Just Pies

Absolutely amazing pies & my mother is an excellent baker...They are homemade, presentation is excellent, they look like they taste...YUMMY

Just Pies is a must-try! I recommend sampling every flavor they bake. Their extensive selection includes delicious fruit pies, rich cream pies, savory pies, and tempting cookies. They cater to all appetites with three different pie sizes. If you're a pie aficionado, you can even buy a pie slicer. I especially appreciate the rewards program, which once rewarded me with a free small pie! Just a heads up: they are closed on Sundays and Mondays, so plan your visit accordingly.

Continuing a long standing Thanksgiving tradition, we spend the holiday with our kids and grandkids in Louisville, KY and our contribution is PIES. The kids and grandkids always look forward to grandpa showing up with pies from Just Pies. I'm usually in line (a really long line) at 8a on Tuesday. This year I didn't get there until about noon. Still had to wait in line but not as long a line as 8a. Still had an excellent selection of pies and I was able to get a large pumpkin and 2 medium apple pies (they were out of large ones). As usual, the pies were delicious and were a hit in Kentucky.

If you love pies this is your place to get them. We were going to a dinner party and brought the 8" Buckeye and 8" Three Berry pies and they were a huge hit. The kids LOVED the Buckeye pie. I also got a 6" butterscotch pie for my family. We didn't try any of the savory ones, yet. The lady that helped me was so sweet and nice.

There's just two words for Just Pies - Just Go! They make amazing pies. I love the peach/berry Peach Riot, and also enjoy the cream pies - chocolate, coconut, etc. All of the pies are generously filled and ultra fresh. They do and will sell out. Either go early, or you can pre-order, which is highly recommended if you want a certain kind. What I really love is that they make a 6 inch size that's just right for a couple of days of pie for one person as well as full sized! Also, don't sleep on the pot pies. They are fantastic! They make a normal chicken pot pie, a dark meat chicken, and a chicken/broccoli/cheese number, all of which I have purchased multiple times and will again. Again, these come in the small and large sizes. The pot pies are sold frozen, and take about an hour to cook, so factor that into your calculations. Please also note - they do use lard in their crust. While I don't normally eat pork, I do make an exception for the best frigging pie crust in the city. No joke. You can also pick up their wares at some of the local grocery stores around town, so if you see them, take advantage, though a trip to the Mother Ship is always a good idea!

Just pies is amazing! Not only is everything we've tried there so delicious, they are extremely efficient. Based on the line at the door, we normally would have tried another day, but it was for Christmas so we got in line. We were in and out in less than 15 minutes. It was impressive, the number of people willing to wait for a pie. They are the real deal and you won't be disappointed!

Pies were great and the chicken pot pie is one of the best you will ever have. They are closed on mondays but other than great place

Buckeye pie is to die for - must try. If you are going to try to get their pies around the holidays, make sure you go early as the line is outside the building!

I visited this bakery three times because of the great reviews. I really enjoyed the buckeye pie and french silk pie more than the fruit pies. On the second and third visit I noticed that the crust was a tad salty. A little salty crust on a savory pie I can deal with, but not on a sweet pie. Also, I was looking forward to trying the key lime pie, but I was very disappointed (glad I only purchased the small). For me, this pie really did not have a good flavor--just a strong tartness. I have had better key lime pie from other bakeries. I may make an occasional visit to Just Pies for the buckeye pie, but this will not be one of my favorite bakeries if the crust continues to be salty. Oh, I enjoyed the turkey pot pie . Excellent customer service, and bright and clean store.

Best pies in Columbus! Better than homemade! And way easier!!! The pumpkin pie is especially good.