Key West Wings

This has now changed to Lithopolis Tavern. They have great pizza, a great vibe and lots of beer on tap!Live music on Saturday evenings too!

Great people behind the bar! Enjoyed some ac and beverages while the Honey Fest was going on. Will go back and try some food soon!

We were a party of seven aged from 5 to 82. Arrived at about 6pm. Music was nice, but too loud for us to hear conversation.Waitress brought out drinks and we ordered. As you might expect, our orders were all over the menu. We sat & sat, waiting for even just one order. Kids were fidgety & getting very hungry in the hour it took to be served. Staff were very nice, but kitchen staff was either very limited, new, or just inexperienced. The Nachos were over browned, they gave us two orders of boneless wings, & neither was not spicy hot. Had to wait for the bone-in ones again. Pizza was very good, as were burgers.Might be a great place to order bone-in wings en route home for pick-up as they were awesome. Did not finish eating until after 9pm & everyone was exhausted: us, the waitress, the kitcand the singer!

We went to Key West Wing in Lithopolis. This visit was a test visit to see what changes had been made due to a change of ownership. The news was all good. The new owners opened and enlarged the space. Key West Wings is much lighter and brighter and has lost the dive bar look. They also have put in new restrooms, which are fabulous. We loved the pizza when the space was JR's and The Pump House. Well, the pizza has not changed. Key West Wing's is New York-style pie. New York style pizza is typically layered with simple toppings and ingredients like mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce, and a choice of a few select types of meat like pepperoni and/or sausages. The thin crust compliments this flavor by allowing the focus on the contrasting flavors of the sauce and its toppings. New York style pizza is easy to eat by folding and does not require utensils. We ordered a large pepperoni and half mushroom. The pie was cut into wedges with a generous portion of cheese, pepperoni, and mushroom. We found the pizza just as we remembered. The pie was fabulous. Service was quick, and the bartender/server was attentive and cheerful. Great experience.

Great food and service in a comfortable setting. I've been here twice now and am excited to go back to try more of their food and drink specials.

Best wings I've had in years. Pizza was amazing. Great crust, sauce and lots of toppings. The sauces and wings are better than BWWs. Worth coming here.

Great place to go eat and get drinks. I keep getting the pizza. Can't help it. It's too good. Wings good too. Staff is very friendly. One of the reasons I keep going back. Would definitely recommend.

I stopped by for lunch today after reviewing verifying the hours on google and they were closed.

Attempted to order takeout but phone line was down so we went in to place order. We were informed phone lines not accepting calls from Verizon customers. Ordered mozzarella sticks and they came out burnt. Attempted to eat a couple however it left a burnt taste in my mouth.

Horrible pizza now. Bring back the way the Pump House made it. Don't fix it if it isn't broken!! Taste like a premade crust