Incredible Pizza Co

Just got my steak subs and they great. The driver was very nice and my food was delivered extremely fast. Thank you. This was my first time ordering and I will order again.

Holy cow. I really appreciate your being open late on a Sunday AND for a long delivery drive but, guys, your food is really bad. I ordered a medium pizza with sausage, onion and banana peppers and the steak sub and both were extremely bland. The pizza was WAY undersauced and the sub was dripping in some gross white stuff. Both items were also completely unseasoned. There was nothing incredible about this order other than your delivery driver who made the trek for me.

This pizza was excellent! I tried the new, Old World Pepperoni they just started selling and it was awesome! So glad I did and thank you to the owner for recommending it. It beats a cracker crust any day of the week. Oh, And now they have a garlic dipping sauce too, and believe me, it is very, very good! My kids are hooked on it..haha. I will definitely be back again soon!!

I'm shocked I gave them a Second chance and my food actually came this time I'm actually shocked thank you

The results are in!? Its open at 4am in a really small town and the food is GREAT! $20 I fed 6 drunk men and we were stuffed!!! Thanks to the MGR Bejoren ??? Thanks for the Great Service!!!! It sucks that you were going thru the driver issue if i ever lose my job i will hit you guys up, Thank You!!

Even if they get your order wrong and try to make you pay once upon ordering and then again before they'll hand over your food, acting like you're the jerk, at least you got to enjoy the worst pizza and and apps you've ever had, right?!? AVOID.

I've been ordering from Incredibles Pizza now going on six years. And I must say that in those six years I've watched this company grow into a incredible place to eat. I first found incredible pizza on morning after working third shift , it was around 2 am and everything was closed but not incredible pizza they where open until 4am. During those first few years I was working third shift and eating alot of incredible pizza and subs.. Today I'm working normal hours but still find myself wanting incredibles pizza and subs. I usually order from them at least three or four times a month. The food is great and the service is outstanding. I recommend there baked ziti and a side salad.

I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and they lied and said that the delivery guy was at my door. That was a complete lie cause I was sitting next to my front door and they never showed up! Then when I called them back and talked to one of the managers she was rude and said she was red flagging me cause I told her what I was told from the guy that I spoke to before. I never did get my pizza I ordered. I think it is very unfair of them to lie and never delivered my food. Then when I point it out to them they want to red flag me.

Food isn't bad, and they're the only spot in town open late. But half of their employees are rude assh*les, and about 60% of the time your food will never even show up! Nor will they call about any items out of stock or even just tell you they can't deliver your food. Oh and if you call regarding anything be prepared to hear people in the background hollering talking sh!t about you!Who even owns this place? They need serious restructuring, and new management. Unless they're proud to be Classic Newark White Trash?

I'm happy to give this pizza place a 5 star. They deserve it. Someone took the worst pizza and subs. And somehow turned it all around. And I mean turned it around. So it went from the worst food in town to the best food in town. And that to me took a lot of work. If you haven't had a incredible pizza lately, you definitely need to check it out. You won't be disappointed.