Jay's Crab Boil & Oyster Bar

Pleasantly surprised! We will definitely be retuning and brining people with us next time. Really good service and delicious food. Sushi was fresh, ramen was hot and tasty, appetizers were good, seafood boil was perfect. I have no complaints at all. Nice inside with friendly staff.

Ugh! I really wanted to like this place! While the food was good, the cleanliness and service were not good. Likes: - The space - the restaurant is extremely spacious and decorated nicely. - The food was good for the most part. I ordered two speciality sushi rolls and while they tasted fairly good - they were overly sauced (drowning out the flavors of the rolls). My friend ordered the walleye and really enjoyed it. Dislikes: - There were gnats swarming around our food the entire time. One ended actually up in the sauce of one of my sushi rolls (insert gag face). - Our waitress (while super kind) kept digging at her short shorts (digging in her behind) while taking our orders, delivering our drinks, and delivering our food. She also only stopped by our table during those times plus to give us our bill. The other times, she was at the bar chatting with the bartenders.If the cleanliness and service were to improve, I would like to stop by again, but for a seafood boil the next time!

Lobster Bisque did not meet my expectations. I had to send it back The lobster roll, unfortunately, did not contain substantial pieces of lobster. The sandwich, as a result, was somewhat disappointing.I would hesitate to recommend it.Lobster Seafood Cheese Rangoon (6) $7.95Lobster Bisque $6.95

We came for lunch, 30 minutes after they opened. No other customers there. Ooh-ohh. Bad sign. For sure.First noticed sticky, dirty floor when led to our booth. Our orders were taken fairly quickly and the food came out timely. We were excited as there was plenty of food on our plates. That feeling changed after the first bite. My fried oysters basket was a fail. i don't know why I would expect fresh oysters from seafood restaurant in mid summer in mid America. Silly me. The oysters tasted like they were CANNED. The sweet potato waffled fries were COLD. The slaw was average. The second order of fried walleye was better and was a "good buy" for a small eater. Substituted salad for fries cost $3. The salad was PLAIN with almost no veggies. After the server brought us our food she never came back to our table. Probably afraid to ask us if everything was OK. Finally another person came to bring our bill.This was our first time here and definitely the last.

10/10 Best crab boil i've been to. The atmosphere is great, the servers are the sweetest and the food is amazing! 10/10 will recommend

My husband wanted "all- you- can- eat" crab for his birthday, and this is one of the few places in town that offers it. Now, when I initially looked up the restaurant, it said that the "All- you- can- eat" deal was just a special that they had going on at the time. But I called the restaurant and they said that even though the dates on the flyer I'd seen had passed, they would still have the deal. My guess is that they probably do it all the time. So anyway, the cost is $53.75 per person, and that gives you crab, sushi, hibachi, and more. That is an amazing deal if you ask me, because the crab alone should be worth that price. The way it works, everyone at your table has to get the "all- you- can- eat" special. You get three items at a time that they will bring out to you. I got two different sushi rolls, and some crab rangoon. When you finish with those three items from round 1, they'll start you on round 2, and you can go as many rounds as you want, with a 2 hr seating limit. But let me tell you, by the time we were done with round 1.5, we were DONEZO. Supa dupa full. To me, for all you can eat crab, this restaurant is a no-brainer!

Located in a strip mall, I was pleasantly surprised at the interior of this restaurant. The room was very large and inviting with a huge bar, around 20 TVs, and a live seafood tank.Coming on a Friday just before the lunch specials were to end, I was handed a humongous menu with pages and pages of offerings. I finally found the lunch specials, but choked on the pricey choices: $18, $25, and something else in the $30's range.I ordered the fried clam strips basket with sweet potato waffle fries: $12.95. My server, Allie was attentive, even bringing me a water with lemon while I took a peek at the fish tanks. Allie also brought me some containers of tarter sauce for the clams and ketchup for the fries, and a little something else: warm caramel sauce which she recommended that it goes well with the sweet potatoes. Yes! It was good!My meal was more than enough, and I took home what would turn out to be another meal, so yay!

My best friend and i came here on valentine's day. They were so slow to seat us and let a huge group of people wait at the door for over 40 mins without asking them to be put on the waitlist. We finally get seated and we order and I specifically asked the waitress how long our food would take since we had been there for so long already. She said "it won't take long" we subsequently waited for an additional 40 mins for our food once ordered, including the appetizer. And the food was very regular. Hope they do better.

We have been here a dozen or so times and it is amazing every time. The boils are the best, Jays Special Blend is top notch. Crab legs are perfect every time. If you are looking for good seafood, this is the place.

The seafood boil was best I've had here in Columbus! Our server was great at offering suggestions on menu items. The food was served super quick. I will be going back!!!