Granato's Pizza

Awesome Pizza Excellent People A must have wherever we get back to T-County! Just make sure to check hours but you will not regret this pizza one bit.

Amazing Pizza, would definitely go back. Workers are so polite. Just wish they took card also

Just discovered Granatos even though we live just down the street... I love the sauce and the cheese sticks are very good! Since Rogies is no longer around, this is probably my favorite (along with Park Street). However, they don't accept card (which in this age is a regular cost of doing business, I cant imagine their profit margin is so little that they can't afford 2.4%) which often means I'm ordering Papa John's since then I don't have to drive to the bank first. Also, every time I've called and stopped in they are unfriendly. If they improved their customer service and accepted cards they could be 5 star.

Large pickup is $9.00, sauce is sweet and the crust is really good. Since the son took over I think it's gotten better. The also have a thick crust that is really good too

Sweet sauce, great service, and has been a family favorite for years. Glad to see on the ownership change it stayed in the family. We love the pizza and I'm a fan of the deep dish also.

My favorite pizza so far in the area. We've been here two years and finally found this place. Closest to my favorite pizza back home.

My go-to for pizza. I can always rely on the workers to give an accurate time estimate and my food to be correct. Hits every time

Granato's has been around for as long as I can remember and I have been enjoying the pizza since I was in grade school. As long as you are willing to pick up the pizza yourself you will not be disappointed.The pizza is modestly-priced as is expected for a small, family-owned business but it is well worth the price. A large, one-topping pizza for pickup is only $8.99 if I remember correctly. This is not that far off from what it was 15 years ago.The sauce is slightly sweet and the crust is fantastic as well. They are both very good complements of one another.There are other items on the menu but I will always be going back for the pizza (both regular and deep dish) as well as the cheese sticks. My mouth is watering just thinking about it right now.All in all this is the best pizza I have ever had and I will constantly make the trip back to New Philadelphia if I ever move out of the area just for this pizza.

I was pretty excited to try this because I know it has been around the area for awhile so I kind of compared it to the likes of mary zifers, pangrazio's and penso's... all of which are deliciously awesome in their own right. So I thought I would give this a try even though the reviews were mixed, and I was super disappointed. There are a couple of good things and the first being, that they are reasonably priced. I got a pretty good amount of food for the price. That was the best thing about it. Some of the downsides are that they ONLY take cash, and they don't deliver, and you apparently get what you pay for! I'll just be forward about this... the pizza sucked. It was awful. I think the crust is what ruined it. I don't know whether they make their own, but it certainly had the taste, look and feel of frozen dough. I would compare it to buying pizza at a gas station. If you have ever been in a speedway where they have the pizza sitting in the warmer by the counter, that's what this reminded me of, except If I remember I think I had the pizza from speedway once or twice and I would actually say it was better. Seriously. It was not good. The sauce was sweet, which I really don't mind, and I think they could have cooked the pizza longer. Everything about it, to me, was cheap. I guess you get what you pay for there. The wings were ok, if you prefer a wing that has no texture. These were kind of sickening because they were mushy. They had no crunch to them at all, just soft and mushy. The sub sandwich would be the ONLY thing I would ever order again from this place. It was pretty good. I will not purposely order pizza from this place again, it was very disappointing.