Thin crust available upon request. Firm square cut with a thin chewy dough layer. #UpCloseSavor
Medium pep and cheese pizza !! Perfectly cooked :)
Exterior entrance and parking. #UpCloseSavor
two chairs in front of the counter
Excellent box kept my pizza hot after a 21min drive home. #UpCloseSavor
the american flag on the wall
First the pizza goes thru the conveyor oven, then into the deck oven to crisp & brown. #UpCloseSavor
So glad we requested thin crust. Don't even need to try the regular rust. #UpCloseSavor
The business owner photo of the pepperoni pizza was legit. Our pizza looked the same. #UpCloseSavor
Pizza :)
Conveyor oven markings with that deck oven browning, and cheese char. #UpCloseSavor
pizza, food
All the Way pizza
food
food
food
menu
Ronda D.
Sep 15, 2024
Amazing pizza and sub! Very crispy . If you like thin crust this is the place for you. I found a replacement for Lil Siscilys :) they use lots of pepperonis on their pizza and don't skimp on the sauce . The sub was HUGE and so flavorful. The Lakehouse sub is the way to go. Friendly service and very clean place ! If you want to dine in there is a small dining area . Will be a repeat customer for sure !
Read More
Amanda K.
Jul 18, 2024
This is my fave pizza around! I am in Johnstown and of course we have many options but I prefer driving the extra few min to Alexandria for this delicious pizza! Also don't sleep on the ice cream place next door by the same owner! Sooo good!
Read More
Erich D.
Nov 22, 2024
HORRIBLE pizza. The sauce is ketchup, the dough is HORRIBLE. ...taste like play dough. The cheese is like wax. F-....and WAY OVERPRICED. $13.95 for a all pizza...RIDICULOUS. F-
Read More
Tony F.
May 24, 2024
Really good tavern cut style pizza with generous toppings. Give it a try and you won't be disappointed.
Read More
Ben P.
May 5, 2023
I have enjoyed everything on the menu! Usually gets done really quick, and you can pick it up, get it delivered or eat inside.
Read More
Margo W.
Nov 21, 2022
This pizza parlor is located in the old Drummies location. The restaurant is clean and the staff is friendly. I ordered an "All the Way"pizza. It was excellent! The toppings were plentiful and bottom of the pizza had a little crunch to it. As I am fan big fan of pepperoni pizza as well, I will be ordering a pepperoni next time. I highly recommend trying this place.
Read More
Courtney F.
Jan 10, 2025
Pizza is really good, especially for a small town spot! I've only tried the pepperoni and cheese but It's a great crispy texture and good ratio of ingredients. The sauce is slightly sweeter which isn't my preferred flavor but overall it's definitely very good!
Read More
Cheryl C.
Dec 9, 2024
DELICIOUS! We have wanted to try for sometime now...however, we live in Westerville. But today!! today! ~ after running errands and a grocery pick up in Heath... it timed out in our favor. XXL Pep and their 12" Lake House Laker Sub!Both were hot and fresh and they made it alll the way to Westerville without my usual complimentary corners for picking up dinner! True testament of how excited we were to try! We'll be back for sure!!!
Read More
Joshua S.
Oct 12, 2024
Waited 2 hours and 12 minutes for 2 large pizza. Was told multiple times "it's on its way". Tasted just like you'd imagine 2+ hour old pizza would!
Read More
Kris S.
Aug 27, 2023
In my opinion this is the best pizza around. We live in Johnstown and drive past several other pizza places to go here
Read More