Time Square Pizza
The Algonquin (White Pizza)
Photo Credit- 614 Magazine
a closeup of the pizza
Photo Credit 614 Magazine
Bodega (Buffalo Chicken Pizza)
Dining room
42nd Street Pizza (Pepperoni)
the neon sign
food, dessert
Bridge and Tunnel (VIP Combo Pizza)
42nd St - 14" pepperoni pizza, with 6 large slices
DJ and raucous
Bar
Top line photo
Draft beer
bbq chicken, chicken, poultry, bbq wings, chicken wings, fried chicken wings, fried chicken, chicken wings and fried chicken, food
Ice cold soda in a chilled glass - thank you, Ivan Kane
Yummy!
42nd St Pizza
Back stage area
House Salad - we split it, making two side salads
Joseph S.
Sep 21, 2024
Had a blast last night. Sorry I didn't take any photos, but I didn't know the rules, even though I saw people taking pictures, this was my first time ever in a place like this. Great staff, and the show was a blast, too. Would love to come back again and stay longer.
Read MoreAja H.
Feb 23, 2025
Number #1 we paid for a table ($15/person) and was not told how to acquire it, so we ended up standing on the side. Will definitely be reaching out about our refund! Okay first this does not reflect the working girls and bouncers in the place, because they are just working. But it is a hard pass for me. NYC focused place, as a former New Yorker it is more like seedy 70s -80s NYC when strip clubs and pimps ran Times Square. Two entrances, no direction, long ass confusing line where you are mixed with bachelorette parties, moms gone wild, backwoods frequents, college girls, pre-strip club goers, and mixed couples that need a darker lighted environment to hang out in this lovely city (meh). The confusion of the drunk group in front of us - who ran into two doors before finding the real door for the event, and even asked the coat rack/cashier to 'hold their pizza' in the back while they partied?!?! may have been a reason we were not told how to get our table or who to go to for it. But guess what happened as we stood among the 'masses'? Someone's drunk mom with the bad Kate plus eight haircut still tried to feel up my date. Her inbred son/husband (?) attempted to hi-five him several times because he was with me...this was before he feel into the table sign on the wall and almost belly flopped some folks. And the carhatt wearing girl crew with them was trying to 'buy him a drink' as a sorry offering. I had to separate them by standing right by the drunk chicks who kept wasting drinks on the stage and focused on our fun instead of having their own. I worked the room giving them a show by having the working girls come through to dance in front of them, giving the attention apparently their families and lovers did not. Can we say 'pick me'? Why else were they acting up? The working girls, table girls, bouncers have their work cut out for them with this hodge podge of folks that shows up and shows their butts in the worse way. I thanked them for their service. You have to remember that Easton and nearby Gahanna were FARMLAND not too long ago and those folks have not left luv. Besides nearly SA the working girls by drunkingly pulling on their briefs and bikini tops (this was the drunk women by me!!!!), the workers are seeing what you get when you mix 'Hard Seltzers, greasy pizza, house well liquor, jello shots, despair, insecurities, unaccomplished dreams, and the need to be seen by awkwardly dancing on each other, in the air, and being proud they memorized hip hop top 40' with receding hair lines. It is a sight to see that I can't erase. VIP or bust with this indeed. Oh and top shelf liqour drinks are $12 and up same price as Denmark or other mixology places here so...pick your poison.
Read MoreJacob S.
Sep 13, 2024
This review pertains to the burlesque show and not the pizzeria. The show was great, cool entrance to the speakeasy, great live entertainment. complementary drink as you enter. Space is at a premium, seating is tight. decently laid out stage with plenty of room for performers to interact. They have created a really neat vibe that fits with the theme of the event.
Read MoreAubrie H.
Sep 6, 2024
Stopped by during happy hour on Thursday and wow. The slices are $2 off making them around $5 each and they are pretty good sized. We tried the pepperoni, cheese, veggie and hawaiian slices. The pepperoni was our least favorite but partially because the others were just so much better. Nice thin crust , cooked well with good flavors. Beers, wines and non speciality cocktails are half off. Those prices are a great deal. We will have to visit again when the Speakeasy is open.
Read MoreDanielle M.
Jun 9, 2024
Had a FANTASTIC experience last night at Ivan Kane's Forty Deuce at the Burlesque Supper Club. It is $65 for a shot upon entrance, two course dinner, bottle of wine/champagne or liquor (it depends on how many people at your table), the burlesque show and entrance back to the nightclub. For dinner, we all got Braised Short Ribs with a red wine Demi- Glacé and Parmesan Risotto served with a Caesar salad. The food was very good but the portions were very small and not very filling which was very disappointing due to how much liquor was drank. There should have been an alternative menu where we could order additional appetizers or more food as it was not enough. For dessert, they served homemade cinnamon knots with homemade icing. They were good but cold. Let's get into the service, it was stellar!! Our waitress, Chloe was AMAZING! She was very helpful and present with our table of 9 bachelorette party. We got Tito's and a whole lot of mixers. Everything we asked for, she was able to get quickly. The best part was that she came over and asked if we needed our drinks topped off. Great service. I was so impressed. Let's get into the show, it was so fun but was a little disappointing that there was only three performers. I wish there were more people in the show. The performances were amazing and so fun. The performers were interactive and fun. I definitely would come back for the show. If I came back, I'd come for the show not the dinner. There is an Supper Club general admission and that would be my go to or do the drink package.
Read MoreJeff R.
Dec 1, 2023
I was a little confused by Fort Deuce's decision to change get rid of their Instagram worthy Milkshakes and entire food menu to replace it with a pizzeria. I decide to give it a shot and try out their pizza offerings. I ordered 2 slices. One was the 42nd St. and the other was the Fuhgeddaboudit!. The 42nd St is what they call their classic pepperoni. The slice was good. Nothing remarkable. I could see eating it again, but wouldn't be my first choice. The 2nd slice, the Fuhgeddaboudit!, was definitely my favorite of the 2. It came topped with pepperoni, sausage, meatball, Canadian bacon, salami, mozzarella, tomato sauce. I didn't think there was anything special about most of the toppings, however the meatballs and sausage were excellent. Definitely getting a pie with just those next time.Also, bring back the milkshakes.
Read MoreTyler J.
May 31, 2024
Absolutely amazing! NY style pizza and the cheesy bread is off the chart. The ambience is great. The staff is absolutely hands-down. Amazing. They have burlesque dancing upstairs. I've never been, but I heard it's really good. Definitely a great place to grab a beer and a slice of pie.
Read MoreAubrey L.
May 3, 2023
I came for the 9:30pm show last Friday. We paid for the VIP table but sat downstairs for pizza before the doors opened. We got the white pizza and it was very good and only $12! The staff was really nice and helpful and answered my many questions lol! The downstairs area is so fun and swanky! I loved the vibes and everyone in there was just having a great time but it was not crazy like a normal bar which I appreciated.Entering the speakeasy was definitely fun! You enter through the kitchen freezer door and then go up stairs to the club portion. We had a nice table at the front and bottle service. Our server was Melanie and she was awesome! So sweet and so nice! The show itself was mildly disappointing but still very fun. It seemed more like an upscale strip club when I went. The music was kinda sucky since it was old music that played at my High School Prom. The dancers were still really cool and they walked around the stage behind us and did some moves. I was later told that the 7:30pm show is the one that is a legitimate burlesque show, which is what we thought we were going to see. I will be back to check out the 7:30 show!
Read MoreDave S.
May 24, 2024
Well they are open quite late which is nice when you want pizza and everything else is closed. A friend of mine and I decided to split a medium sized vegan pizza and thought it would not be expensive all pizza's were on a half off sale that night. The crust was very thin, there weren't a lot of toppings nor were there a lot of cheese or pizza sauce AND the waiter refused to give us the half off price special rate so we paid a good bit of money for an inferior pizza. I guess when they are the only shop around that's still open they get to charge whatever they want because of the late night service.
Read MoreJenny Z.
Apr 7, 2023
This was my first time spending a weekend evening at Easton. It ended up being one my favorite Friday nights in cbus so far, spent with good friends. All of the food we ordered was great... not one thing we disliked. The Fuhgeddaboudit pizza is a meat lover's dream and has a kick to it. The white pizza featured ricotta dollops of perfection. If you like your chocolate chip cookie with a little sea salt, you must try theirs. We got lucky and somehow snagged a table to that night's burlesque show due to a last minute cancelation. Incredible. A night of pizza, fun vibes AND an unexpected show. Can't wait to return for another show! Adrian, Chloe and IVAN KANE (!) were amazing and treated us like family. Exceptional service.
Read More