Joey Fratello's Pizzeria
Joey Fratello's Pizzeria
Pepperoni & sausage personal pizza
Joeys Favorite Sub, with capicolla ham and Genoa salami
Menu as of 7/12/21
Menu as of 7/12/21
Mandarin Chicken Salad
Phenomenal supreme pizza!!!
a pizza in a box
Asiago chicken
a pizza in a box
Chocolate Chip Cannoli dessert pizza
pizza
a box of pizza
New York Calzone with ham
a pizza in a box
Calzone pepperoni cheese and mushrooms excellent
the kitchen
Best place to eat pizza in the town,period!!
pizza, food
White pizza with ricotta, pepperoni and garlic. Yum!
Steakburger sandwich and fries
Veggie Pizza
food, steak
Dan B.
Feb 23, 2025
The pizza and the service was great. My favorite pizza in Findlay. The fried ravioli was great as an appetizer.
Read More
Scott O.
Nov 12, 2023
We had friends and family over and got takeout. Three pizzas and a couple breadstick orders. Everyone agreed it was awesome. This is the go to place in Findlay for pizza.Always enjoy this when we're in town. Mom's favorite.
Read More
Catherine M.
Jul 21, 2024
Driving through town, used Google to find a pizza place nearby. Joey Fratello's came up with good reviews. A couple of turns later, we parked in front of an unassuming joint. We were the only customers on a lazy Sunday afternoon. The pizza was excellent! We ordered three pies and everyone devoured them! Plenty of topping to choose from and unique specialty options as well. Would be good for takeout too. Customer service was great.
Read More
Matt U.
Aug 19, 2024
Best pizza I've had in years! Super tasty and a perfect crust! Good bread sticks, excellent deep fried ravioli! The drinks could use an upgrade from Pepsi bottles to fountain Coca Cola (I didn't knock down on stars because some people prefer Pepsi, just not me) Bar stool pizza reviews should do this place! It would be 8 or higher, two factors: crust sauce and cheese plus price! Cool little funky old school aroma and fast service. Price is why I would go every time I would be near this place!! Great job, better pizza!!
Read More
Lexi M.
Sep 30, 2020
Wow!Now this is a great pizza joint. Their supreme pizza is out of this world. They have amazing lunch specials and some meat packed salads too. Their pizza is a perfect medium crust. Not too big and not cracker pizza which is what I love about their pizza. But if you're looking for a protein packed salad this is the place.
Read More
Bill P.
Apr 29, 2023
Pizza is good overall. I like the style of pizza, but not a huge fan of the pizza sauce, as it is pretty acidic and the flavor doesn't have much depth to it. Their wings though are really good! Highly recommend the wings!
Read More
Milan L.
Feb 15, 2025
Joeys is not great for ambience but has great pizza!! I've take guests with me and all rave about it!The only downside is parking. That can be an issue.
Read More
David M.
Jun 5, 2024
Long-time occasional customer. Used to stop in once a week in their early days when I worked downtown. Mainly carry out a few times a year now. Food quality has been consistently good over the years. Menu has been amazingly stable (which shows they have the sense to recognize success and not mess with it in an often futile attempt to chase trends.) I have never had a service issue, whether in-store, carry-out or delivery. Pricing is reasonable relative to the competition. Availability of nearby parking is inconsistent and can present a problem if you plan to drive there with intention of a quick bite or carry out experience.
Read More
Deron M.
Aug 30, 2023
Best pizza in town but I feel that you really should eat it there while it's fresh outta the oven. Those guys in the kitchen are HUSTLING! Still service with a smile.
Read More
Lara G.
Nov 5, 2022
Walked by this pizza place yesterday and it smelled heavenly so of course I had to get that pizza tonight.We ordered an 8" Greek and a 12" classic combo. Pizza isn't bad but it's not great either, just ok. The Greek was decent but the classic was slightly underdone.I will say, the service is excellent. Even though they were all hustling they were still very polite and helpful. Well done to the staff.
Read More
