me, but there was also a weird smell (alcohol?) in the air that was a little off-putting to me. I was a little worried but ordered anyway.When I got the pizza, I figured out why the pictures look "bad" to me....the cheese is mostly on top of the other toppings. I could tell, though, this wasn't a pizza made for its social media posts....this was just a good old fashioned, well made pizza. And holy crap, was it GOOD. I ate half of an extra large, admittedly a good bit more than I meant to eat tonight, and I really want more as I'm typing this out. Seriously, every part of this pizza was just good...the crust and sauce especially stood out to me.I don't order pizza often, but I'm definitely going back and not just because I'm lazy and it's close.

Ostrander is a nice small town, a little hilly (for Ohio,) quiet. I thought about moving here years ago. If I had, I would have come here often. Small towns might only have one or two restaurants, and you hope they're good but you never know- and they don't have to be good, if they're the only place around. This place is very good.Nothing fancy, just a small, family-run restaurant and bar. I went mid-afternoon so it was quiet, and I'd bring kids here, but it probably gets louder in the evening (since it's probably also the only bar in town.) There's a pool table. Straightforward menu with pizza, subs, etc. I went with the garlic pizza since it looked good and I love garlic, and some BBQ wings. The pizza was more of an appetizer, personal-pizza size but cut into many strips. Very good crust, a little thick but crisped up, great cheese, great garlic and butter flavors with real garlic. Not greasy. The wings were big and meaty, heavily sauced. Good-not-great. I will definitely try more of their pizza, and subs, etc. Prices are reasonable. I had leftovers. Service was friendly and fast, and personal- you're dealing with the owner. Now I understand the other reviews, and why people were so excited when this family opened a new location.

Great local pizza place with a small town casual feel. The pizza was fantastic and the beer cold! We had a pepperoni and jalapeño pizza with ample amounts of both. It was cooked to perfection and we'll be back!

Called a week in advance for 6 pizzas to be ready at noon on a Saturday as we were having a family baby shower. I was told no problem. 2 cheese, 2 sausage and 2 pepperoni. Our shower was being held within walking distance of the pizza shop so was told the pizzas could be delivered. I am neurotic and told myself to call a reminder the day before. I got busy and did not get the call made the day before. Family arrived and the shower was in full swing. 11:50 the pizzas were delivered hot and delicious. Family enjoyed every slice. The pizza remained hot for the next 50 min until it was gone. Our youngest family (18 months) kept asking for more. She prob ate 2 pieces herself. I ordered 6 pizzas and had a little less than 1 pizza, left which was perfect as I didn't have to make dinner that evening. Thanks Leb's for a job well done!

We live nearby and it's our go to when we want quick delicious food. Subs and burgers never disappoint

I do like his pizza. Owner is friendly and I enjoy eating at the bar. He may want to look at the decor and lighting.

Very casual and laid back setting. Love the Sicilian and Club subs- highly recommended. The pizza is also very good. Service is always great!

The folks at Leb's were amazing to our family as we were in need of a gathering place for a meal after a funeral. The food was amazing, fresh, hot, and somehow they kept up with a large group of 50+ bombarding them at one time. Can't say enough good things about this place! 5 stars just doesn't do it justice. Thanks again so much for a perfect celebration of life gathering spot!

It's ok but I don't like when they put the pizza toppings underneath the cheese it's just wrong

Some of the best pizza in ostrander to be completely honest the owner himself is such a good dude he is a baseball coach and really cares about his community!