Joe and Mimi's Pizzeria

This place has good pizza but they seem to make up the hours they want to be open. Tried calling tonight an hour and a half before their posted closing time only to be met with a constant busy signal which has happened numerous times in the past. We decided to drive over to order because we thought phone lines might be screwed up. We arrived at 8pm only to see employees mopping the floor and closed sign was posted. Again we have driven there before when they are supposed to be open only to find this place closed. Don't post hours if you're not going to ever be open. Don't waste your time trying to do business there.

NY Style pizza. It was pretty good. It deserves more like a 3.5/5.0, but not quite a 4.0. If they cooked the bottom of the pizza more, it would be better. This place is worth trying and would be willing to give them another try in future. Their prices online are outdated - is much more expensive than advertised online.

Awesome... I was a little concerned because their dinning room only had 3 tables in it and it was a little off the beaten path. I was truly surprised at how good the food was. We started out with the antipasto salad which was great (it was kind of a shame I did not get a pic of it because it looked as good as it tasted). The wifie had their Italian sub which was AWESOME. I had the pizza rollover or something like that which was a meat filled stromboli which was AWESOME. I am excited about stopping back to try the pizza. I strongly recommend that you stop in if you are in Granville and hungry. The owner was super nice and provided great service. Yes this is a 5 star review of a take out pizza shop with only 3 tables inside but it is that good.

My opinion is pizza is always better when you can dine in and have it fresh. We looked at Elms pizza (closed on Sunday) we saw DeFelice said dine in so we headed that way, NOPE no dine in it just "says that online" lol. Same with Joe and Mimi's it says dine in but she told us it is not, they are to small but did offer us a old table on the patio and we took her up on it. Wasn't to friendly but wasn't mean, almost like the offer was expected to be declined then was shocked we said yes. We ordered two 12 inch pies and spaghetti w/ a meat ball. My daughter (7 years old) said the spaghetti was good, needed more sauce. The pizza is also good, nothing out of the ordinary but good. Served in slices and says "New York style". The appearance was like a Pizza Hut BUT the crust actually held up and had a little crunch which was a pleasant surprise. Over all, decent spot that is close to us so that is a plus.

Wow! We recently moved to Granville and have been trying out some of the pizza places. We thoroughly enjoyed our large pepperoni, onion, tomato and hot pepper pizza! They are not lying when they say it is New York pizza - it is!! Really authentic and so delicious. Highly recommend!We picked it up and placed it in a 350 degree confection oven for 5 minutes and it was perfect.We also had 2 side salads with fresh cut greens and just real veggies - no cheese or croutons

They were not very friendly and just to busy to explain to a new customer the way they operate. It's hit it miss if they are open and you have to order ahead of time or wait for them to cook a pizza for 30 min in which they discourage you to do so. So i opted yo try a salad and they were very sparse with nothing but lettuce. Not a good experience for my first time there. Decide to walk out with nothing

The best NY style pies in the area .Excellent service ,very friendly staff and owners.

Amazing pizza! Service is great! Take out only. New York style. Make sure you order ahead. Check hours not open every day! Great people!

Food was very good, fresh and prepared well. It was just ridiculously expensive. And don't rely on the menu thats posted on Yelp, its way out of date, at least the prices shown are. Will probably try it again but not in a hurry.

Pizza good. The family loves it. Owner never has been nice to me. Gruff. Not sure why. I am respectful to everyone. I order and my husband picks it up so I don't have to feel bad over and over again. Stars are based on pizza minus a star for the customer service.